- Subjects
- English A Lang & Lit
- Rhetoric and persuasion
Rhetoric and persuasion
How texts persuade through credibility, feeling and reasoning, through patterns made for the ear, through degrees of certainty and the pronouns that place an audience, and through the shape and frame of an argument.
- IB English A: Language and Literature
- Analysis toolkit
- SL and HL
Rhetoric is the craft of persuading an audience: choosing what to say, in what order and in what words, so that listeners or readers come to think, feel or act as the speaker intends. It works in a campaign speech, an advertisement, a newspaper column and a courtroom statement alike, and its tools can be named, quoted and judged. Frederick Douglass’s Fourth of July oration, given in Rochester, New York, on 5 July 1852, is a speech in which a man who had escaped slavery tells an antislavery audience why he will not argue a case they already accept.
Questions an audience answers for itself
The extract opens with a run of questions, and Douglass waits for no reply to any of them. “Would you have me argue that man is entitled to liberty?” (paragraph 1) has only one possible answer, and the audience in Corinthian Hall knows it. A question asked for its effect rather than for information is a rhetorical question. Its effect here is to make the listeners supply the answer themselves, so that the conclusion feels like their own rather than the speaker’s.
The next sentence shows where the answer comes from: “You have already declared it” (paragraph 1). The Declaration of Independence, read aloud at Fourth of July celebrations across the country, states that all men are created equal and have a right to liberty. Douglass’s question turns the audience’s own founding document into the reply, on the day after the holiday that celebrates it.
Three kinds of question
The oration uses rhetorical questions in three different ways. Some accuse: “Must I argue the wrongfulness of slavery? Is that a question for Republicans?” (paragraph 1) suggests that anyone who treats the matter as open has forgotten what a republic is. The Republican Party did not yet exist, and in 1852 the word meant the citizens of a republic. Some cannot be answered at all: “Who can reason on such a proposition?” (paragraph 3) uses its italic, the printed trace of the speaker’s stress, to say that nobody decent could.
The third kind is answered by the speaker himself. “What, to the American slave, is your 4th of July? I answer;” (paragraph 5) asks the question the whole speech has been delaying, then supplies the reply: a short sentence, and after it a catalog of 79 words. The first two kinds close a question down; the third opens the one the audience has been waiting for. The extract is built on that difference, since paragraphs 1 to 3 ask and dismiss, and paragraph 5 asks and answers.
A rhetorical question works differently in drama, where the audience on stage can be shown answering it. In Shakespeare’s Julius Caesar (Act 3, Scene 2), Mark Antony speaks to a Roman crowd at Caesar’s funeral, after Brutus has defended the murder by calling Caesar ambitious. Antony reminds the crowd that Caesar refused a crown three times, then asks: “Was this ambition?” The crowd has just heard the evidence, so it answers against Brutus without Antony ever having to accuse him.
The same feature fails when the audience might answer the other way. Douglass could ask whether liberty needed arguing (paragraph 1) because his listeners belonged to an antislavery society, and their answer was certain. Put to a crowd that defended slavery, the same questions would have invited exactly the reply he least wanted. A rhetorical question is a wager on what the audience already believes, so an analysis has to say who the audience is before it says that a question persuades.
Refusing to argue
Paragraphs 1 to 3 have a strange shape for a speech against slavery. Each says that Douglass will not argue, and each then names the argument. Paragraph 2 opens with a single question of 86 words. It asks whether he must prove “that it is wrong to make men brutes”, then lists what slavery does: “to work them without wages”, “to flay their flesh with the lash”, “to sell them at auction, to sunder their families”. The sentence ends “is wrong? No! I will not.”
Drawing attention to something by saying that it will not be mentioned is praeteritio, from the Latin for “passing over”. Its advantage is that the speaker puts the whole case before the audience without the weakness of having argued it. Thirteen cruelties are named, each as a short verb phrase, and none is defended or proved, because the refusal treats proof as an insult. The listener hears the evidence and the speaker’s contempt for having to give it at the same moment.
