- Subjects
- English A Lang & Lit
- 7 Global issues
- 7.3 Politics, power and justice
7.3 Politics, power and justice
How to narrow the field of politics, power and justice to a specific global issue, and see it at work in a courtroom speech, a play, a statement to Washington and a cartoon.
- IB English A: Language and Literature
- Part of 7 Global issues
- SL and HL
Notes on 7.3 Politics, power and justice
The field of politics, power and justice gathers the questions societies ask about who holds power, how it is used and checked, and what a just order requires. Its issues are often argued in courts, parliaments and streets, and texts take part in those arguments. In March 1922 M. K. Gandhi was tried in Ahmedabad, in British India, for sedition in articles he had published. Before reading his written statement he spoke to the court, and an American weekly printed his words:
What the field covers
Gandhi’s remarks set two authorities against each other. He accepts that his campaign is “in law … a deliberate crime”, and in the same sentence calls it “the highest duty of a citizen” (paragraph 2). The law and his conscience give opposite verdicts on one act, and he asks the court to choose between them. The judge, he says, must either resign or impose “the severest penalty”, so the court itself is drawn into the argument.
The field covers everything such a conflict touches: rights and responsibilities, how governments, courts and other institutions work, who sits where in a hierarchy, how wealth and power are shared, the limits of the law, inequality, and conflict and peace. The concept pages on perspective and representation describe how texts position their readers and picture others; this field asks how those choices bear on power. A text from the field usually shows power at work in one room, as Gandhi’s does in a courtroom.
The act Gandhi defends has a name. Openly breaking a law judged unjust, without violence, and accepting the penalty in order to change the law or the public’s view of it is civil disobedience. The idea is old, and Henry David Thoreau’s essay of 1849, later printed as “Civil Disobedience”, gave it its English name. Gandhi’s words show its two halves: “I do not ask for mercy” (paragraph 2) refuses the law’s authority over his conscience, and his request for “the highest penalty” accepts its authority over his body.
The limit Gandhi names himself
The remarks do not present civil disobedience as simple. Gandhi opens by refusing to “dissociate myself from the diabolical crimes of Chauri-Chaura or the mad outrages of Bombay” (paragraph 1). In February 1922 a crowd at Chauri Chaura had set fire to a police station and killed more than twenty policemen, and Gandhi had halted his campaign in response. A nonviolent campaign can be followed by violence it did not intend, and the question of who answers for that violence is part of the issue. Gandhi answers that he does, “I knew that I was playing with fire” (paragraph 1), and the court sentenced him to six years in prison.
Who the law hears
Power is easiest to see in who speaks with authority, who speaks without it, and who is only spoken about. Susan Glaspell’s one-act play Trifles (1916) is set in the kitchen of a farmhouse where a man has been strangled. The county attorney and the sheriff search the house for evidence against his wife, who is held in jail, and bring two women to collect her things. As the men go upstairs, they assign the women a part in the investigation:
SHERIFF: I suppose anything Mrs. Peters does’ll be all right. She was to take in some clothes for her, you know, and a few little things. We left in such a hurry yesterday.
COUNTY ATTORNEY: Yes, but I would like to see what you take, Mrs. Peters, and keep an eye out for anything that might be of use to us.
MRS. PETERS: Yes, Mr. Henderson. (The women listen to the men’s steps on the stairs, then look about the kitchen)Trifles, lines 47–49
The attorney enlists Mrs. Peters as the law’s eyes, “of use to us” (line 48), but not as its judge. She may look, and the men will decide what her looking is worth. Her whole reply, “Yes, Mr. Henderson” (line 49), is three words of assent. The accused woman never appears at all: Mrs. Wright is talked about throughout the play and is never heard.
The women do not simply obey. Left alone, Mrs. Hale says she would hate to have men “snooping round and criticizing” in her own kitchen (line 50), and Mrs. Peters answers with the law’s own view:
MRS. PETERS: Of course it’s no more than their duty.
