1.5 How does the structure or style of a text affect meaning?

How arrangement and style make meaning: three scales of structure, style as a pattern of choices, cohesion and coherence, foreshadowing, deviation, and whether style can be separated from what a text says.

  • IB English A: Language and Literature
  • Part of 1 Readers, writers and texts
  • SL and HL

23 min readLast reviewed

Notes on 1.5 How does the structure or style of a text affect meaning?

The structure and style of a text affect meaning because arrangement is part of what a text says. Where a detail is placed, what it stands beside and what returns all change the same material, and a writer’s style, the pattern of choices across a whole text, decides what a reader is ready to notice. “Temperament”, the poem of a piano tuner’s daughter in Winnipeg, never names a feeling, so almost everything it means is carried by how it is arranged.

TemperamentHouse Calls, a sequence of poems from Winnipeg, 1980sWritten for Augment Education
Every October, when the furnaces came on,
the pianos of Winnipeg went flat together,
a few cents at a time, and my father
drove around the city putting them back.
I carried his case. I handed him the felt.
In the tall houses on Wellington Crescent
I sat on the bottom stair and waited
while he leaned into the strings and listened for the beat
that two strings make when they nearly agree,
a wavering, like someone breathing behind a door.
He turned the pin the width of a hair
till it slowed, and slowed, and stopped.
He said it once, driving home in the dark:
Nothing’s in tune. Not really.
You set every fifth a hair narrow
so the music can go into any key it wants.
Tune one key pure and you can’t play the rest.
He said it to the windshield. I was eleven
and thought he was talking about pianos.
Ours stood in our kitchen by the back door
and he never touched it. A day of other people’s
was plenty, he said. The F stuck.
The A had three strings and three opinions.
My mother sang over it on Sundays
in Ukrainian, as if it were in tune.
It’s in my hallway now. His tuning hammer
lies in the drawer of the hall table, in its cloth.
I have his ear, my mother says. Some nights
I strike the A and listen to it waver,
someone breathing behind a door,
and I leave it.

Arrangement at three scales

The structure of a text, the order and arrangement of its parts, works at three scales at once: the sentence, the unit (a line, stanza, paragraph or post) and the whole text. The chapter on structure and form takes each part of structure in turn; read whole, “Temperament” shows how the three scales work together. Its sentences vary widely in length. The longest runs for 42 words across five lines, from “In the tall houses on Wellington Crescent” (line 6) to “like someone breathing behind a door” (line 10). The shortest have two or three: “Not really.” (line 14) and “The F stuck.” (line 22).

The lengths are not random. The 42-word sentence is the child waiting on “the bottom stair” (line 7) while her father listens. Its clauses keep adding detail, “while he leaned into the strings and listened for the beat” (line 8), so that the sentence lasts as long as the wait. The shortest sentences come where a fact is final: “Nothing’s in tune. Not really.” (line 14), “The F stuck.” (line 22). At the scale of the sentence, the poem’s syntax gives time to what was slow and patient, and cuts short what was settled and hard.

The units do the same work on a larger scale. Each of the five stanzas is a scene. Each ends on a sentence that is complete at the end of its line: “putting them back” (line 4), “stopped” (line 12), “pianos” (line 19), “in tune” (line 25), “and I leave it” (line 31). Across the whole poem, the order runs from the city’s pianos to the family’s one piano and then to the speaker’s hallway, narrowing like a camera moving in. A reader reaches the last line having followed the tuner through other people’s houses, so the one piano he never tuned arrives as the poem’s real subject.

I have his ear, my mother says. Some nights
I strike the A and listen to it waver,
someone breathing behind a door,
and I leave it.

“Temperament”, lines 28–31

The ending changes what came before. Read once, the first stanza is about a trade: a man who drove around Winnipeg “putting them back” (line 4). Read again after “and I leave it”, it becomes the first half of a contrast between a father who restored every piano but his own and a daughter who will not restore hers. Nothing in the first stanza changes on the page. Its meaning changes because of where it stands in an arrangement whose last step had not yet been taken.