Paragraph 3 gives the reason for the refusal:
What, then, remains to be argued? Is it that slavery is not divine; that God did not establish it; that our doctors of divinity are mistaken? There is blasphemy in the thought. That which is inhuman, cannot be divine! Who can reason on such a proposition? They that can, may; I cannot. The time for such argument is past.
Frederick Douglass, Fourth of July oration (1852), paragraph 3
An argument implies that the other side has a case worth answering. By refusing, Douglass denies the defenders of slavery the standing of a side at all. He also leaves his own audience in an awkward position. If arguing the case would be “to offer an insult to your understanding” (paragraph 1), then the nation’s failure to act on it is harder to excuse. The refusal is aimed at the friends in the hall as much as at the enemies outside it.
Antony uses the same move at Caesar’s funeral. He tells the crowd that he has not come to disprove what Brutus said, and then mentions Caesar’s will, which he says he should not read, until the crowd demands to hear it. Both speakers gain by declining. Douglass gains the authority of a speaker with “better employment for my time and strength” (paragraph 2) than debate. Antony gains an audience that asks for exactly what he came to give it.
Try it
In paragraph 3 Douglass asks whether he must prove “that our doctors of divinity are mistaken”. What is he refusing to argue here, and how do the next two sentences refuse it?
He is refusing to argue against the religious defense of slavery, made by ministers (“doctors of divinity”) who claimed that the Bible allowed it. “There is blasphemy in the thought” turns the charge around: the defense, not the refusal, is what offends God. “That which is inhuman, cannot be divine!” then settles in seven words what a sermon might take an hour to argue, and leaves the ministers nothing to answer.
Credibility, feeling and reasoning
Douglass’s oration persuades in three ways at once, and each can be found in its lines. The argument of paragraph 1 rests on the audience’s own principles: they have “already declared” that men are entitled to liberty, so slavery contradicts what they say they believe. The list in paragraph 2 works on feeling, through physical verbs such as flay, burn and starve. The whole extract also depends on who is speaking: a man who had been enslaved, telling free citizens that he has “better employment for my time and strength” (paragraph 2) than proving his own humanity.
The oldest account of these three means of persuasion is Aristotle’s Rhetoric, written in Athens in the fourth century BCE. Aristotle divided the means of persuasion that a speech itself provides into three: the character of the speaker (ēthos), the state of mind of the audience (pathos) and the argument (logos). Ethos is persuasion through the speaker’s credibility, pathos through the audience’s feelings, and logos through reasoning and evidence.
Douglass’s ethos in this extract owes little to stated credentials. He never says in these paragraphs that he was enslaved; his audience knew it, and the refusal to argue draws on that knowledge. A man who had escaped slavery does not need to prove that it is wrong, and his saying so carries an authority that no free-born speaker in the hall could claim. His pathos is equally exact. It names no single victim and tells no story, but the verbs of paragraph 2 make the audience feel each act on a body, so that a calm debate about slavery comes to seem obscene.
The diagram places one quotation from the oration at each corner of the triangle, with the speaker, the audience and the argument as the three points a speech connects. In the center sits a line from paragraph 1 that uses all three at once. “There is not a man beneath the canopy of heaven, that does not know that slavery is wrong for him” is an argument, since every man would refuse slavery for himself. Its italic stress asks each listener to imagine it, which is an appeal to feeling. And it is spoken by one man who knows from experience, which is ethos.


Experience as a credential
The ferry column, the Off the Wharf column in The Port Ellery Tide, a weekly newspaper in a harbor town in Nova Scotia, has to build its ethos from nothing. Its writer is a private person arguing against a council report, with no office and no expert title. The column’s first sentence is therefore its credential:
I have taken the Saturday ferry for eleven winters, most of them on the 8 a.m. sailing with a thermos and a list for the Co-op. In all that time I have never had the deck to myself.