Trifles, line 51
Mrs. Peters defends a system that has just told her to watch and keep quiet, and she does it in the language of common sense: “Of course”. Nobody has forced her to; the men are upstairs. Power that works through consent of this kind, because the dominant group’s view has come to seem natural even to those it disadvantages, is called hegemony. The term comes from the Italian political thinker Antonio Gramsci, writing in prison in the 1930s, and it explains why the play’s most important change is a change in what Mrs. Peters takes for granted.
The diagram sorts the people in Trifles and in Frederick Douglass’s Fourth of July oration of 1852 by their relation to power. In both texts the person most affected by the law is absent and silent: Mrs. Wright in her cell, and “the American slave”, whom Douglass names in the third person (paragraph 5) while he speaks to free listeners as “you”. The comparison suggests a question that the field often turns on: what kind of justice is possible for people who are discussed but not heard?


From field to issue, step by step
The question the diagram raises can be narrowed into an issue and tested. The worked example uses Trifles as its literary work and, as its body of work, the statements of Chief Joseph of the Nez Perce, who spoke for his people in Washington in 1879 after their forced removal. Joseph spoke through an interpreter, whom he mentions, and his words reached print through a magazine that framed them with a bishop’s introduction. The close of his statement in The North American Review asks for one thing:
We only ask an even chance to live as other men live. We ask to be recognized as men. We ask that the same law shall work alike on all men. If the Indian breaks the law, punish him by the law. If the white man breaks the law, punish him also.
Chief Joseph, “An Indian’s Views of Indian Affairs” (1879), paragraph 3
The demand is not for a new law but for the same law, applied evenly. The repeated “We ask” builds a list of requests so modest that refusing them exposes the injustice, and the two final sentences mirror each other exactly, as the law should. The statement accepts the law’s authority and asks only to be within it, which is why its quietness is so pointed.
In this case the tests did not reshape the issue much, but they showed that it has two sides, and that each work presents one of them. That discovery is worth as much as a revision: an oral built on this pair can move from exclusion that is accepted, in Mrs. Peters’s “Of course”, to exclusion that is named and refused.
Five more issues from the field
Each issue that follows is phrased as a question that societies argue about, with a literary work and a non-literary body of work that present it. The pairs show the kind of match that works; an oral uses works studied in class, and the same issue can be found in many others.
When breaking a law is right
Every state asks for obedience, and every age has people who refuse it on grounds of conscience. The issue asks when, if ever, a citizen is right to break a law. Sophocles’ Antigone, first performed in Athens in the fifth century BCE, presents it as a tragedy: Antigone buries her brother against the king’s decree and dies for it, and the king loses his family. Gandhi’s trial remarks belong to a larger body of work, his speeches and the articles in his weekly paper, that present the same question as a public program. The play shows the cost of conscience, and the speeches argue for paying it.
Whose freedom a nation celebrates
Nations celebrate the freedoms named in their founding documents, and the issue asks whom those freedoms include. Douglass, invited to speak in Rochester, New York, the day after the national holiday, holds his audience to their own words:
Would you have me argue that man is entitled to liberty? that he is the rightful owner of his own body? You have already declared it.
Douglass, Fourth of July oration, paragraph 1
The two questions sound like the opening of a debate, and the short sentence that follows ends it. “You have already declared it” turns the Declaration of Independence into evidence against the people celebrating it, so the speech needs no new principle, only the nation’s own. Douglass’s speeches and writings over half a century form a body of work on this issue. Langston Hughes’s poem “Let America Be America Again” (1936) presents it from inside, through a speaker who answers each praise of the American promise by recalling that it was never kept for him.
Messages from the state
Every government speaks to its citizens, and the issue asks where informing them ends and managing them begins. Communication designed to spread a belief or win support for a cause, usually by selecting what it shows and appealing to feeling, is propaganda. The word comes from a committee of the Catholic Church founded in 1622 to spread the faith, and it was neutral for centuries before it became an accusation.
George Orwell’s Animal Farm (1945) presents the issue as a fable: the pigs who rule the farm quietly rewrite the commandments painted on the barn wall until the last of them declares some animals “more equal” than others. The posters and pamphlets of the United States Committee on Public Information, which ran the country’s publicity during the First World War from 1917, form a body of work that shows a democracy doing the same work openly.