Style: the pattern of choices

A single choice is a feature; a choice that recurs across a whole text becomes part of its style. “Temperament” has a style that can be described precisely, because its choices repeat. It uses no quotation marks: the father’s words are set in from the margin (lines 14–17) or reported with “he said” (lines 13, 18, 22). Its nouns come from the trade and the house, such as “case”, “felt”, “pin”, “hammer”, “drawer”. It counts: “a few cents”, “every fifth”, “eleven”, “three strings and three opinions” (line 23). And in 31 lines it never gives a word to the speaker’s own feeling. There is no grief, love or loss in its vocabulary, only things done and said.

Described this way, the style is an argument about the father. A man who explains tuning to a windshield (line 18) is remembered in a poem that also speaks through objects and numbers rather than through emotion. The speaker has inherited his reticence as well as his piano, and the style is the evidence of it. “I have his ear” (line 28) is the closest the poem comes to saying what she feels, and it is reported as her mother’s words.

The study of style with the tools of linguistics is stylistics. Its method is the one just used: find the features that recur, count them where counting helps, compare them with what a different text or writer would do, and link the pattern to meaning. Counting matters because impressions of style are unreliable. Most readers would call “Temperament” a plain poem. Counting suggests that its plainness has a particular shape: plain nouns and plain verbs, with a few words such as “temperament”, “pure” and “opinions” kept back so that they stand out.

Style as character

Style can belong to a writer across many works, and it can belong to a narrator inside one. Ernest Hemingway’s short story “Hills Like White Elephants” (1927) is famous for a style built on omission. A man and a woman wait for a train at a station in Spain and talk about an operation that neither of them names. The sentences are short and declarative, the dialogue repeats itself, and the narrator reports what is said and done without explaining what anyone feels. Hemingway later compared his method to an iceberg, most of whose mass lies under the water, in Death in the Afternoon (1932). The operation is known only from what the couple avoid saying. The couple cannot say what they mean, and the prose does not say it for them.

Kazuo Ishiguro’s novel The Remains of the Day (1989) gives the same kind of control to a narrator. Stevens, an English butler on a motoring trip in 1956, tells his story in long, formal, carefully qualified sentences, and that style is his defense. It lets him describe years of service, and a woman he did not let himself love, without ever quite admitting either. When the novel lets his feeling through near the end, it does so in a single short admission, and the effect depends on the hundreds of pages of formality around it. A style held for a whole novel turns a single break into an event.

Non-literary texts have styles too, sometimes a house style shared by everyone who writes for a source. The Penang night-market blog post “Same umbrella, new hands”, from a family oyster-omelette stall, keeps putting its jokes and asides in brackets:

Here is what stays the same: the batter, the chilli sauce (still made on Wednesdays, still too strong for Papa), the colour of the umbrella, and Uncle Bala’s extra chilli without him needing to ask.

“Same umbrella, new hands”, paragraph 8

The brackets recur across the post: “(less than you think)” and “(hotter than you think)” in paragraph 7, “(Papa still prefers cash)” in paragraph 9, “(it is a long story)” in paragraph 10. Each one holds a small family fact or joke beside the business news, so the style keeps the post personal even while it announces prices. A notice from a company would leave the brackets out, and with them the family. In a blog post, as in a poem, the recurring choice is the voice.

How a text holds together

“Temperament” is easy to follow, although its stanzas jump from the city to a staircase, a car, a kitchen and a hallway. Part of what holds it together is visible on the page. Pronouns point back to things already named, nouns return, and images repeat. These visible links between sentences make up a text’s cohesion. The fourth stanza depends on them:

Ours stood in our kitchen by the back door
and he never touched it. A day of other people’s
was plenty, he said.

“Temperament”, lines 20–22

“Ours” makes sense only because line 19 has just said “pianos”, and every it that follows points back to that one word. The diagram traces this chain through the poem, with two others. Followed to the end, the first chain holds a surprise: the word piano does not appear in the singular. The city’s pianos are named twice (lines 2 and 19), but the family’s own instrument exists only as “Ours”, “it” and “It’s in my hallway now” (line 26). The poem refers to it as a family refers to something everyone in the house knows, or as a person avoids naming something that hurts. Cohesion here is more than a joining device: the pronouns are where the poem keeps its feeling.