“Keep the Saturday ferry”, paragraph 1
Eleven winters, an early sailing, a thermos and a shopping list make the writer an ordinary user of the boat, which is exactly the authority the argument needs. When the column needs more weight than one islander can carry, it borrows ethos from others. The ferry’s captain reports that half her summer deck comes from town (paragraph 10). A man on the wharf is quoted first and credited afterward: “He has been on the water for 40 years, which is longer than some of our councillors have been alive” (paragraph 11). The comparison adds a jab to the credential, so that years on the water are set against years in office.
The column’s pathos is quieter than Douglass’s. A 91-year-old woman’s hair appointment “every second Saturday since before the plant closed” (paragraph 7) moves readers by its smallness, and the column never tells them what to feel about it. Its logos works on the council’s own figure, the average load of each Saturday sailing, which it turns against the report. Each appeal is sized for a local audience that would distrust a speech.
Three appeals or one?
The three terms are tools for analysis, not three separate parts of a text. Aristotle treated them as working together, and the line about slavery being “wrong for him” (paragraph 1) shows how closely they can combine. In The New Rhetoric (French 1958, English 1969), Chaïm Perelman and Lucie Olbrechts-Tyteca went further. They argued that every argument is shaped by the audience it is meant to win, so that even logos is never neutral reasoning: it starts from what a particular audience already accepts.
Their position fits Douglass closely, since his logic works only because his listeners have “already declared” (paragraph 1) that liberty is a right. It does not make the three terms useless. They still name what a line is doing, provided an analysis shows how the appeals combine in that line rather than sorting quotations into three boxes. The TED-Ed lesson by Camille A. Langston sets out the three appeals with modern examples and adds a fourth idea from Greek rhetoric, the right moment for a speech.
YouTubePatterns made to be heard
A speech is heard once, at the speaker’s pace, so its argument is built into patterns that a listener can follow without seeing the page. Paragraph 4 of the oration names what the moment needs in three nouns of growing force: “We need the storm, the whirlwind, and the earthquake.” A sequence of three parallel words, phrases or clauses is a tricolon. Three is the smallest number that makes a pattern: two items are only a pair, while a third confirms the shape and lets it close.
Douglass’s tricolon in paragraph 4 also rises. A storm passes, a whirlwind destroys what it touches, and an earthquake breaks the ground on which everything stands, so each item is larger than the last and the sequence builds to a climax. The rise is the claim: protest must grow until something in the nation gives way. Rewritten as We need strong protest, the line says the same thing in plainer words and loses the sense of mounting force that the speech wants its audience to feel.
The same opening, again and again
Paragraph 5 uses a different pattern. Once Douglass has asked his central question, nearly every clause of the next sentence begins with the same word:
To him, your celebration is a sham; your boasted liberty, an unholy license; your national greatness, swelling vanity; your sounds of rejoicing are empty and heartless; your denunciations of tyrants, brass fronted impudence; your shouts of liberty and equality, hollow mockery
Frederick Douglass, Fourth of July oration (1852), paragraph 5
Repeating a word or phrase at the start of successive clauses is anaphora. The repeated your gives the sentence a beat that a hall can hear, and it does more than that. Each time the word comes round, it hands one more part of the holiday back to the audience as their own, until “your prayers and hymns, your sermons and thanksgivings” belong to them too. By the end of the sentence the listeners own everything Douglass has condemned.
Anaphora is as useful on the page. The ferry column answers the council’s word discretionary with three sentences that begin “It looks like” (paragraph 7): teenagers who work Saturdays, the food-bank volunteers, a dog, two hockey bags and a woman of 91. The repeated frame turns the paragraph into a row of exhibits, and each new “It looks like” adds someone the report did not count. The pattern is gentle where Douglass’s is relentless, which suits a writer who needs neighbors to agree rather than a nation to feel ashamed.
Opposites in balance
The third pattern sets opposites against each other in a balanced sentence. In paragraph 3 Douglass disposes of the religious defense of slavery in a single line: “That which is inhuman, cannot be divine!” The two key words, inhuman and divine, are set against each other, and the line makes the first rule out the second. This is antithesis: contrasting ideas set in parallel grammar, so that the balance of the sentence makes the opposition sharp. The same paragraph ends with a shorter one, “They that can, may; I cannot”, which turns the opponents’ readiness to argue into a moral failing.
