6 Global issues

What a global issue is, the five fields of inquiry and how an issue is narrowed from one, how literature presents an issue, what the individual oral asks, and how it differs at SL and HL.

  • IB English A: Literature
  • SL and HL

7 min readLast reviewed

The subtopics of Global issues

Each has its own page of notes.

  1. 6.1Culture, identity and community
  2. 6.2Beliefs, values and education
  3. 6.3Politics, power and justice
  4. 6.4Art, creativity and the imagination
  5. 6.5Science, technology and the environment

An overview of Global issues

A global issue is a question that societies argue about, significant on a wide scale, crossing national borders and felt in everyday local life. Global issues give the study of literary works a direction beyond the classroom, and one of them is the focus of the individual oral. Works present such issues through people, scenes and words, and rarely as plain statements. In Sophocles’ Antigone, first performed in Athens in about 441 BCE, two sisters argue over whether to bury their brother, whom the king has ordered left unburied.

ANTIGONE: My brother, and, though thou deny him, thine.
ANTIGONE: No man shall say that I betrayed a brother.
ISMENE: Wilt thou persist, though Creon has forbid?
ANTIGONE: What right has he to keep me from my own?

Sophocles, Antigone, translated by F. Storr (1912), lines 45–48

The play never names its issue, which is when a person may refuse a ruler’s law. The issue arrives as a quarrel between sisters, each holding to a different loyalty. Ismene names authority, “Creon has forbid” (line 47), while Antigone answers with family, in the stressed “I” of line 46 and the possessive “my own” of line 48. Her last line is a question that challenges the king’s right itself. A reading of this issue in the play would analyze those choices of pronoun and question, not argue about civil disobedience in general.

The issue at the center of the oral

The individual oral is a ten-minute talk on how one global issue is presented in two works, one originally written in English and one studied in translation, through one extract from each. Five minutes of questions from the teacher follow. The pages on the individual oral explain how to choose the issue, the works and the extracts, and how to plan and deliver the talk. The pages on the fields of inquiry supply what comes first: the issues themselves, and practice in finding them in works.

What makes an issue global

A global issue has three qualities, and the question in Antigone has all three. It matters on a wide scale, wherever a state makes laws that some of its people believe unjust. It crosses national borders, since the same argument is held about protest, refusal to fight and the treatment of the dead in many countries and periods. Its effects are also felt in everyday local life, whenever one person decides whether to obey a rule they think wrong. An issue that has only one or two of these qualities is usually either too local to share with another work or too abstract to find in an extract.

An issue is also framed as a question, not as a slogan. “Unjust laws should be disobeyed” is a position to agree with, and two works can only illustrate it. “When may a person refuse a ruler’s law?” leaves room for two works to answer differently, which is what a comparison needs. Care matters too. Many issues concern painful subjects, such as war, abuse or the death of a child, and they are discussed through how the works present them, with the respect owed to people who have lived them.

Fields of inquiry and issues

The course offers five fields of inquiry to help students find an issue. Each field is a broad area of human concern:

  • Culture, identity and community: belonging, family, migration, language, and the communities that include or exclude.

  • Beliefs, values and education: religious and secular belief, moral codes, and what schools and societies teach.

  • Politics, power and justice: authority and resistance, law, class, war, rights and empire.

  • Art, creativity and the imagination: what art is for, who may make it, censorship and the artist in society.

  • Science, technology and the environment: the natural world and its use, the costs of progress, the body and medicine.

The fields are guides, not a closed list, and an issue may touch more than one of them. Most issues sit naturally in one field, as the question in Antigone sits in politics, power and justice. A field is never itself the issue, because it asks no question. Between the two lies a topic, such as migration or obedience, which names a subject but still sets no question.

A narrowing in miniature

Finding an issue means narrowing step by step until both works answer the same question. The diagram follows one narrowing from the field of politics, power and justice. The topic of obedience to authority is still a subject. It becomes an issue when it is put as the question “How far does obeying orders excuse a share in injustice?” Real societies argue over that question, in war crimes trials and in offices where an employee is told to do something wrong.

Diagram: a funnel. Field of inquiry: politics, power and justice. Topic: obedience to authority. Global issue: how far does obeying orders excuse a share in injustice? It splits into two works, The Remains of the Day (in English) and The Reader (in translation), each with an extract.Diagram: a funnel. Field of inquiry: politics, power and justice. Topic: obedience to authority. Global issue: how far does obeying orders excuse a share in injustice? It splits into two works, The Remains of the Day (in English) and The Reader (in translation), each with an extract.
From field to extracts: one narrowing for the individual oral. Each step must be possible before the next is chosen.