Diagram: three chains of cohesion in Temperament. The family piano: pianos (19), Ours (20), it (21), it (24), it (25), It’s (26), never named in the singular. The sound: a wavering like someone breathing (10) returns as waver, someone breathing (29–30). The note: the A (23) and the A (29).Diagram: three chains of cohesion in Temperament. The family piano: pianos (19), Ours (20), it (21), it (24), it (25), It’s (26), never named in the singular. The sound: a wavering like someone breathing (10) returns as waver, someone breathing (29–30). The note: the A (23) and the A (29).
Three chains of cohesion in “Temperament”. The family piano is held in the poem by pronouns alone.

The other two chains join the poem’s beginning to its end. The father’s simile, “a wavering, like someone breathing behind a door” (line 10), comes back as the speaker listens to “it waver” (line 29); the chapter on structure reads that return as the poem’s circle closing. “The A” of line 23, with its “three strings and three opinions”, is the note the speaker strikes in line 29. Each repeated word carries the earlier scene into the later one, so the hallway of the last stanza is full of the kitchen and the houses on Wellington Crescent.

Line 21 suggests that cohesion can open meaning as well as tie it. “A day of other people’s / was plenty” leaves a noun out, to be supplied from earlier lines. Pianos is the obvious answer, carried over from line 19, but houses, rooms and lives would all fit. The gap is a kind of cohesion, since the missing word must be found earlier in the poem, and it is also a small ambiguity that the father, a man of few words, would not have bothered to close.

Coherence: the reader’s work

Cohesion is in the text; the sense that a text makes as a whole, its coherence, is built by the reader. “Temperament” has almost no connectives between its stanzas. No but, so or later says how the car on the drive home relates to the kitchen piano, or how either relates to the hallway. They are connected by inference, and the poem relies on it. The father’s claim that “Nothing’s in tune” (line 14) is followed, without comment, by a family piano that is not in tune and a mother who sings “as if it were in tune” (line 25). The poem never says that the lesson applied at home. A reader who makes the link supplies the poem’s argument.

Non-literary texts usually make more of the work visible, because their purpose cannot depend on inference. The heat leaflet from Kelverton Health, a community health service in Melbourne, links its sections with headings and its advice with conditionals such as “If your home is too hot” (paragraph 18). A poem that spelled out its links in this way would lose the work it leaves to its reader; a leaflet that left them out would fail the resident who needs it most.

Order for a purpose: news and the blog

Non-literary texts order their material for their purposes, and some orders are so common that they are expected. A news report is usually built as an inverted pyramid, with the most important facts first, then the reasons, then details and background, for readers who stop after one paragraph and editors who cut from the bottom. The Penang blog post opens like a news report:

The umbrella goes up again this Thursday, 4 September, at our old pitch in Taman Cempaka Sari (stall 14, between Kak Ros and the durian lorry).

“Same umbrella, new hands”, paragraph 5

The sentence gives what, when and where in one breath, as a news lead would. The next paragraphs give the reasons (the grandmother retired after “Forty-one years, four nights a week, one kuali”, paragraph 6) and the details (what stays the same and what changes, paragraphs 8–9). For its first half, the post follows the pyramid, and its regular customers learn the one fact they need before anything else.

Then the post leaves the pyramid. A news report ends on its least important material; the post ends on its most personal. Paragraphs 10 to 12 hold the invitation to opening night, the thanks in Hokkien, “Kamsiah for waiting” (paragraph 11), and the signature of three generations. After them comes a second structure that the family does not control, the comment thread, where regulars and a neighboring stallholder answer. The diagram sets the two orders side by side. Where the post follows the pyramid it informs; where it departs, it turns a notice into a relationship, and the order says which matters more to the stall.