The catalog of paragraph 5 is antithesis repeated until it becomes the structure of the sentence. Each boast is paired with what Douglass says it is: the celebration with a “sham”, national greatness with “swelling vanity”, “shouts of liberty and equality” with “hollow mockery”. Often the verb is left out, so the two halves meet with only a comma between them. The listener hears each pair as a verdict, with no room for a reply.
Ornament or persuasion
A pattern persuades when the argument would be weaker without it, and it is ornament when the argument would survive unchanged. The test is to rewrite the line plainly, as the tricolon was rewritten. Douglass’s storm, whirlwind and earthquake fail the test in the right way: the plain version loses part of the claim. The ferry column’s concession that “nobody at the Co-op thinks budgets grow on spruce trees” (paragraph 3) passes it. Its argument survives as Everyone knows the council must save money, so the joke adds nothing to the logic.
The joke still persuades, though, through ethos rather than logos. Bending a saying about money to the island’s “spruce trees” (paragraph 3) makes the writer sound like a neighbor with a sense of humor rather than an angry campaigner. A reader who smiles at it is more willing to hear the rest. A feature can be ornament for the argument and persuasion for the voice at the same time. An analysis should say which kind of work a feature does, rather than assuming that every pattern carries the case.
How certain a claim sounds
Every claim carries a degree of certainty, and the end of the oration pushes that degree as high as it can go. Paragraph 5 closes with a claim no one could prove: “There is not a nation on the earth guilty of practices, more shocking and bloody, than are the people of these United States, at this very hour.” Deliberate exaggeration for effect is hyperbole. In persuasion it carries a risk, because an audience that notices an overstatement may start to doubt everything else the speaker has said.
Douglass meets the risk by turning the hyperbole into a dare. Paragraph 6 sends each listener on a search “through all the monarchies and despotisms of the old world”. Then it asks them to “lay your facts by the side of the every day practices of this nation”. The speaker is sure the search will fail, and the paragraph ends on “America reigns without a rival”. Reigns is a monarch’s verb applied to a republic that was founded against a king, so the exaggeration closes on an irony the audience must work out for itself. By inviting a test, Douglass makes an overstatement sound like a finding.
The ferry column takes the opposite course. Where a protest leaflet might call the cut a disaster, the column says only that “Some of what it carries cannot wait until Monday” (paragraph 5). Its readers know the boat, the slip and the numbers, and one exaggeration they could check would cost the writer the credibility of eleven winters. Hyperbole suits an audience that already accepts the facts and needs to be shaken; it backfires with readers who have to be convinced and can check the details.
Modality: the small words of certainty
Most claims are set lower than Douglass’s, whose nation “must be roused” (paragraph 4), and English marks the setting with small words. A speech given in a courtroom shows how carefully a speaker can choose them. In March 1922 Mohandas K. Gandhi was tried in Ahmedabad, India, for sedition, for articles in his weekly paper Young India that attacked British rule. A few weeks earlier, at Chauri Chaura, a crowd had set fire to a police station and killed the policemen there, and Gandhi had called off his campaign of non-cooperation. Before reading his written statement, he spoke to the court:
He is quite right when he says, that as a man of responsibility, a man having received a fair share of education, having had a fair share of experience of this world, I should have known the consequences of every one of my acts. I knew that I was playing with fire. I ran the risk and if I was set free I would still do the same.
. . .
I do not ask for mercy. I do not plead any extenuating act.
. . .
but by the time I have finished with my statement you will perhaps have a glimpse of what is raging within my breast to run this maddest risk which a sane man can run.M. K. Gandhi, remarks before the court, Ahmedabad, 18 March 1922, as printed in Unity (Chicago), 4 May 1922, paragraphs 1 and 2
Words that set the degree of certainty or obligation in a claim express modality. Gandhi’s modality is unusual for a man on trial. He accepts the prosecutor’s judgment of him, “I should have known the consequences of every one of my acts”, in full and without softening; should marks a duty he failed, and he agrees that he failed it. He then commits himself with a conditional that holds no doubt: “if I was set free I would still do the same”. The sentences about mercy contain no modal verb at all, only flat denials, and they are the firmest in the passage.