The issue then has to hold in two works. Kazuo Ishiguro’s The Remains of the Day (1989) is narrated by Stevens, an English butler who, on his employer’s instruction, dismisses two Jewish maids in the 1930s. Bernhard Schlink’s The Reader (1995), translated from German by Carol Brown Janeway (1997), shows a former concentration camp guard on trial, who asks the judge what he would have done in her place. The two works present the issue from opposite sides. Ishiguro gives it to the man who obeyed, whose calm narration avoids the judgment, and Schlink to a narrator who loved the accused and must judge her.

Presentation, not the issue itself

An oral analyzes how works present an issue, not the issue itself. Literature presents an issue through characters and their choices, through form and structure, through a narrative voice, and through images. Stevens’s restraint is the presentation in The Remains of the Day, since a narrator who will not name what he did leaves the reader to name it. An oral that explained the history of obedience in wartime, however accurately, would describe the subject and leave the writing unread.

The five field pages each work the same way. Each opens with a scene in which an issue can be seen, such as a family meeting officials on a San Francisco wharf or a town doctor discovering that its Baths are poisoned. Each teaches the field’s own terms, follows one worked narrowing to two works and two extracts, and sets out further issues and the ways an issue can go wrong. They can be read in any order, but they are best read before the pages on the individual oral, which assume them.

Issues, concepts and contexts

Global issues draw on the rest of the course. An issue is often read through a central concept, especially representation, which asks how a group of people is shown and by whom, or perspective, which asks whose view a work takes. The area of exploration Time and space supplies context, so that a law or a custom in a work can be understood in its place and period. The area Intertextuality supplies the habit of setting two perspectives on one question side by side, which is what an oral does with its two works.

Standard and higher level

The individual oral is the same task at both levels, with the same timing, criteria and marks. It counts for 30 percent of the grade at standard level and 20 percent at higher level, which adds the HL essay. Higher level students study more works, so they can test an issue against more pairings before choosing. Whether one work can serve in more than one of the oral, the HL essay and Paper 2 is a rule to confirm, so students check with their teacher which works they may use where.

How literature presents an issue leads back to the concepts of representation and perspective. It leads forward to the pages on the individual oral, which turn an issue into a choice of extracts and a plan for ten minutes.

Key terms

Each is also in the Global issues glossary for IB English A Lit, beside the other terms of its topic.

Field of inquiry

One of the five broad areas of human concern from which a global issue is found: culture, identity and community; beliefs, values and education; politics, power and justice; art, creativity and the imagination; and science, technology and the environment. A field is wider than an issue and is not itself a question, so an issue has to be narrowed from it.

Global issue

A question that societies argue about, significant on a wide scale, crossing national borders and felt in everyday local life. In the individual oral it is the issue whose presentation the student examines in two works, through an extract from each.

Practice questions on Global issues

Augment’s own questions, written in the style of IB exam papers. Here is how a few of them start.

Question 1 · ENGAL-0000320 marks
Lot Forty-onePepper Trees, a collection of essays from Los Angeles, 1920sWritten for Augment Education
There is a piece of paper in my Bible, at the Book of Ruth, which has been there so long that the pages on either side of it have gone brown in its shape. It is a deed. It says that for the sum of three hundred and fifty dollars, paid in gold coin, the Rosedale Terrace Land and Water Company grants to Walter J. Ames and Hattie Ames, his wife, Lot Forty-one in Block C of the Rosedale Terrace Tract, County of Los Angeles, together with all water rights. At the top there is a picture of the town. It has a hotel with four towers and a flag on every tower, a fountain, a streetcar, and a row of young orange trees going off into the distance like children in a procession.
We bought it in March of 1887, the spring that everybody in Iowa seemed to be coming to California, and most of them on the same train. The Company ran an excursion out from the city with a brass band and a free lunch, and I remember the lunch better than the land: ham sandwiches and pickles laid out on boards under a striped tent, and a man going around with lemonade in a bucket. The auctioneer stood on a wagon and talked about the climate as if he had invented it. Walter bid against a dentist from Pasadena and won, and the dentist shook his hand and told him he had got a bargain. I believe the dentist has done very well since.
The boom broke the next year, the way a fever breaks, all at once. The hotel was never built. Neither was the fountain, nor the streetcar, nor the town. We drove out to see our lot only once, on a Sunday in the summer of 1889, in a hired buggy with the children asleep in the back. We found the place by a stake with a tin number nailed to it, standing in a dry wash full of sage and white stones. A jackrabbit sat on Lot Forty-two and looked at us. Walter got down and walked all the way around the stake, slowly, as if there might be more to it from the other side. Then he climbed back up and said, “Well, Mother, we own a piece of California,” and we drove home.
We paid the taxes on it every year after that, eleven dollars and some cents, then nine, then four. Walter said it was cheaper than a lodge and gave a man more to talk about. The deed went with us to four houses, from the rooms over the feed store on Main Street to the house on Bonnie Brae with the pepper tree, and in each house it lived in the Bible, because the Bible was the one thing we were sure not to lose. Walter died in 1911. I went on paying the taxes. I could not have told you why, except that stopping would have felt like letting go of the last thing he ever bid on.