Diagram: on the left, the inverted pyramid of a news report, from what, who, when and where at the wide top to background at the narrow bottom. On the right, the Penang post in order: notice, story, lists (following the pyramid), then invitation and thanks, then comments (departing from it).Diagram: on the left, the inverted pyramid of a news report, from what, who, when and where at the wide top to background at the narrow bottom. On the right, the Penang post in order: notice, story, lists (following the pyramid), then invitation and thanks, then comments (departing from it).
The inverted pyramid of a news report beside the order of the Penang blog post. The post follows the pyramid for its news and leaves it for its relationship with readers.

Early details, later meanings

Arrangement works across time, too: an early detail that prepares for a later event so quietly that it is noticed only on a second reading is foreshadowing, which drama uses often, because an audience cannot turn back the page. Susan Glaspell’s Trifles (1916) opens in the cold kitchen of an Iowa farmhouse the morning after John Wright has been found dead. In the first minutes a neighbor recalls an exchange about a shared telephone line:

I didn’t know as what his wife wanted made much difference to John——

Susan Glaspell, Trifles (1916), line 10

The county attorney cuts the neighbor off, and the line seems to be gossip. On a second reading it is the first sign of the motive the play goes on to uncover, a marriage in which the wife’s wishes counted for nothing. A few lines later the sheriff’s wife worries that Mrs. Wright’s jars of preserves “would break” in the cold (line 28), and the men dismiss women who worry over preserves (lines 29–31). Later in the play the women find a broken birdcage and a dead canary, and the broken jars turn out to have prepared for them: small things broken in a cold house. Foreshadowing of this kind is part of the play’s argument, since it hides the evidence in exactly the things the men dismiss.

The Penang post foreshadows in a lighter key. Paragraph 10 says of the grandmother: “She says she is coming to eat. We know she is coming to supervise.” The post itself never shows her supervising. The thread does, in her own comment, typed by her granddaughter: “Don’t let her put too much starch.” (paragraph 19). The joke is set up by one writer and finished by another, and the thread has the pleasure of seeing the family’s prediction come true. In both texts, the early detail asks to be remembered without seeming to.

Try it

Lines 18–19 of “Temperament” read: “He said it to the windshield. I was eleven / and thought he was talking about pianos.” How do these lines prepare for the rest of the poem?

They tell the reader that the father’s words about tuning had a second meaning that the child missed, without saying what it was. Everything after them is read with that in mind. The family piano that he “never touched” (line 21), the mother singing “as if it were in tune” (line 25) and the speaker who leaves her A untuned (line 31) all become possible applications of a lesson about people. The lines work like foreshadowing in reverse: they point backward to the father’s words and forward to the poem’s ending at once.

Departures from the norm

One sentence of “Temperament” cannot be literally true: “The A had three strings and three opinions.” (line 23). A piano’s A does have three strings, struck together, but strings do not hold opinions. The sentence breaks an ordinary rule of meaning, and the break is what makes it memorable: a note that will not agree with itself becomes a family that cannot. Language that departs from the ordinary rules or habits of a language variety is linguistic deviation. Geoffrey Leech, in A Linguistic Guide to English Poetry (1969), set out the levels at which it can happen, among them words, grammar, meaning, sound and the look of a text on the page.

“Temperament” deviates at more than one level. Line 23 deviates in meaning. The father’s speech deviates in layout: where prose would use quotation marks, the poem sets his four lines in from the margin (lines 14–17), so that his voice is marked by space rather than punctuation. Each departure makes part of the poem stand out against the rest, which the chapter on structure calls foregrounding. Deviation is one of the main ways a text tells its reader where to look.

The idea needs care, because a departure is always a departure from some norm, and the choice of norm can be unfair. The Penang blog post ends with a comment from the grandmother who founded the stall, typed by her granddaughter:

Mei say I must write something. Thank you everybody, forty-one years. Thursday I come. Don’t let her put too much starch.