The few places where Gandhi softens a claim are chosen as carefully. He tells the judge that by the end of his statement “you will perhaps have a glimpse” of what drove him. Perhaps and a glimpse lower the claim twice: he does not presume to make the judge understand, only to let him see a little. Lowering the certainty of a claim on purpose is hedging. Here it is a courtesy to the court, and it makes the unhedged sentences around it sound firmer still.
The sharpest contrast in Gandhi’s remarks uses modality as well. He calls his act “what in law is a deliberate crime and what appears to me to be the highest duty of a citizen” (paragraph 2). The law receives the plain verb is; his own conviction receives the hedged appears to me. By granting the law its certainty and claiming only his own view, he makes the larger claim, that duty can stand above law, hard to dismiss as arrogance.
Public health writing chooses its modality for a different reason. The heat-wave leaflet from Kelverton Health, a community health service in Melbourne, opens: “Very hot weather can make anyone sick, and it can make health problems worse.” Can is exact: heat does not make everyone ill, and the leaflet cannot promise that its advice prevents every case. Where the danger is certain, the modal verb disappears and the leaflet gives an order in bold type: “Never leave children, older people or pets alone in a car.” The diagram places five of these lines on a single scale, from Gandhi’s hedged perhaps to the leaflet’s command.


Is hedging a weakness?
Hedging has often been read as a lack of confidence. In Language and Woman’s Place (1975), the linguist Robin Lakoff argued that hedges such as sort of and I guess signal uncertainty, and that women were taught to use them more than men. Janet Holmes, in an article of 1984 on hedges in recorded speech, argued that many hedges do other work: they soften a claim to protect the listener’s feelings, or invite the listener into the conversation. On this view a hedge can show care rather than doubt.
Holmes’s position fits Gandhi’s remarks better than Lakoff’s. His “you will perhaps have a glimpse” (paragraph 2) comes from a speaker who is otherwise categorical, so it reads as courtesy, not insecurity, and it is placed where courtesy costs him nothing. Lakoff’s point keeps its value as a warning, since a speaker who hedges every claim does sound unsure. The useful question about any hedge is what it protects: the speaker, the listener, or the honesty of a claim that cannot be fully proved.
Try it
Paragraph 4 of Douglass’s oration contains the sentence “O! had I the ability, and could I reach the nation’s ear, I would, to day, pour out a fiery stream” of denunciation. How certain is this sentence, and why would a speaker who is plainly able choose it?
The modality is low and conditional: had I, could I and I would place the action in an imagined world where the speaker has the ability and the whole nation listening. The modesty is a convention of oratory, and it is not meant to be believed. The sentence does what it says it cannot: it pours out a list of denunciations in its own words, and the paragraphs that follow are the denunciation it claims to be unable to give.
We, you and they
Pronouns decide where an audience stands in relation to a speaker. A speech on a national holiday might be expected to say we: we the citizens, we who celebrate. Douglass’s oration almost never does. In paragraph 5 the holiday is “your 4th of July”, the celebration is “your celebration”, and its meaning is given “to him”, the enslaved man. The pronouns divide the hall into three groups: the speaker, the free citizens he addresses, and the enslaved people for whom he speaks.
The division is part of the argument. A man who could not share the nation’s liberty refuses to share its first person plural, and every your tells the audience that they own what the speech condemns. The one we in the extract shows the other use of the pronoun. “We need the storm, the whirlwind, and the earthquake” (paragraph 4) speaks for everyone who wants slavery ended. It recruits the antislavery audience into the speaker’s cause at the moment he is condemning the nation they belong to.
