- Subjects
- English A Lit
- 1 Readers, writers and texts
- 1.6 How do literary texts offer insights and challenges?
1.6 How do literary texts offer insights and challenges?
How literature gives insight by making the familiar strange and other lives visible, and challenges readers through satire, moral ambiguity, paradox, difficulty and theater that refuses comfort.
- IB English A: Literature
- Part of 1 Readers, writers and texts
- SL and HL
Notes on 1.6 How do literary texts offer insights and challenges?
Literature gives insight by making readers see differently, and it challenges them by refusing to let them stay comfortable. Both effects are designed: a text that unsettles has chosen how to unsettle, and the choices can be analyzed like any others. Michel de Montaigne wrote “Of the Caniballes” around 1580, after meeting three men from Brazil who had been brought to France. In John Florio’s English translation of 1603, its account of a people Europeans called savages becomes a way of looking at Europe.
Making the familiar strange
The essay’s last paragraph describes the society of the Tupinambá almost entirely by what it lacks. It is a nation that has “no kinde of traffike, no knowledge of Letters, no intelligence of numbers, no name of magistrate, nor of politike superioritie” (paragraph 8). The list runs on through riches, poverty, contracts, inheritance and wine. Each item is something Europeans of 1603 took for granted as part of any civilized life.
The catalog works by subtraction. Trade, writing, government, property and servants are named one after another as things a society can do without, and once they are listed as additions they stop looking like necessities. The final item goes further: “The very words that import lying, falshood, treason, dissimulations, covetousnes, envie, detraction, and pardon, were never heard of amongst them” (paragraph 8). Europe’s vices appear here as vocabulary, words the European language needs because European life produces the things they name. An essay that promised an account of strangers ends by describing the familiar world as if from outside.
Making the familiar strange, so that it is seen afresh, is defamiliarization. The Russian critic Viktor Shklovsky gave the idea its name in “Art as Technique” (1917). Habit, he argued, makes people stop perceiving the things they live among; art exists to restore perception, “to make the stone stony”. His main examples came from Tolstoy, who described familiar things as if seeing them for the first time. In the story “Kholstomer” the narrator is a horse, to whom the human idea of owning another creature makes no sense, and Tolstoy’s account of flogging describes the act so plainly that its cruelty, hidden by custom, becomes visible.
Montaigne uses the same device three centuries before it had a name. His first paragraph turns on the word savage. People call the Brazilians savage, he says, “as we call those fruits wilde, which nature of her selfe, and of her ordinarie progresse hath produced” (paragraph 1). Then the comparison reverses itself: the fruits that Europeans have altered “by our artificiall devices” are the ones “we should rather terme savage”. The word that was supposed to describe others now describes Europe, and Montaigne’s audience is made to stand outside its own vocabulary.
Insight into other lives
Defamiliarization shows the familiar world differently. Literature also claims to show unfamiliar worlds from inside, and that claim has a long history. George Eliot, in an essay of 1856, “The Natural History of German Life”, argued that the greatest debt owed to artists is the extension of sympathy. “Art is the nearest thing to life”, she wrote: a way of “amplifying experience” beyond the limits of a single life. Her own novels set out to make readers feel for ordinary, unheroic people they would otherwise overlook.
How dissonant would hee finde his imaginarie common-wealth from this perfection?
Montaigne, “Of the Caniballes”, tr. John Florio (1603), paragraph 8
Montaigne’s essay shows both the power and the limit of that claim. Its last sentence calls the Brazilians’ society a “perfection” that would shame Plato’s ideal republic. The word is generous, and it is also a distortion. Montaigne never went to Brazil; he relies on a servant who had lived there and on three visitors he met through an interpreter. The people he praises become a mirror held up to Europe, and the essay sees Europe more clearly than it sees them. An idealized portrait of another culture can be as distant as a hostile one.
The limit has been argued directly. The critic Suzanne Keen, in Empathy and the Novel (2007), questioned the claim that empathy with fictional characters makes readers kinder in real life, finding little evidence that what is felt while reading leads to action. Eliot’s claim survives in a smaller form. Literature can let someone inhabit another perspective for the length of a book, and that is a real insight. It is an insight into the text’s version of a life, however, made by a writer with purposes of their own.