“Same umbrella, new hands”, paragraph 19

Measured against standard British or American English, “Mei say” and “Thursday I come” break rules of grammar. Measured against the Malaysian English that the stall’s customers speak, shaped by the languages around it, they follow a variety with rules of its own, and nothing in them deviates. Calling them deviant would treat one variety as the measure of all the others. A better norm is the one the text itself sets. The post is written in Mei’s standard English, with Malay and Hokkien words left in, and against that background the grandmother’s comment does stand out. It brings the founder’s own voice into a text written for her, and its short sentences sound like the kitchen orders of paragraph 7.

Can style be separated from what a text says?

Every reading of style rests on an assumption about how style relates to content, and readers have held two opposite views. The older view treats style as the clothing of a thought that exists before the words. Alexander Pope put it in one line of An Essay on Criticism (1711): “Expression is the dress of thought”. On this view, the same content could be dressed in other words, and analysis asks why these clothes were chosen. The opposing view holds that the words are the thought. Cleanth Brooks, in the essay “The Heresy of Paraphrase” in The Well Wrought Urn (1947), argued that a poem cannot be restated in other words without losing what it means, so that a paraphrase is never the poem itself.

He turned the pin the width of a hair
till it slowed, and slowed, and stopped.

“Temperament”, lines 11–12

A paraphrase of these lines would say that the father tuned the string. It would keep the event and lose the slowing: the repeated “slowed” and the three-word close make the sentence lose speed exactly as the beat does. A paraphrase of the whole of “Temperament” might say: a woman remembers her father, a piano tuner, and keeps his untuned piano. Almost everything analyzed so far disappears: the 42-word sentence of waiting, the piano that exists only as “Ours” and “it”, the simile that returns without its like. Brooks’s view fits the poem. The heat leaflet, by contrast, paraphrases with little loss: drink water, keep cool, check on others, call 000 in an emergency. A text whose purpose is to pass its content on is written to survive paraphrase, and Pope’s view describes it well.

Linguists have found a working position between the two. Geoffrey Leech and Mick Short, in Style in Fiction (1981), treat style as choice: a writer chooses among alternatives that say roughly the same thing, and the differences between those alternatives are where style becomes visible. The father’s “Tune one key pure and you can’t play the rest.” (line 17) could have been “A perfect key spoils the others”. The comparison makes his plain second person, the voice of a man teaching a trade, easy to see. Their position keeps Pope’s idea that content can be held steady long enough to compare ways of saying it, and Brooks’s insistence that the ways are never quite equivalent. If two wordings meant exactly the same, the choice between them would not matter, and there would be nothing to analyze.

The judgment that serves analysis best is a matter of degree. Style and content can be separated far enough to compare a text with what it might have said, and no further. The Penang post sits between the poem and the leaflet. Its notice paraphrases easily (reopening Thursday at six, stall 14), but its brackets, “(it is a long story)” (paragraph 10), do not, because they carry the family’s voice rather than its information. How much of a text survives paraphrase is a fair measure of how much its meaning depends on style, and therefore of how much an analysis of it should say about style.

Writing about structure and style

A strong paragraph about structure or style makes a claim about a pattern and proves it from several places in the text, because a pattern cannot be shown in a single quotation. The paragraph that follows is about how the comment thread under the Penang blog post shapes the post’s meaning, written as a strong student might write it.

The comment thread under “Same umbrella, new hands” reads less like a set of separate replies than like the post continued by its community, because its words keep returning to the post’s own.note 1 Mei’s reply to Uncle Bala, “Extra chilli, of course” (paragraph 15), keeps the promise of paragraph 8, where his “extra chilli without him needing to ask” is listed among the things that stay the same.note 2 The day the post announces is repeated across the thread by all three generations of the family, from Mei’s “See you Thursday” (paragraph 11) to Papa’s invitation to try the small portion “on Thursday” (paragraph 18) and Ah Ma’s “Thursday I come” (paragraph 19).note 3 Even the one complaint is drawn into the chain: Jason T.’s “RM11 for small??” (paragraph 17) is answered with the post’s own reason, that oysters cost more. Through these links the thread turns a business notice into evidence of a community, so that by the last comment the reopening has been agreed to rather than merely announced.note 4

  1. A claim about structure. The first sentence names a pattern across the whole thread and states its effect, so the paragraph has an argument to prove.