A first-person plural that draws the audience into the speaker’s group is an inclusive pronoun. You and they, used to hold people outside the group, work as exclusive pronouns. Many speeches move between the two, and the moves are worth tracking, because each one changes who is being praised, blamed or asked to act.
The ferry column depends on stretching its we. Early on, the pronoun means the whole community, which keeps a fire hall it hopes not to need: “We keep it for the afternoon that isn’t quiet” (paragraph 5). When the column turns to readers in town, it switches to direct address:
If you live in town and have never crossed, this is your boat too.
“Keep the Saturday ferry”, paragraph 10
The sentence gives the boat to readers who may have thought of it as the island’s problem. The last sentence then closes the circle with a promise to “keep filling it” (paragraph 13). There the first-person plural means the islanders again, offering their side of a bargain to everyone else in return for a vote. Each change of pronoun moves one group of readers into or out of the argument, and the column ends with both groups bound by the same verb, keep.
The shape of an argument
Douglass’s oration is built on a refusal, but most persuasive texts follow an argument with a recognizable shape. The ferry column states its position in the headline, “Keep the Saturday ferry”, and then works through parts its readers would recognize from any debate. Before it argues anything, it grants the other side a point:
I will grant the council this much: $212,000 is real money in a district our size, and nobody at the Co-op thinks budgets grow on spruce trees. Deputy Mayor Ruth Mosher has been straight with us about the numbers.
“Keep the Saturday ferry”, paragraph 3
Admitting the strength of an opposing point is a concession; answering it is a rebuttal. The column’s concession is generous and specific: the saving is real, and the deputy mayor has been honest. It costs the writer little, because the column never disputes the saving. It disputes what the report counted, and the rebuttal follows at once: “But look at what the report actually counted” (paragraph 4). By conceding the money and contesting the measure, the column sounds fair while giving away nothing it needs.
The diagram maps the column’s eight moves in order, from the claim to the call to action, “Come and fill it” (paragraph 12). The order matters as much as the parts. The concession comes early, before readers have been asked to agree to anything, so that the writer’s fairness is established first. Evidence from the slip comes before the reframing of the ferry as a road, and the call to the public hearing comes after the last voice from the wharf, when the case is complete and only action remains.


Douglass’s oration breaks the shape on purpose. It contains no concession at all, since to grant the other side a point would be to admit that slavery had a side worth hearing. Its rebuttals are refusals, such as “I will not” (paragraph 2), and its evidence arrives inside a question that says no evidence is needed. An analysis that looks for claim, evidence, concession and rebuttal in every persuasive text will miss texts like this one, where the missing part is the point.
Framing and selection
Before any argument begins, a text decides what the issue is. The council’s report presents the Saturday boat as a cost, measured by its average load, and its words follow from that: under-used, discretionary. The column objects to a habit in the council chamber of speaking of the ferry “as if it were a private yacht we had asked the town to pay for” (paragraph 9). Presenting an issue within a chosen set of ideas, so that some conclusions seem natural and others hardly arise, is framing. The council’s frame makes the boat a favor to a few islanders; the column’s reply, that the ferry is “the island’s road”, makes it public infrastructure, and the chapter on diction traces the vocabulary of roads that follows.
Framing works through selection: what a text chooses to count, show or name. The report’s figure, “an average of 58 passengers” (paragraph 4), is accurate, and the column never says otherwise. An average, though, hides the one Saturday that matters, just as the fire hall’s quiet afternoons hide the day it is needed. The column’s own selection is equally deliberate. Of everyone on the slip, it names workers, volunteers and a woman of 91, and it leaves out anyone whose Saturday trip could wait.
Framing has been studied most closely in politics. In Don’t Think of an Elephant! (2004), the linguist George Lakoff discussed the phrase tax relief, which spread from the White House of George W. Bush into news reports in the early 2000s. Relief assumes an affliction, so the phrase frames taxes as a burden and whoever removes them as a rescuer; anyone who argues against “tax relief” has already accepted the frame. Lakoff’s advice was to answer a frame with a different frame rather than by denying it. The ferry column does exactly that when it stops disputing the word “under-used” (paragraph 4) and calls the boat a road.
