1.6 How do texts offer insights and challenges?

How texts show readers what they had not seen and unsettle what they assumed: insight, moral ambiguity, complicity, defamiliarization, didactic texts, challenges that are absorbed, and the case for comfort or discomfort.

  • IB English A: Language and Literature
  • Part of 1 Readers, writers and texts
  • SL and HL

30 min readLast reviewed

Notes on 1.6 How do texts offer insights and challenges?

Texts offer insight when they show readers something they had not seen, and challenge when they unsettle something they assumed. The two often arrive together, since seeing more is frequently the cause of believing less, and in many texts the discomfort is the point. Susan Glaspell’s one-act play Trifles (1916) opens in the cold kitchen of a farmhouse in the American Midwest. A sheriff, a county attorney, a neighbor and two women arrive the morning after the farmer has been found strangled in his bed.

Trifles (opening)Trifles, 1916Susan Glaspell, Trifles: A Play in One Act, Frank Shay / The Washington Square Players, New York, 1916
SCENE: The kitchen in the now abandoned farmhouse of John Wright, a gloomy kitchen, plainly left without having been put in order—unwashed pans under the sink, a loaf of bread outside the bread-box, a dish-towel on the table—other signs of incompleted work. Door opens rear and enter sheriff followed by county attorney and Hale. The sheriff and Hale are men in middle life, the county attorney is a young man; all are much bundled up and go at once to the stove. They are followed by the two women—the sheriff’s wife first; she is a slight wiry woman, a thin nervous face. Mrs. Hale is larger and would ordinarily be called more comfortable looking, but she is disturbed now and looks fearfully about as she enters. The women have come in slowly, and stand close together near the door.
COUNTY ATTORNEY(Rubbing his hands) This feels good. Come up to the fire, ladies.
MRS. PETERS(Takes a step forward and looks around) I’m not—cold.
SHERIFF(Unbuttoning his overcoat and stepping away from the stove as if to mark the beginning of official business) Now, Mr. Hale, before we move things about, you explain to Mr. Henderson just what you saw when you came here yesterday morning.
COUNTY ATTORNEYBy the way, has anything been moved? Are things just as you left them yesterday?
SHERIFF(Looking all about) It’s just the same. When it dropped below zero last night I thought I’d better send Frank out this morning to make a fire for us—no use getting pneumonia with a big case on, but I told him not to touch anything except the stove—and you know Frank.
COUNTY ATTORNEYSomebody should have been left here yesterday.
SHERIFFOh—yesterday. When I had to send Frank to Morris Center for that man who went crazy—I want you to know I had my hands full yesterday. I knew you could get back from Omaha by today and as long as I went over everything here myself——
COUNTY ATTORNEYWell, Mr. Hale, tell just what happened when you came here yesterday morning.
HALEHarry and I had started to town with a load of potatoes. We came along the road from my place and as I got here I said, “I’m going to see if I can’t get John Wright to go in with me on a party telephone. I spoke to Wright about it once before and he put me off, saying folks talked too much anyway, and all he asked was peace and quiet——I guess you know about how much he talked himself, but I thought maybe if I went to the house and talked about it before his wife, though I said to Harry that I didn’t know as what his wife wanted made much difference to John——
COUNTY ATTORNEYLet’s talk about that later, Mr. Hale. I do want to talk about that, but tell now just what happened when you got to the house.
HALEI didn’t hear or see anything; I knocked at the door, and still it was all quiet inside. I knew they must be up, it was past eight o’clock. So I knocked again, and I thought I heard somebody say “Come in.” I wasn’t sure, I’m not sure yet, but I opened the door—this door (jerking a hand backward) and there in that rocker—(pointing to it) sat Mrs. Wright. (All look at the rocker)
COUNTY ATTORNEYWhat—was she doing?
HALEShe was rockin’ back and forth. She had her apron in her hand and was kind of—pleating it.
COUNTY ATTORNEYAnd how did she—look?
HALEWell, she looked queer.
COUNTY ATTORNEYHow do you mean—queer?
HALEWell, as if she didn’t know what she was going to do next. And kind of done up.
COUNTY ATTORNEYHow did she seem to feel about your coming?
HALEWhy, I don’t think she minded—one way or other. She didn’t pay much attention. I said, “How do, Mrs. Wright, it’s cold, ain’t it?” And she said “Is it?”—and went on kind of pleating at her apron. Well, I was surprised; she didn’t ask me to come up to the stove, or to set down, but just sat there, not even looking at me, so I said, “I want to see John.” And then she—laughed. I guess you would call it a laugh. I thought of Harry and the team outside, so I said a little sharp: “Can’t I see John?” “No,” she says, kind o’ dull like. “Ain’t he home?” says I. “Yes,” says she, “he’s home.” “Then why can’t I see him?” I asked her, out of patience. “’Cause he’s dead,” says she. “Dead?” says I. She just nodded her head, not getting a bit excited, but rockin’ back and forth. “Why—where is he?” says I, not knowing what to say. She just pointed upstairs—like that (himself pointing to the room above) I got up, with the idea of going up there. I walked from there to here—(pointing)—then I says, “Why, what did he die of?” “He died of a rope round his neck,” says she, and just went on pleatin’ at her apron. Well, I went out and called Harry. I thought I might—need help. We went upstairs and there he was—lyin’——