  2. Cohesion located. A repeated phrase is traced from the post into a reply, with both places cited.

  3. A chain, not a single quotation. Three voices repeating one word show the pattern across the thread, which one example could not.

  4. Meaning, not mechanics. The last sentence says what the cohesion does for the post’s purpose instead of naming the device again.

The paragraph uses a technical idea, cohesion, without letting the term stand in for the analysis; the word is not even needed. The same discipline separates a weak sentence about style from a strong one. The two sentences that follow describe the style of “Temperament”.

Weak: The poet uses a simple and emotional style to show how she feels about her father.note 1

Strong: The style of “Temperament” refuses to name feeling: across 31 lines the speaker reports objects, numbers and her father’s words, so that “I have his ear” (line 28), itself her mother’s claim, is the nearest the poem comes to confession.note 2

  1. Two impressions, one of them wrong. “Simple” and “emotional” are impressions, and the second is mistaken: the poem contains no word of emotion at all.

  2. A pattern with its evidence. The sentence names what recurs and what is absent, and quotes the one line where the pattern almost breaks.

Applying it in Paper 1

Paper 1 texts are unseen and non-literary, and their structure is usually the clearest sign of their purpose. A guiding question may ask how a text is organized to achieve its aims, how its structure shapes the reader’s response, or how the writer’s style creates a particular voice. Each of these invites a claim about arrangement or pattern, proved from several places in the text. The Penang post, for example, gives its regulars “this Thursday, 4 September” (paragraph 5) before anything else, and saves its thanks and its invitation for the end.

A strong thesis on the post might read: “The post is ordered like news, then like a letter to friends, so its changes arrive inside a relationship.” The commonest way to lose marks is to describe structure by walking through the text in order, paragraph by paragraph, which narrates the arrangement instead of explaining it. A close second is a one-word verdict on style (“informal”, “conversational”) that is never connected to a choice or an effect.

Structure is also easier to see at speed than word choice. In the first minutes of reading an unseen text, labeling each paragraph or section in three or four words gives a map of its arrangement, and the places where the map changes direction are usually where the analysis should begin.

Structure and style lead on to the question of how texts follow and break the conventions of their forms and types, where an arrangement is read against the arrangement a reader expects. They lead too to the pages on the blog as a text type and on poetry as a form, each of which has its own units and its own ways of ordering them.

Self-check

  • To do:

    I can show how one text uses arrangement at the scale of the sentence, the unit and the whole.

  • To do:

    I can describe a writer’s style as a pattern of choices, with evidence counted and quoted.

  • To do:

    I can trace a chain of cohesion through a text and explain what the reader supplies to make it coherent.

  • To do:

    I can compare the order of a news report with the order of a blog post and say what each serves.

  • To do:

    I can explain how foreshadowing prepares a later meaning in a play and in a non-literary text.

  • To do:

    I can identify linguistic deviation and say which norm a feature departs from.

  • To do:

    I can set out Pope’s, Brooks’s and Leech and Short’s views of style and reach a judgment of my own.

Key terms

Each is also in the Readers, writers and texts glossary for IB English A Lang & Lit, beside the other terms of its topic.

Coherence

Coherence is the sense that a text makes as a whole, which a reader builds by connecting its parts through knowledge of the world and of the situation. A text can be coherent with few visible links, and cohesive yet hard to follow.

Cohesion

Cohesion is the set of visible links that tie a text’s sentences together: pronouns that refer back, repeated words, words from the same field and connectives. It can be pointed to on the page.

Foreshadowing

Foreshadowing is an early detail that prepares for a later event or meaning, so that the later moment feels prepared and a rereading finds it signaled. It often passes unnoticed on a first reading.

Linguistic deviation

Linguistic deviation is language that departs from the ordinary rules or habits of a language variety, in its words, grammar, meaning, sound or layout. It is one main way a text makes part of itself stand out.