Watching the citizen
States watch their citizens to protect them, and the issue asks how much watching a free society should accept. Orwell’s Nineteen Eighty-Four (1949) presents surveillance as total: screens in every room that watch as well as broadcast, and posters warning that Big Brother is watching. A non-literary body of work presents the same question in the language of reporting. In 2013 The Guardian and The Washington Post published a series of reports on government surveillance programs, based on documents taken by a contractor, Edward Snowden. The two papers shared a Pulitzer Prize for the work in 2014. The governments concerned argued that the programs prevented attacks, and the reports argued that they went beyond what citizens had agreed to.
The press and power
A free press is meant to hold power to account, and the issue asks what happens when the press is itself part of the power it reports. Henrik Ibsen’s play An Enemy of the People (1882) presents a town newspaper that supports a doctor’s report on the poisoned baths until the town’s money turns against him. Thomas Nast’s cartoons in Harper’s Weekly against the politicians who ran New York City through Tammany Hall present the opposite case, a press that helped bring a corrupt group down. One of them shows the group’s leader, William M. Tweed:

The cartoon draws a heavy, prosperous body in a good suit, hands thrust into its pockets, and in place of a face a sack of money marked with a dollar sign. The caption calls this figure the “Brains” behind a political victory, in quotation marks that make the word sneer. No speech balloon or argument is needed; the image states that the man thinks with money. The ring’s power collapsed within months, and Tweed was later convicted.
The cartoons were as one-sided as any wartime poster, and their target was guilty. Whether they count as propaganda depends on whether the word describes a method or condemns a purpose, which is itself part of the issue. In 1950 the cartoonist Herbert Block, drawing for The Washington Post, helped make the word McCarthyism current, and his cartoons are a later body of work on the same question.
Try it
Why might Nast have set the word “Brains” in quotation marks in the caption, when the image has already replaced the man’s head with a money bag?
The quotation marks make the caption speak in someone else’s voice, as if repeating the praise of Tweed’s supporters, and so turn the praise into mockery. Image and caption then work as a pair: the picture shows what is inside the head, and the caption quotes what his allies claim is there. The gap between the two is the cartoon’s argument about power and money.
How an issue goes wrong
Issues from this field fail in the usual four ways. Power and injustice are field words, too broad to direct a talk. Why the sheriff calls the kitchen “Nothing here but kitchen things” (line 26) is a question about one line of one play, too narrow for two works. Courtrooms is a topic, a setting with no tension in it. And war is bad is a slogan: true for most listeners, and no use to an oral, because no text needs analyzing to prove it.
The slogan takes a subtler form in this field: the position. The law is unfair to women sounds like an issue, but it is a verdict that the oral would then have to prove. Trifles does not simply prove it; the play gives Mrs. Peters reasons to side with the law, and the audience watches her change. A question such as who does the law hear, and what is lost when it cannot hear someone? leaves room for that change, and for Joseph’s different answer.
The field also includes violence, and texts that present it need careful handling. Douglass’s list of the cruelties of slavery (paragraph 2) is a deliberate accumulation, and an analysis can explain how its length and its verbs work on an audience without repeating each cruelty for effect. The same restraint applies to a text about war, a massacre or a prison. A good analysis describes what the text does with its painful material, quotes only what the point needs, and keeps the people in it at the center rather than the shock.
Writing about it
The two openings that follow were planned for an oral on Trifles and Chief Joseph’s statements. The first argues a position; the second states the issue as a question and shows how each text presents it.
Weak: My global issue is that the justice system is unfair.note 1 In Trifles the men are sexist and in Joseph’s speech the Native Americans are treated badly, so both texts prove that justice is not equal.note 2
Strong: My issue is what happens to justice when the people a law judges cannot speak its language, literally or socially.note 3 Glaspell keeps the accused woman offstage and gives her case to two neighbors whose evidence the men dismiss as “trifles”note 4, while Joseph, speaking through an interpreter, asks only “that the same law shall work alike on all men”.note 5
A verdict, not an issue. The sentence states a conclusion the talk would have to prove, so the texts become evidence for a view.