COUNTY ATTORNEYI think I’d rather have you go into that upstairs, where you can point it all out. Just go on now with the rest of the story.
HALEWell, my first thought was to get that rope off. It looked—(stops, his face twitches)—but Harry, he went up to him, and he said, “No, he’s dead all right, and we’d better not touch anything.” So we went back down stairs. She was still sitting that same way. “Has anybody been notified?” I asked. “No,” says she, unconcerned. “Who did this, Mrs. Wright?” said Harry. He said it business-like—and she stopped pleatin’ of her apron. “I don’t know,” she says. “You don’t know?” says Harry. “No,” says she. “Weren’t you sleepin’ in the bed with him?” says Harry. “Yes,” says she, “but I was on the inside.” “Somebody slipped a rope round his neck and strangled him and you didn’t wake up?” says Harry. “I didn’t wake up,” she said after him. We may have looked as if we didn’t see how that could be, for after a minute she said, “I sleep sound.” Harry was going to ask her more questions but I said maybe we ought to let her tell her story first to the coroner, or the sheriff, so Harry went fast as he could to Rivers’ place, where there’s a telephone.
COUNTY ATTORNEYAnd what did Mrs. Wright do when she knew that you had gone for the coroner?
HALEShe moved from that chair to this one over here, (pointing to a small chair in the corner) and just sat there with her hands held together and looking down. I got a feeling that I ought to make some conversation, so I said I had come in to see if John wanted to put in a telephone, and at that she started to laugh, and then she stopped and looked at me—scared. (County attorney, who has had his notebook out, makes a note) I dunno, maybe it wasn’t scared. I wouldn’t like to say it was. Soon Harry got back, and then Dr. Lloyd came, and you, Mr. Peters, and so I guess that’s all I know that you don’t.
COUNTY ATTORNEY(Looking around) I guess we’ll go upstairs first—and then out to the barn and around there. (To sheriff) You’re convinced that there was nothing important here—nothing that would point to any motive?
SHERIFFNothing here but kitchen things.
COUNTY ATTORNEY(Opens the door of a cupboard closet. Gets up on a chair and looks on a shelf. Pulls his hand away, sticky) Here’s a nice mess. (The women draw nearer)
MRS. PETERSOh, her fruit; it did freeze. (To County Attorney) She worried about that when it turned so cold. She said the fire’d go out and her jars would break.
SHERIFFWell, can you beat the women! Held for murder and worrying about her preserves.
COUNTY ATTORNEY(Setting his lips firmly) I guess before we are through she may have something more serious than preserves to worry about.
HALEWell, women are used to worrying over trifles. (The two women move a little closer together)
COUNTY ATTORNEY(With the gallantry of a young politician) And yet, for all their worries, what would we do without the ladies? (The women do not unbend. He goes to sink, takes a dipperful of water from pail and pouring it into basin, washes his hands. Starts to wipe them on roller-towel, turns it for a cleaner place) Dirty towels! (Kicks his foot against pans under the sink) Not much of a housekeeper, would you say, ladies?
MRS. HALE(Stiffly) There’s a great deal of work to be done on a farm.
COUNTY ATTORNEY(With conciliation) To be sure. And yet (with a little bow to her) I know there are some Dickson county farmhouses which do not have such roller towels. (Gives it a pull to expose its full length again.)
MRS. HALEThose towels get dirty awful quick. Men’s hands aren’t always as clean as they might be.
COUNTY ATTORNEYAh, loyal to your sex, I see. But you and Mrs. Wright were neighbors. I suppose you were friends, too.
MRS. HALE(Shaking her head.) I’ve not seen much of her of late years. I’ve not been in this house—it’s more than a year.
COUNTY ATTORNEYAnd why was that? You didn’t like her?
MRS. HALEI liked her all well enough. Farmer’s wives have their hands full, Mr. Henderson. And then——
COUNTY ATTORNEYYes—?
MRS. HALE(Looking about.) It never seemed a very cheerful place.
COUNTY ATTORNEYNo——it’s not cheerful. I shouldn’t say she had the homemaking instinct.
MRS. HALEWell, I don’t know as Wright had, either.
COUNTY ATTORNEYYou mean that they didn’t get on very well?
MRS. HALENo, I don’t mean anything. But I don’t think a place’d be any cheerfuller for John Wright’s being in it.
COUNTY ATTORNEYI’d like to talk more of that a little later. I want to get the lay of things upstairs now. (Moves to stair-door, followed by the two men)
SHERIFFI suppose anything Mrs. Peters does’ll be all right. She was to take in some clothes for her, you know, and a few little things. We left in such a hurry yesterday.
COUNTY ATTORNEYYes, but I would like to see what you take, Mrs. Peters, and keep an eye out for anything that might be of use to us.
MRS. PETERSYes, Mr. Henderson. (The women listen to the men’s steps on the stairs, then look about the kitchen)
MRS. HALEI’d hate to have men coming into my kitchen, snooping round and criticizing. (Arranges pans under sink which the county attorney had shoved out of place)
MRS. PETERSOf course it’s no more than their duty.
MRS. HALEDuty’s all right, but I guess that deputy sheriff that came out to make the fire might have got a little of this on. (Gives roller towel a pull) Wish I’d thought of that sooner. Seems mean to talk about her for not having things slicked up when she had to come away in such a hurry.
MRS. PETERS(Going to table at side, lifts one end of towel that covers a pan) She had bread set. (Stands still)