Style

Style is the recognizable pattern of choices a writer makes across a text or a body of work, in words, sentences, structure and sound. It is described precisely by naming the recurring choices and what they do, rather than by a single label such as simple or flowery.

Stylistics

Stylistics is the study of style using the tools of linguistics. It describes the patterns of a text's language, often by counting and comparing features, and links them to the text's meanings and effects.

Practice questions on 1.5 How does the structure or style of a text affect meaning?

Augment’s own questions, written in the style of IB exam papers. Here is how a few of them start.

Question 1 · ENGALL-0000125 marks

Compare and contrast two of the literary works you have studied.

Writers often show conflict between characters through small things rather than open argument. How, and to what effect, is this done in two works you have studied?

Exemplars and marksSee them with a free account
Question 2 · ENGALL-0001120 marks

The following parody appeared in 2011 on “The Last Laugh”, the weekly satire page of The Sunday Calabash, an independent newspaper in Accra, Ghana, and is written in the form of a government press release.

Operation Free Flow a Resounding SuccessThe Last Laugh, the weekly satire page of The Sunday Calabash, an independent newspaper in Accra, Ghana, 2011Written for Augment Education
MINISTRY OF RIVERS, DRAINS AND ALLIED MATTERS
PRESS RELEASE · FOR IMMEDIATE RELEASE
OPERATION FREE FLOW A RESOUNDING SUCCESS: NSUOBI RIVER DECLARED CLEAN
ACCRA, 13 June 2011. The Ministry of Rivers, Drains and Allied Matters is pleased to announce the successful completion, ahead of schedule and within budget, of Operation Free Flow, the Government’s flagship programme for the restoration of the Nsuobi River to a condition befitting a modern capital city.

Write a guided analysis of the following text.

– How and to what effect does this parody use the conventions of an official press release?

You may answer the guiding question or set your own focus on a technical or formal aspect of the text.

Exemplars and marksSee them with a free account
Question 3 · ENGALL-0002320 marks

The following travelogue is taken from Far Edges, the long-read travel section of a British online magazine. It was published in 2018. A kgotla is the meeting place of a village in Botswana, where public meetings and customary court hearings are held in the open air.

Words at the KgotlaFar Edges, the long-read travel section of a British online magazine, 2018Written for Augment Education
Words at the Kgotla
In a village in central Botswana, a travel writer sits in on a trial and finds that he has been judging all along.
The charge
The goat was not in court. I had half expected it to be: a tethered witness by the acacia, chewing through the proceedings. Instead there was a semicircle of plastic chairs under a thatched shelter, a looser semicircle of younger men on upturned crates, a row of women on a low wall to one side, and, at the open end, the kgosi¹ in a grey suit and a felt hat, with a ledger on his knee. In the middle stood a young man of perhaps nineteen in a faded football shirt. He was accused of taking a neighbour’s goat and selling it at a cattle post².

Write a guided analysis of the following text.

– How and to what effect is structure used in this travelogue to represent a village court?

You may answer the guiding question or set your own focus on a technical or formal aspect of the text.

Exemplars and marksSee them with a free account

Practice all 14 questions on 1.5 How does the structure or style of a text affect meaning?

Free with an account. Write your answer, open the markscheme beside it and mark yourself. Augment keeps the ones you got wrong for another go.

1.5 How does the structure or style of a text affect meaning? questions by paper, with 6 in full

The English A Lang & Lit question bank, topic by topic

More in 1 Readers, writers and texts

The whole topic is on its own page.

  1. 1.1Why and how do we study language and literature?
  2. 1.2How are we affected by texts in various ways?
  3. 1.3In what ways is meaning constructed, negotiated, expressed and interpreted?
  4. 1.4How does language use vary among text types and among literary forms?
  5. 1.5How does the structure or style of a text affect meaning?This page
  6. 1.6How do texts offer insights and challenges?

Carry on with 1.5 How does the structure or style of a text affect meaning? in Augment

With a free account, Augment remembers where you stopped in the notes and which questions you have marked.