A word that carries a judgment inside what looks like a description is loaded language, and relief is one. The council’s under-used is another: it sounds like a measurement and works as a verdict. Spotting such words is the first step in seeing a frame, and the opinion column’s own page takes the matter further.
Images frame an issue too. The Tidemark Hardware & Marine advertisement in the same newspaper places a coil of rope, made fast to a cleat, above a headline claiming that the shop knows the ropes. The picture turns an idiom about experience into a literal claim about what the shop sells. How a picture, its crop and its layout persuade is the subject of the chapter on reading images and layout.
Writing about rhetoric
A paragraph about rhetoric names a feature only on the way to saying what it does to a particular audience. The paragraph that follows, as a strong student might write it, is about paragraph 5 of Douglass’s oration.
Douglass answers the question his speech has delayed for four paragraphs by dividing his listeners from the people he speaks for.note 1 The holiday becomes “your 4th of July” and its meaning is given “to him”, so the free citizens in Corinthian Hall hear themselves addressed from outside their own celebration.note 2 The catalog that follows pairs each part of the festival with its opposite, “your celebration is a sham; your boasted liberty, an unholy license”, and the anaphora of “your” hands the blame back to the audience at every clause.note 3 Because these listeners already opposed slavery, the aim is not to convert them but to unsettle them: their principles do not exempt them from a nation whose “shouts of liberty and equality” are “hollow mockery”.note 4
A claim about purpose. The opening sentence states what the paragraph of the speech does, in terms of its audience, before any feature is named.
Pronouns as evidence. Two short quotations prove the division, and the sentence says where it leaves the listeners.
Two features, one effect. Antithesis and anaphora are named only as the means of a single effect, the blame returned to the audience.
Audience and context. The last sentence uses what is known about the Rochester audience to judge the speech’s aim, which is where an analysis of rhetoric earns its conclusions.
Each sentence of the paragraph does a different job, and none names a feature without its effect. The same habits separate a weak sentence from a strong one about a single choice. The two sentences that follow are about paragraph 2 of the oration.
Weak: Douglass uses a long list and pathos to make the audience feel sad about how bad slavery is.note 1
Strong: Claiming that he will not argue the wrong of slavery, Douglass names thirteen of its cruelties anyway, so the audience hears the whole case without the insult of being asked to judge it.note 2
Labels without a reason. A long list and pathos could describe hundreds of speeches, and “feel sad” is a weaker feeling than the passage aims at. Nothing in the sentence belongs to these lines.
Choice, means, effect. In 33 words the sentence describes the choice (the refusal to argue), the means (the thirteen cruelties) and its effect on this audience, and it explains why refusing to argue persuades more than arguing would.
The strong sentence never uses the word pathos, though it describes an appeal to feeling exactly. It explains the mechanism instead: the refusal lets the list stand as evidence that needs no proof. A sentence about rhetoric is strongest when it says how the feature works on this audience, so that the term, if it appears, confirms an explanation already given.
Applying it in Paper 1
Many Paper 1 texts are written to persuade: opinion columns, speeches, appeals, advertisements and campaign leaflets. A guiding question such as In what ways does the writer try to win the support of readers who do not live on the island? directs attention to the features of the ferry column traced here. They include the borrowed ethos of the captain and the man on the wharf, the concession before the rebuttal, the frame of the road, and the turn to readers in town with “this is your boat too” (paragraph 10). A thesis might read: The column wins readers in town by conceding the council’s numbers, then reframing the ferry as a road that serves them too, so that keeping it becomes their interest as well as the island’s.
The commonest way to lose marks is to organize the essay by appeal, with one paragraph on ethos, one on pathos and one on logos, each with a quotation. That structure sorts the text instead of following its argument, and it hides the order of the writer’s moves, which is often the most persuasive choice in the text. A stronger essay follows the stages of the argument and names the appeals inside them. The other common loss is to forget the audience. “Would you have me argue that man is entitled to liberty?” persuades only listeners who give the expected answer, and an essay has to say who those listeners are.