Insight: learning where to look

The men in Trifles have come to find a motive, and they are sure where it is not. After hearing the neighbor’s account, the county attorney asks whether there is anything in the kitchen “that would point to any motive”, and the sheriff answers for all of them: “Nothing here but kitchen things.” (line 26). The audience has already been shown otherwise. The opening stage direction lists “unwashed pans under the sink, a loaf of bread outside the bread-box, a dish-towel on the table” and “other signs of incompleted work” (line 1). The kitchen is full of evidence, and the play’s first gift to its audience is the habit of reading it.

The insight comes through point of view as much as through detail. For most of the extract the men lead and the women stand “close together near the door” (line 1), answering when spoken to. When the men go upstairs, “The women listen to the men’s steps on the stairs, then look about the kitchen” (line 49), and the audience stays with them. From that moment the play sees through the women’s eyes. The first thing they notice is work: Mrs. Hale rearranges the pans the attorney kicked aside, and Mrs. Peters lifts a towel and finds that “She had bread set.” (line 53).

MRS. HALE: (Stiffly) There’s a great deal of work to be done on a farm.

Susan Glaspell, Trifles (1916), line 33

Mrs. Hale’s reply to the attorney’s “Dirty towels!” and “Not much of a housekeeper” (line 32) is the play’s insight in one sentence. The men treat the kitchen as a place where nothing happens; the women know it as the place where a farm’s daily work is done, often alone. The audience of 1916, used to seeing the kitchen as women’s business and the barn as men’s, is shown a whole life it had been trained to overlook. Insight of this kind redirects attention. It does not add a new fact so much as make visible a category of facts that was always there.

A novel can offer the same kind of insight more slowly. In Chimamanda Ngozi Adichie’s Purple Hibiscus (2003), Kambili, a fifteen-year-old girl in Enugu, Nigeria, narrates life in the house of a wealthy, devout and violent father. At first she reports his punishments as part of a family’s ordinary order, and only gradually comes to see them for what they are. Because the novel is told in her voice, understanding grows on the page at roughly the pace of hers, as she reports a beating in the same even tone as a meal. The insight is earned, and it is all the stronger for having been resisted by the person who narrates it.

Challenge: a verdict the play will not give

Insight in Trifles leads directly to challenge. As the play goes on beyond the extract, the two women find what the men miss: quilt pieces sewn erratically, a birdcage with a broken door, and, hidden in a sewing box, a dead canary whose neck has been wrung. They understand that John Wright killed the one thing that sang in his wife’s silent house, and that she killed him. Then they hide the box. When the county attorney, joking at the end, asks what the women call what Mrs. Wright was doing with her quilt, Mrs. Hale answers with the play’s last words: “We call it—knot it, Mr. Henderson.”

The play gives its audience no verdict. Mrs. Wright, the women conclude, has killed her husband, and the women who conceal the evidence are the sheriff’s wife and a neighbor. Against that stand years of cruelty that the law would not have weighed, and a recognition Mrs. Hale puts in a single paradox: “We live close together and we live far apart.” A situation or choice that can be judged right and wrong at once, and that a text leaves open, is moral ambiguity. Trifles hands the act of judging to the audience, which is the challenge: to decide whether loyalty to a suffering woman outweighs the justice of the court.