Case study: “A Modest Proposal”
Jonathan Swift published “A Modest Proposal” in Dublin in 1729, after several years of failed harvests had left many of Ireland’s poor close to starvation. It looks like one of the many pamphlets of its time in which a “projector” offered a scheme to improve the economy, and its title page is laid out like one.

The title page shows the disguise before a word of the argument is read. Its language is the language of policy: children who are a “Burthen” to their parents and country are to be made “Beneficial to the Publick”. Nothing in it is unusual for 1729. The horror lies in what “beneficial” will turn out to mean, and the title’s calm, official phrasing is the first layer of the irony.
A reasonable voice
The pamphlet is spoken by a persona, an invented proposer who is not Swift. He is sober, numerate and sure of his good intentions. He opens with real distress, the beggars “followed by three, four, or six children, all in rags”. Then he spends several paragraphs calculating: of a million and a half people, about two hundred thousand couples whose wives are “breeders”, and a hundred and twenty thousand children born each year to poor parents. Only then, in the ninth paragraph, does he make his proposal:
I have been assured by a very knowing American of my acquaintance in London, that a young healthy child well nursed, is, at a year old, a most delicious nourishing and wholesome food, whether stewed, roasted, baked, or boiled; and I make no doubt that it will equally serve in a fricasee, or a ragoust.
Jonathan Swift, “A Modest Proposal” (1729), paragraph 9 (Project Gutenberg text)
The shock comes from the gap between the subject and the voice. The sentence offers cannibalism in the tone of a cookery book, moving from health to flavor to a list of recipes, and the French dishes at the end make it sound almost refined. The delay matters as much as the tone. Eight paragraphs of reasonable concern have earned the proposer some trust, so the proposal arrives inside a frame of good sense, and the reader has to recognize the horror unaided.
The language of numbers
The proposer’s vocabulary is the essay’s real target. He calls mothers “breeders”, reckons a child under twelve as “no saleable commodity” (paragraph 7), and speaks of “carcasses” for export (paragraph 27). These are the words of the cattle market and the ledger, and they were the words of serious economic writing in Swift’s time. By applying them literally to human beings, the pamphlet makes visible what that language had already done: treated the poor as numbers to be managed. Swift’s irony works by taking an existing way of speaking one step further than its users would go.
I grant this food will be somewhat dear, and therefore very proper for landlords, who, as they have already devoured most of the parents, seem to have the best title to the children.
“A Modest Proposal”, paragraph 12
This sentence shows where the satire points. The word “devoured” is literal in the proposal and metaphorical in Ireland’s reality: landlords have consumed the poor through rents, and the proposal only completes what they began. The gap between what is said and what is meant is verbal irony, and here it widens into a whole argument. The diagram sets out its layers: what the proposer says, what the reader recognizes, and the targets the recognition exposes.


The real remedies, rejected
Near the end the proposer lists other ideas he will not hear of: taxing absentee landlords, buying only Irish goods, curing pride and vanity, “teaching landlords to have at least one degree of mercy towards their tenants”. Several of these were remedies Swift had argued for himself, as in his pamphlet of 1720 urging the Irish to use only goods made in Ireland. Placing them in the mouth of a man who dismisses them as impractical makes the essay’s point by contrast. The sensible remedies are plain and possible; the public has ignored them; the monstrous one is offered as the only “solid and real” plan left. The proposer’s last sentence insists that he has nothing to gain, since his youngest child is nine and his wife “past child-bearing”, and the claim of disinterest is the final irony.
Writing that attacks folly or vice through ridicule, irony and exaggeration, usually to provoke change, is satire. Swift’s method is the naive mask: a speaker who does not see what he is saying, so that the reader must see it for him. The insight the essay gives is about language as much as policy. Once “breeders” and “carcasses” have been heard applied to children, the same words in a real economic report sound different.