Labels instead of analysis. “Sexist” and “treated badly” judge the content; neither names a choice either writer made.
The issue as a question. The wording covers both works and both senses of “language”, so the talk has one axis.
A choice of staging named. Keeping Mrs. Wright offstage is presented as Glaspell’s decision, which is what analysis needs.
A quotation that carries the issue. Joseph’s words show his position toward the law in his own phrasing, not the student’s.
The strong opening never says whether the law in either text is fair. It sets justice judged outside the law in one work beside justice asked for inside it in the other, and it leaves the judgment to the analysis that follows.
Applying it in the individual oral
In the individual oral the student speaks for about ten minutes on how a literary work and a non-literary body of work present one global issue, through an extract from each. The teacher’s questions follow for about five minutes. Extracts are usually around 40 lines, or one item or a short sequence from a body of work; check the exact rules with your teacher. The field of politics, power and justice gives an oral its axis when the issue asks who holds power and who is affected by it. Each extract can then be read for how it distributes voice, authority and silence.
A strong plan for Trifles and Joseph opens with the issue as a question. It reads lines 46–53 of the play for who gives orders and who answers, then turns to how the whole play moves judgment to the women. It reads paragraph 3 of Joseph’s statement for its repeated requests and mirrored sentences, then turns to the frame of interpreter and editor around all his statements. It closes on what each text suggests justice would need. The commonest way to lose marks in this field is to spend minutes on the history behind a text, the trial or the war, and too little on how the text itself presents it.
Power in a text is easier to analyze with the vocabulary of the concept pages on perspective and representation, and the text type pages on the manifesto and the speech read political texts closely. The Internal assessment pages on choosing a global issue and extracts turn a tested issue into a plan for the oral.
Self-check
- To do:
I can describe what the field of politics, power and justice covers.
- To do:
I can explain civil disobedience, hegemony and propaganda and find each at work in a text.
- To do:
I can show who holds authority, who speaks and who is only spoken about in a literary work and a non-literary text.
- To do:
I can narrow the field step by step to a specific issue and test it against two texts.
- To do:
I can state five issues from the field as questions, each with a literary work and a body of work.
- To do:
I can present violence and oppression in a text through what the text does, without sensationalism.
- To do:
I can keep context in the service of analysis when an oral turns to history.
Key terms
Each is also in the Global issues glossary for IB English A Lang & Lit, beside the other terms of its topic.
- Civil disobedience
The open and deliberate breaking of a law that a person judges unjust, done without violence and with acceptance of the legal penalty, in order to change the law or the public's view of it.
- Hegemony
Power that a dominant group holds through consent rather than force, because its values and ways of seeing come to seem like common sense even to those they disadvantage. The term is associated with the Italian political thinker Antonio Gramsci.
- Propaganda
Communication designed to spread a belief or win support for a cause, usually by a government, party or organization, and usually by selecting what it shows and appealing to feeling more than to evidence. Whether a text counts as propaganda is often argued, since the term judges its purpose as well as describing it.
Practice questions on 7.3 Politics, power and justice
Augment’s own questions, written in the style of IB exam papers. Here is how a few of them start.
Practice all 18 questions on 7.3 Politics, power and justice
Free with an account. Write your answer, open the markscheme beside it and mark yourself. Augment keeps the ones you got wrong for another go.
7.3 Politics, power and justice questions by paper, with 6 in full
More in 7 Global issues
The whole topic is on its own page.
- 7.1Culture, identity and community
- 7.2Beliefs, values and education
- 7.3Politics, power and justiceThis page
- 7.4Art, creativity and the imagination
- 7.5Science, technology and the environment
More IB English A Lang & Lit notes
- 7.2 Beliefs, values and educationBefore this in the syllabus.
- 7.4 Art, creativity and the imaginationNext in the syllabus.
- English A Lang & Lit exam formatEach English A Lang & Lit paper, how long it is and its share of the grade.
- IB English A Lang & LitThe English A Lang & Lit syllabus, how it is assessed and every notes page.
Carry on with 7.3 Politics, power and justice in Augment
With a free account, Augment remembers where you stopped in the notes and which questions you have marked.