SHERIFF: I suppose anything Mrs. Peters does’ll be all right. She was to take in some clothes for her, you know, and a few little things. We left in such a hurry yesterday.
COUNTY ATTORNEY: Yes, but I would like to see what you take, Mrs. Peters, and keep an eye out for anything that might be of use to us.

Susan Glaspell, Trifles (1916), lines 47–48

These two lines suggest how the play implicates its audience. The sheriff trusts his wife without a thought, and the attorney asks her to watch for anything “of use to us” (line 48), so the audience knows exactly whose side the law expects her to be on. By the time the women find the bird, the audience has spent the play in the kitchen with them, seeing what they see, and is on their side before it knows what they will do. When they hide the box, the audience has seen the same evidence and is not asked to speak. The curtain falls with the secret kept, and everyone in the theater is part of the keeping. Nothing in the ending releases the audience from that position, so the play withholds the relief that a verdict would give. A text that makes its readers or audience share in what they are asked to judge creates complicity.

Mrs. Hale’s “We live close together and we live far apart.” is a paradox: a statement that seems to contradict itself but holds a truth when it is thought through. The farm wives of the play are neighbors who see each other rarely, so they are close and strangers at once; the paradox makes Mrs. Hale’s guilt at not visiting part of the play’s judgment. Glaspell rewrote the play as a short story in 1917, and its title, “A Jury of Her Peers”, names the challenge outright. The two women act as the jury of equals that a court run by men would not have given Mrs. Wright.

Making the familiar strange

The men in Trifles cannot see the kitchen because they have seen kitchens all their lives. Habit makes the familiar invisible, and one way texts offer insight is by breaking it. The Russian critic Viktor Shklovsky made this the purpose of art in his essay “Art as Device” (1917). Ordinary perception, he argued, becomes automatic, so that people pass over objects without seeing them; art makes things strange again in order to slow perception down. One of his examples was Leo Tolstoy’s story “Kholstomer” (1886), narrated by a horse, who finds the human idea of owning living creatures absurd. Presenting the familiar as if it were strange, so that it is seen again, is defamiliarization.

Satire has used the method for centuries. In Jonathan Swift’s Gulliver’s Travels (1726), the tiny people of Lilliput have fought a long war with their neighbors over which end of an egg to break. An official tells Gulliver that eleven thousand people have chosen death rather than break their eggs at the smaller end, although their scripture says only that believers should break their eggs at the convenient end. Shrunk to the size of a breakfast quarrel, a war over religious doctrine looks as foolish as it is deadly, and Swift’s first audience, in a country long divided by religion, could recognize its own history in it.

Strangeness in a life story

Defamiliarization can also be the natural result of an outsider’s eyes, in a text that makes no claim to be literature. The Interesting Narrative of the Life of Olaudah Equiano (1789) is the autobiography of a man who tells how he was kidnapped as a child in West Africa and enslaved. He later bought his freedom and campaigned against the slave trade in London. In one passage the child, newly sold in Virginia, is sent into the house of the plantation owner to fan him while he sleeps:

The first object that engaged my attention was a watch which hung on the chimney, and was going. I was quite surprised at the noise it made, and was afraid it would tell the gentleman any thing I might do amiss: and when I immediately after observed a picture hanging in the room, which appeared constantly to look at me, I was still more affrighted, having never seen such things as these before.

Olaudah Equiano, The Interesting Narrative (1789), chapter 3

A watch and a portrait are among the most ordinary objects in an eighteenth-century gentleman’s house, and Equiano’s British audience would hardly have noticed them. Seen by the child, the watch becomes a spy that might “tell the gentleman”, and the portrait a face that “appeared constantly to look at me”. The child is wrong about what the objects are and right about the house. A few lines earlier he has seen an enslaved cook wearing an iron device that locked her mouth, which he “afterwards learned was called the iron muzzle”. In a house of surveillance and punishment, a clock that informs and a picture that watches are accurate images of how the household feels to the people it owns.

The insight is a challenge to the book’s first buyers, many of them comfortable households in London. The objects of their own homes, the watch that “was going” and the picture on the wall, are returned to them as instruments of fear. Defamiliarization here invents nothing strange: it reports truthfully what a familiar world looks like from the position of someone who has no power in it.

A single phrase can do the same work. An oxymoron joins two words of opposite meaning, as when John Milton’s Paradise Lost (1667) describes the fires of hell as giving only “darkness visible” (Book I). The phrase asks for something that cannot be seen to be imagined, and the strain of trying is the effect: hell is made strange by being described in a contradiction. Where a paradox, like Mrs. Hale’s, unfolds a contradiction across a sentence, an oxymoron compresses it into two words.