Write a guided analysis of the following text.

This is an extract from Pepper Trees, a collection of essays.

Guiding question: How does the writer use the description of a single object to explore the passing of time?

Use the guiding question or propose an alternative technical or formal aspect of the text to focus your analysis.

Exemplars and marksSee them with a free account
Question 2 · ENGAL-0001320 marks
Astoria, March 1986Fog Season, a collection of letters from the Oregon coast, 1980sWritten for Augment Education
Dear Jo,
Your letter came Tuesday with the flap torn and taped again, which means it went through the kitchen first, so I’ll write this one knowing it will too. Hello, Dad.
I’ve been here eleven months now and I still haven’t seen the top of the hill behind the boarding house. It rains here sideways, all day, without making a point of it. At home rain is an event. Dad stands on the porch and watches it come across the wheat like it owes him money, and we all stand behind him and watch him watch it. Here nobody looks up. You just put your hood on and go to work, and the rain goes to work too.
I’m at Halvorsen’s yard still, scraping hulls. They haul a boat up on the ways and you take off everything the ocean has put on her: barnacles, weed, a kind of green fur that comes off in sheets, and under that the old paint, three or four colors of it, the last owner’s and the one before. Then you find out what she’s made of. Most of them are fine underneath. Some you can put a scraper straight through, and the owner stands there in his rain gear and says he had no idea, and he did.

Write a guided analysis of the following text.

This is an extract from Fog Season, a collection of published letters. They were written in the 1980s by a young man working in Astoria, on the Oregon coast, to his younger sister at the family’s home in eastern Oregon.

Guiding question: Consider how, and to what effect, the writer uses descriptions of the coast in his letter to his sister.

Use the guiding question or propose an alternative technical or formal aspect of the text to focus your analysis.

Exemplars and marksSee them with a free account
Question 3 · ENGAL-0000420 marks
Monsoon HouseMonsoon House, a play from Bombay, 1910sWritten for Augment Education
The back verandah of a bungalow on Malabar Hill. Afternoon. A cane table and two chairs. HARGREAVES, an inspector of police, sits at the table with a notebook, his helmet beside him. MRS LIDELL stands. SAKHU stands by the steps, the end of her sari drawn over her head. TARA, ten, stands between them, a little in front of her mother.
When SAKHU and TARA speak to each other they speak Marathi. The audience hears it as English.
HARGREAVESNow. Ask your mother when she last saw the bangle.
TARA(to SAKHU) He wants to know when you saw it.

Write a guided analysis of the following text.

The following extract is from the play Monsoon House. The play is set in Bombay in 1913; Sakhu is an ayah, a children’s nurse, in the house of Mrs Lidell, Tara is her daughter, and Hargreaves is an inspector of police.

Guiding question: In what ways does the playwright use translation to shift the balance of power in this extract?

Use the guiding question or propose an alternative technical or formal aspect of the text to focus your analysis.

Exemplars and marksSee them with a free account

Practice all 116 questions on Global issues

Free with an account. Write your answer, open the markscheme beside it and mark yourself. Augment keeps the ones you got wrong for another go.

The English A Lit question bank, topic by topic

Carry on with Global issues in Augment

With a free account, Augment remembers where you stopped in the notes and which questions you have marked.