Rhetoric leads directly to the speech and the opinion column, where these features are read as conventions of a whole text type, and to the appeal and the manifesto, where persuasion turns into a demand for action. The question of how texts affect their audiences, and why the same speech can move one listener and leave another cold, takes the idea further.
Self-check
- To do:
I can explain ethos, pathos and logos and show how one line can use more than one of them.
- To do:
I can identify the kind of a rhetorical question and say what its answer, given or withheld, does for its audience.
- To do:
I can explain how praeteritio lets a speaker present a case while refusing to argue it.
- To do:
I can analyze tricolon, anaphora and antithesis and judge whether a pattern persuades or only decorates.
- To do:
I can describe how hyperbole, modality and hedging set the certainty of a claim, and why a speaker chooses that degree.
- To do:
I can track inclusive and exclusive pronouns and say how they place an audience.
- To do:
I can trace the shape of an argument and explain how framing and selection decide what an audience sees.
- To do:
I can write a sentence that links a rhetorical choice to its audience, its purpose and its effect.
Key terms
Each is also in the IB English A Lang & Lit glossary.
- Anaphora
Anaphora is the repetition of a word or phrase at the start of successive clauses, sentences or lines. It gives a passage a strong beat and makes each new item feel like one more step in the same direction.
- Antithesis
Antithesis is the setting of contrasting ideas against each other in balanced, parallel grammar. The balance of the sentence makes the opposition between the ideas sharp and memorable.
- Ethos
Ethos is persuasion through the credibility of the speaker or writer. An audience is moved to accept a claim because it trusts the experience, character or authority of the person making it.
- Framing
Framing is presenting an issue within a chosen set of ideas, words and facts, so that some conclusions seem natural and others hardly arise. It works through what a text selects to count, show or name.
- Hedging
Hedging is the deliberate softening of a claim to make it less certain or less direct. A speaker may hedge to be cautious, polite or honest about the limits of what can be proved.
- Hyperbole
Hyperbole is deliberate exaggeration for effect, a statement larger than the literal truth. In persuasion it can stir an audience but risks its trust if the overstatement is noticed and doubted.
- Inclusive pronoun
An inclusive pronoun is a first-person plural pronoun that draws the audience into the speaker's group. Its opposite, an exclusive pronoun, holds the audience or others outside the group the speaker belongs to.
- Logos
Logos is persuasion through reasoning and evidence. A text sets out facts, figures, examples or steps of argument so that its conclusion seems to follow.
- Modality
Modality is the degree of certainty, possibility or obligation that a statement expresses. It is carried mainly by modal verbs and by adverbs of certainty, and it shows how strongly a speaker commits to a claim.
- Pathos
Pathos is persuasion through the feelings of the audience. A text rouses emotions such as pity, anger, pride or fear so that the audience is moved toward the speaker's view.
- Praeteritio
Praeteritio is drawing attention to something by saying that it will not be mentioned or argued. The speaker puts a point before the audience while appearing to pass over it.
- Rhetoric
Rhetoric is the craft of persuading an audience through the choice and arrangement of words, arguments and appeals. It covers how a text tries to make its audience think, feel or act in a particular way.
- Rhetorical question
A rhetorical question is a question asked for its effect rather than to get information. It may expect an obvious answer, have no possible answer, or be answered at once by the speaker, and in each case it leads the audience toward a conclusion.
- Tricolon
A tricolon is a sequence of three parallel words, phrases or clauses. Three items complete a pattern that an audience can hear and remember, and they often rise in force toward the last.
Analysis toolkit for English A Lang & Lit
- 1Diction and tone
- 2Imagery and figurative language
- 3Structure and form
- 4Sound and rhythm
- 5Rhetoric and persuasionThis page
- 6Narrative voice and point of view
- 7Reading images and layout
More IB English A Lang & Lit notes
Carry on with English A Lang & Lit in Augment
With a free account, Augment remembers where you stopped in the notes and which questions you have marked.