Challenge as argument

Non-literary texts can challenge directly, by argument, and the hardest audience to challenge is one that already agrees. Frederick Douglass, who had escaped slavery in Maryland in 1838, spoke on 5 July 1852 in Corinthian Hall in Rochester, New York, at the invitation of the Rochester Ladies’ Anti-Slavery Society, to an audience that opposed slavery already. He did not try to persuade them that slavery was wrong. He told them what the Fourth of July looked like to the enslaved:

To him, your celebration is a sham; your boasted liberty, an unholy license; your national greatness, swelling vanity; your sounds of rejoicing are empty and heartless; your denunciations of tyrants, brass fronted impudence; your shouts of liberty and equality, hollow mockery;

Frederick Douglass, Fourth of July oration, 1852, paragraph 5

The target is less an opinion than a belief so widely shared that it seemed simply true: that the United States was the land of liberty and the Fourth of July its proof. A system of beliefs and values that a society holds so firmly that its members take it as common sense is an ideology. Douglass names each part of the national celebration and sets beside it what it hides, in balanced pairs: “liberty” against “unholy license”, “national greatness” against “swelling vanity”. The paragraph ends by calling the whole display “a thin veil to cover up crimes”, which is a precise image for how an ideology works. It covers what it does not want seen, and it is thin enough to see through once someone points.

The pronoun “your” carries the challenge to the people in the hall. They are opponents of slavery, but they also celebrate the Fourth of July, so the “celebration”, the “liberty” and the “shouts” are theirs too. Douglass gives them no position outside the nation he indicts. The speech challenges its allies by refusing to let their opinions excuse their place in the system, a move that the chapter on communication reads as one speech with two audiences.

Texts that teach openly

Douglass tells his audience exactly what to think, and so do many texts written to instruct. A text whose open aim is to teach a lesson or a belief practices didacticism. School readers of the nineteenth century were didactic by design. One of the most widely used series of schoolbooks in the United States was McGuffey’s readers. A lesson called “Knowledge Is Power” in McGuffey’s Fourth Eclectic Reader (revised edition, 1879) is a dialogue. A “bustling little man” praises knowledge, and an old man teaches him its dangers through three comparisons: a horse, a pond and a ship. It ends with the old man’s moral and a set of exercises for the pupil:

“Well, then,” continued the old man, “if you see these things so clearly, I hope you can see, too, that knowledge, to be a good thing, must be rightly applied. God’s grace in the heart will render the knowledge of the head a blessing; but without this, it may prove to us no better than a curse.” “I see! I see!” said the little man, “I see!”
Exercises.—What is the subject of this lesson? Is knowledge always a power? Is it always a blessing?

“Knowledge Is Power”, McGuffey’s Fourth Eclectic Reader (1879), paragraph 6 and Exercises

The lesson leaves the pupil nothing to decide. The old man’s three comparisons all say the same thing, that power is good only under restraint: the horse “under restraint”, the water “properly conducted by trenches”, the ship “steered aright”. The little man answers each with a more eager “I see!”, which models the response the book expects from the child reading it. The exercises then ask questions whose answers the lesson has already given. Behind the lesson sits an ideology of its time, in which learning is safe only inside religious obedience, and the text passes it on as plain good sense.

Readers have long resisted texts of this kind. The poet John Keats complained, in a letter to his friend John Hamilton Reynolds of 3 February 1818, of “poetry that has a palpable design upon us”: writing that pushes its reader toward a fixed conclusion. Trifles is the opposite case. It has a view of how the law treats women, but no character states it; the audience reaches it through evidence such as the bread “set” and abandoned (line 53). The McGuffey lesson confirms what its pupils’ parents and teachers already believed, while Trifles asks its audience to believe less than it did. A text can teach openly and still challenge, as Douglass’s oration does; it challenges when its lesson runs against its audience’s comfort, and reproduces ideology when it runs with it.

Try it

The little man in the McGuffey lesson says “I see!” after each of the old man’s comparisons, and “I see! I see!” at the end. How might a reader today read this repetition differently from the lesson’s first pupils?

The lesson presents the repetition as a sign of understanding growing, the response a good pupil should give. A reader today, less used to texts that state their morals, may hear comedy in it: the little man agrees more loudly each time without adding a thought of his own. Read that way, the lesson unintentionally shows the cost of didactic teaching, a pupil trained to agree. The change is in the reader’s position, not in the words, which is a reminder that a text’s capacity to challenge depends on who reads it and when.

When a challenge is absorbed

A challenge works only if its audience cannot easily absorb it, and some audiences absorb almost anything. On 5 October 2018, at an auction at Sotheby’s in London, a framed painting by the anonymous street artist Banksy, Girl with Balloon, sold for just over a million pounds. Moments later a shredder hidden in the frame cut the lower half of the canvas into strips in front of the bidders. The stunt looked like a direct challenge to the art market, an artwork destroying itself at the moment it became a luxury good.