The risk of irony
Satire depends on recognition. Anyone who misses the signals, or who shares the proposer’s assumptions, can take the pamphlet for a sincere scheme. The history of irony is full of audiences who took a satirist literally. Swift’s calm voice gives the essay both its force and its risk: nothing on the surface says that the author disagrees. To understand the essay at all, a reader has to supply the moral judgment the text withholds, and in doing so takes part in its argument.
Try it
Read the proposer’s last sentence: “I have no children, by which I can propose to get a single penny; the youngest being nine years old, and my wife past child-bearing.” Why does Swift end here?
The sentence is a claim of disinterest of the kind a real projector would make, to prove that his scheme serves the public, not himself. But the claim shows what the proposer is: a man who measures even his own children by the profit they might bring, and who considers them safe only because they are too old to sell. The essay ends by turning its irony on the proposer’s own family, so the logic of the market is shown to reach everywhere, even into the speaker’s home.
Texts that teach and texts that unsettle
Some literature aims openly to teach. Tolstoy’s “How Much Land Does a Man Need?” ends with its lesson in a single measurement, “Six feet from his head to his heels was all he needed”, and the story’s meaning is in no doubt. A short narrative that teaches a moral or spiritual lesson by analogy is a parable, and the aim of teaching through literature is didacticism. Its classic forms include Aesop’s fables with their stated morals, the medieval morality play Everyman, in which a man summoned by Death finds that only his Good Deeds will go with him, and the improving tales written for Victorian children.
Didactic is often used as an insult, but a parable’s clarity is a choice with its own art. Tolstoy’s story works through a structure that makes the lesson feel inevitable. The real distinction is between texts that hand over a conclusion and texts that leave the conclusion open. Satire sits between the two. George Orwell’s Animal Farm (1945) uses the oldest didactic form, the beast fable, to attack the betrayal of the Russian Revolution, and its last commandment needs no explanation:
ALL ANIMALS ARE EQUAL BUT SOME ANIMALS ARE MORE EQUAL THAN OTHERS
George Orwell, Animal Farm (1945), chapter 10: the single commandment left on the barn wall
The commandment is a sentence that contradicts itself, and the contradiction is the lesson: equality has been kept as a word and abandoned as a fact. Orwell’s fable teaches, but it teaches through a joke the reader has to get. The diagram places six works on a line from texts that teach to texts that unsettle. A work’s position describes its method, and says nothing about its quality.


Moral ambiguity and the antihero
Further along the line are works that ask readers to stay close to people they cannot approve of. Fyodor Dostoevsky’s Crime and Punishment (1866) follows Raskolnikov, a poor former student in St Petersburg who murders an old pawnbroker. In Constance Garnett’s translation of 1914, the novel enters his mind on the first page, before saying what he plans:
“I want to attempt a thing like that and am frightened by these trifles,” he thought, with an odd smile. … “Am I capable of that? Is that serious? It is not serious at all.”
Fyodor Dostoevsky, Crime and Punishment, tr. Constance Garnett (1914), Part I, chapter 1
The novel withholds what “that” is, so the reader shares Raskolnikov’s nervous, self-mocking thoughts before learning that they are about killing someone. By the time the murder comes, his reasoning has been the novel’s medium for chapters, and that closeness is its challenge. Raskolnikov is intelligent, generous to strangers, ill and vain, and he has a theory that extraordinary people may step over moral law. A character or situation that resists a clear moral judgment shows moral ambiguity.
Raskolnikov is an antihero: a protagonist without the conventional qualities of a hero who still holds the reader’s attention and some of their sympathy. The antihero turns judgment back on the person judging. A reader who finds herself hoping that Raskolnikov will escape detection has learned something uncomfortable about how sympathy works, and the novel has designed that discovery. An analysis that treats that discomfort as a flaw in the book misses what the book is doing.
Paradox and black comedy
Some challenges are packed into a single sentence. Montaigne’s opening paragraph claims that the fruits Europeans call wild are the natural ones, and that the cultivated fruits “which our selves have altered by our artificiall devices” are those “we should rather terme savage” (paragraph 1):
They are even savage, as we call those fruits wilde, which nature of her selfe, and of her ordinarie progresse hath produced: whereas indeed, they are those which our selves have altered by our artificiall devices, and diverted from their common order, we should rather terme savage.