The market took it in. Renamed Love Is in the Bin, the half-shredded work was certified as a new piece and sold again at Sotheby’s in October 2021 for about £18.6 million, many times its first price. The challenge became part of the object’s value, and the event that mocked the auction became its best advertisement. The story marks a limit of challenge in any text: what unsettles one audience can be turned into a commodity, a joke or a classic by the institutions it attacks.

Literary texts are absorbed too, more slowly. Trifles was little read for decades and returned to wide study from the 1970s, when its view of women and the law suited a new generation of readers. The county attorney’s charm is a good test:

COUNTY ATTORNEY: (With the gallantry of a young politician) And yet, for all their worries, what would we do without the ladies?

Susan Glaspell, Trifles (1916), line 32

In 1916 the line could pass as ordinary politeness, and the stage direction’s “gallantry of a young politician” was a sharp joke at the speaker’s expense. A modern audience may find the condescension predictable rather than startling, since the play has taught a century of readers to expect it. The play’s challenge has moved rather than disappeared. It has passed from the question of whether women’s lives deserve attention, which most of its audience now takes for granted, to the harder question of whether the women were right to hide the evidence.

Comfort or discomfort

Readers disagree about where a text’s value lies when it offers insight and challenge. One position holds that the purpose of serious reading is discomfort. In a letter to his friend Oskar Pollak of 27 January 1904, the writer Franz Kafka argued that the books worth reading are those that strike their readers hard. A book, he wrote, should be an axe for the frozen sea inside them. Shklovsky’s defamiliarization belongs to the same family of ideas: a text matters because it breaks the habits through which a reader sees the world.

The opposite position defends comfort, or rather recognition. The critic Rita Felski, in Uses of Literature (2008), described four ways readers engage with literature: recognition, enchantment, knowledge and shock. She argued that critics had come to value shock and suspicion and to treat recognition, the experience of seeing oneself in a text, as naive. Recognition, on her account, is itself a form of knowledge, because seeing one’s life put into words can change how it is understood, and it is often the reason ordinary readers read at all.

The diagram places the texts discussed so far according to how much of what it presents its audience had not seen, and how much it unsettled that audience. The positions are judgments, open to argument, but the pattern is clear enough. The texts that challenge most are not always those that show most: Douglass told his audience little they did not know, and unsettled them more than any other text here. The McGuffey lesson does neither for its pupils, and Banksy’s shredding challenged an audience that turned the challenge into profit.

Diagram: texts placed by insight (across) and challenge (up). Trifles high on both; Douglass high challenge, less insight; Equiano and Gulliver high on both; Purple Hibiscus high insight, middle challenge; McGuffey lesson low on both; Banksy’s 2018 shredding a challenge absorbed downward by the…Diagram: texts placed by insight (across) and challenge (up). Trifles high on both; Douglass high challenge, less insight; Equiano and Gulliver high on both; Purple Hibiscus high insight, middle challenge; McGuffey lesson low on both; Banksy’s 2018 shredding a challenge absorbed downward by the…
Insight and challenge as two separate measures. A text can unsettle its audience without telling it anything new, and a challenge can be absorbed.

Trifles suggests that the two positions describe stages of one experience rather than rival values. The women’s challenge to the law begins in recognition. Mrs. Hale sees her own life in Mrs. Wright’s, “We all go through the same things”, and that recognition leads directly to the act that unsettles the audience. Felski is right that recognition is a form of insight and not a lesser pleasure; Kafka is right that the texts that last tend to leave their readers less settled than they found them. The judgment most useful in analysis is to ask of each text what it lets its audience recognize, and what that recognition then costs them.

MRS. HALE: Well, I don’t know as Wright had, either.

Susan Glaspell, Trifles (1916), line 43

Mrs. Hale’s reply to the attorney’s charge that Mrs. Wright lacked “the homemaking instinct” (line 42) is the first small recognition of this kind in the extract. In eight words she turns a judgment of one woman into a question about the marriage, and the attorney, who wants to talk about it “a little later” (line 46), moves on. The audience does not. Here insight and challenge are one sentence long, and the play builds everything that follows on them.

Writing about challenge

Writing about how a text challenges its audience needs two things that a summary of its argument does not give: a precise audience, and the choices that make that audience uncomfortable. The paragraph that follows is about how Douglass’s oration challenges listeners who already agreed with him, written as a strong student might write it.

Douglass challenges an audience that already opposed slavery by refusing the role it had invited him to play.note 1 The expected speech was an argument; instead he asks “Would you have me argue that man is entitled to liberty?” and answers for his listeners, “You have already declared it.” (paragraph 1).note 2 Each possible argument is then raised and dropped until “The time for such argument is past.” (paragraph 3), so that the audience’s agreement turns from a credit into a charge: people who already know that slavery is wrong have no excuse for celebrating while it lasts.note 3 The refusal ends in his statement that “scorching irony, not convincing argument, is needed” (paragraph 4), which announces that the speech aims at his listeners’ comfort rather than their opinions, the harder thing to move.note 4

  1. A precise audience. The claim names who is challenged and why that audience is unusual: they already agree.

  2. The choice, quoted. The rhetorical question and its answer are quoted together, so the reader sees the refusal happen.

  3. The effect on that audience. The sentence explains what the structure does to these listeners, not to “the reader” in general.

  4. The text’s own account. Douglass’s statement of method is used as evidence for the paragraph’s claim about purpose.

The paragraph never says that the speech is “powerful” or that it “makes the audience think”. It names an audience, quotes the choices and says what changes for that audience. The same difference separates a weak sentence about challenge from a strong one. The two sentences that follow are about the same speech.

Weak: Douglass’s speech is challenging because it talks about slavery, which is a serious issue that makes people think.note 1

Strong: By calling the national holiday “your 4th of July” (paragraph 5), Douglass leaves his antislavery listeners no place outside the nation he accuses, so that their agreement with him becomes part of what he challenges.note 2

  1. Subject mistaken for challenge. A serious subject does not make a text challenging; the sentence would fit any text about slavery.

  2. A choice and its target. One word, the pronoun, is shown doing the work, and the people it unsettles are named.

Applying it in the individual oral

The individual oral asks how a global issue is presented in one literary work and one non-literary body of work studied in class, through an extract from each. The student talks for about 10 minutes, the teacher asks questions for about 5, and the oral is marked out of 40 on four criteria. Insight and challenge give an oral its sharpest questions, because a global issue is usually something a text either shows its audience or unsettles them about. Trifles and the speeches of Frederick Douglass, for example, could be paired under the field of politics, power and justice, on how people denied a voice in the law expose its failures.

A strong line in such an oral would connect the two extracts through method as well as subject: “Glaspell lets her audience find the injustice in objects the men dismiss, and Douglass refuses to argue a case his listeners already accept.” Both make an audience complicit, one by letting it keep the women’s secret, the other by calling the holiday “your 4th of July” (paragraph 5). The commonest ways to lose marks are a global issue so broad that it fits any text (“injustice is wrong”), unequal time for the two works, and a talk about the extracts that never reaches the works around them. A further risk is to describe an extract as “challenging” without showing whom it challenged and how.

The oral’s five minutes of questions often test exactly this idea. A teacher may ask whether the play’s challenge still works for an audience today, or whether Douglass’s refusal to argue would persuade anyone who disagreed with him. A student who has thought about who was unsettled then, and who is unsettled now, can answer from the texts instead of from opinion.

Insight and challenge lead to perspective, the position from which a text sees what it shows, and to the global issue of politics, power and justice, where texts challenge the institutions that govern their readers. They lead too to the question of how texts affect their readers, which this question extends: from feeling with a text to being changed by it.

Self-check

  • To do:

    I can explain how a text offers insight by redirecting attention, with evidence from Trifles.

  • To do:

    I can explain how moral ambiguity and complicity turn insight into challenge.

  • To do:

    I can analyze defamiliarization in a literary text and in a non-literary one.

  • To do:

    I can identify paradox, oxymoron and ideology in a text and say what each unsettles.

  • To do:

    I can compare a didactic text with one that leaves its conclusion open, and say when each challenges.

  • To do:

    I can explain how a challenge can be absorbed by its audience or change as audiences change.

  • To do:

    I can set out the case for discomfort and the case for recognition, and reach a judgment.

Key terms

Each is also in the Readers, writers and texts glossary for IB English A Lang & Lit, beside the other terms of its topic.

Complicity

Complicity is a reader's or audience's share in what a text depicts, when the text makes them recognize that they have enjoyed, accepted or helped to keep in place what they are asked to judge.

Defamiliarization

Defamiliarization is presenting something familiar as if it were strange, so that a reader sees it again instead of passing over it by habit. It works by changing the angle, scale or voice through which the familiar is seen.

Didacticism

Didacticism is the open aim of a text to teach a lesson, moral or belief. A didactic text tells its reader what to think, where other texts leave the conclusion to be drawn.

Ideology

An ideology is a system of beliefs and values that a society or group holds, often so firmly that its members take it as common sense. Texts can promote an ideology, take it for granted or expose it.

Moral ambiguity

Moral ambiguity is a situation or choice in a text that can be judged right and wrong at once, which the text leaves open instead of settling. It hands the act of judging to the reader or audience.

Oxymoron

An oxymoron is a phrase that joins two words of opposite meaning, usually an adjective and a noun. It compresses a contradiction into a few words.

Paradox

A paradox is a statement or situation that seems to contradict itself but holds a truth when it is thought through. It forces a reader to stop and work out how both parts can be true.

Practice questions on 1.6 How do texts offer insights and challenges?

Augment’s own questions, written in the style of IB exam papers. Here is how a few of them start.

Question 1 · ENGALL-0004220 marks

The following leaflet was produced by Breadfruit Corner Library, a small community library in Belize City that runs free reading activities for families in its neighborhood.

Portrait leaflet on cream with a turquoise header: the headline WHO SAYS READING IS QUIET?, a flat illustration of an older woman telling a story under a tree to children with notebooks beside a library, two colored boxes of bullet points and an orange band reading Unu kom!
Description of the leaflet

A single-page leaflet in bright flat colors on a cream background. A turquoise band at the top holds a small logo, an open book with a yellow leaf, and the library’s name in white.

The headline fills the next third of the page in heavy capitals, “WHO SAYS” in dark navy and “READING IS QUIET?” larger, in orange.

Below it, a rounded illustration shows a sandy yard under a large green tree. An older woman sits on a chair in a pink dress and yellow headwrap, arms raised, with orange curls of sound rising from her. Three children sit on the ground facing her, each with an open notebook, and an older child stands with a sketchpad. A string of colored pennants runs from the tree to a small library building on the right, whose open door shows shelves of books.

Under the picture, the event’s name is set in large orange italic, with a short paragraph beneath it. Two boxes, turquoise and green, hold bullet points. The time and place follow, and an orange band at the foot holds the call to action in large white letters.

The text of the leafletBreadfruit Corner Library, a community library in Belize City, 2024Written for Augment Education
BREADFRUIT CORNER LIBRARY · Belize City
WHO SAYS READING IS QUIET?
Saturday Story Yard
Stories in Kriol¹ and English, for all ages

Write a guided analysis of the following text.

– How do text and image work together in this leaflet to challenge ideas about what reading is?

You may answer the guiding question or set your own focus on a technical or formal aspect of the text.

Exemplars and marksSee them with a free account
Question 2 · ENGALL-0005225 marks

Compare and contrast two of the literary works you have studied.

Referring to two works you have studied, discuss how far their endings offer the reader consolation for what has come before.

Exemplars and marksSee them with a free account
Question 3 · ENGALL-0007020 marks

The following diary entry, written by a secondary school student in Georgetown during a nationwide teachers’ strike, is taken from Notes from the Seawall, an online collection of diaries kept by young people in Guyana.

Tuesday 13 February 2024Notes from the Seawall, an online collection of diaries kept by young people in Guyana, 2024Written for Augment Education
Tuesday 13 February 2024
Day seven of the strike. Day seven of no Chemistry, no Maths, no English B, and CSEC¹ is in May. I know because I have the countdown on my phone: 84 days. Mummy says the countdown is “not helping anybody, Keisha”. It is helping me.
Last night she was at the dining table with the Bristol board² and the markers I bought for my SBA³, making signs. I watched her do the letters. She does them exactly like on the blackboard, pencil first, then marker, every letter the same height. WE TEACH YOUR CHILDREN. PAY US LIKE IT MATTERS. She asked me to colour in the O’s. I said I had studying to do. I went to my room and did not study.
This morning she said, “Come with me today. You can’t learn Chemistry from a phone anyway.” I said that is exactly what I am doing, actually, because of her. She didn’t answer. She just put the second sign in the car. So I went. I don’t fully know why. Maybe because the house is so quiet when she isn’t in it.

Write a guided analysis of the following text.

– How and to what effect is the diary’s personal voice used to present the teachers’ strike?

You may answer the guiding question or set your own focus on a technical or formal aspect of the text.

Exemplars and marksSee them with a free account

Practice all 14 questions on 1.6 How do texts offer insights and challenges?

Free with an account. Write your answer, open the markscheme beside it and mark yourself. Augment keeps the ones you got wrong for another go.

1.6 How do texts offer insights and challenges? questions by paper, with 6 in full

The English A Lang & Lit question bank, topic by topic

More in 1 Readers, writers and texts

The whole topic is on its own page.

  1. 1.1Why and how do we study language and literature?
  2. 1.2How are we affected by texts in various ways?
  3. 1.3In what ways is meaning constructed, negotiated, expressed and interpreted?
  4. 1.4How does language use vary among text types and among literary forms?
  5. 1.5How does the structure or style of a text affect meaning?
  6. 1.6How do texts offer insights and challenges?This page

Carry on with 1.6 How do texts offer insights and challenges? in Augment

With a free account, Augment remembers where you stopped in the notes and which questions you have marked.