Montaigne, “Of the Caniballes”, tr. Florio (1603), paragraph 1
The claim seems to contradict itself, since the cultivated fruit cannot be the wild one. Thought through, it holds a truth: on Montaigne’s terms, what Europeans call civilization is a corruption of nature, and the word savage describes the people who use it. A statement that seems self-contradictory but holds a truth is a paradox. Paradox challenges because it cannot simply be accepted or rejected; it has to be worked out, and working it out changes the meaning of the words involved.
Paradox becomes the engine of a whole novel in Joseph Heller’s Catch-22 (1961). Its American airmen in the Second World War learn that a man who asks to be excused from flying missions because he is insane must be sane, since only a sane man would ask, and so he must fly. The rule is absurd and the deaths it causes are real, and the novel invites laughter at both. Comedy drawn from death, suffering or taboo is black comedy. Its challenge is to make the laughter itself a judgment: the laugh comes first, and the question of what made the horror funny comes after it. Joe Orton’s play Loot (1966), in which a dead woman’s body is hidden so that her coffin can hide stolen money, uses the same discomfort on the stage.
Difficulty and theater that refuses comfort
Some writers challenge readers by being hard to read. T. S. Eliot argued in “The Metaphysical Poets” (1921) that poets in modern civilization “must be difficult”, because a complex world needs a poetry that can hold its complexity. Difficulty on this view is a demand for attention, not a failure of communication. The challenge is to habits of reading: a text that cannot be read quickly has to be read differently.
The theater, where an audience usually expects to be moved, found its own ways to refuse comfort. Bertolt Brecht’s Mother Courage and Her Children was first performed in Zurich in 1941. It follows a woman who trades from a cart behind the armies of the Thirty Years’ War and loses all three of her children while trying to profit from the war. Brecht did not want his audience to weep for her. He interrupted the action with songs, announced what each scene would show before it began, and asked actors to present their characters as if quoting them. The aim was to keep the audience at a distance, so that it would judge the war and the trade that fed on it.
Brecht’s methods of preventing an audience’s identification with the characters, so that it thinks critically instead, are known as the alienation effect. Their effect depends on performance, and the National Theatre’s introduction shows them on the stage in a way a page cannot.
YouTubeSamuel Beckett’s Waiting for Godot (first performed in Paris in 1953, in English in 1955) withholds meaning instead of comfort. Two tramps wait by a tree for a Godot who never arrives, pass the time with talk, games and two strange visitors, and at the end of each act decide to leave:
Yes, let’s go.
They do not move.Samuel Beckett, Waiting for Godot (1954), the end of each act
The words and the stage direction contradict each other, and the play ends twice on that contradiction. The audience waits with the tramps for an event the play never supplies, and the waiting becomes the experience. The critic Vivian Mercier summed it up in 1956 as a play in which nothing happens, twice. Martin Esslin grouped Beckett with Eugène Ionesco and others in The Theatre of the Absurd (1961), naming drama that presents a universe without meaning through circular action, broken logic and repetition. The theater of the absurd challenges the audience’s need for a story that adds up, and the discomfort of that refusal is its subject.
Where readers disagree: instruct, delight or unsettle?
The oldest answer to the question of what literature is for comes from the Roman poet Horace, whose Art of Poetry (late first century BCE) put it in one line:
aut prodesse volunt aut delectare poetae
Horace, Ars Poetica, line 333: “poets wish either to benefit or to delight”
Horace added that the poet who mixes the useful with the pleasant wins every vote. For centuries this was the standard defense of literature: it teaches, and it makes the teaching agreeable. On this view the parable and the fable are literature at its most complete, and Swift’s satire is a bitter medicine sweetened with wit.
Franz Kafka, aged twenty, answered differently in a letter to his friend Oskar Pollak in January 1904. He wrote that books which make people happy could be written by the readers themselves at a pinch, and that what is needed are books that strike like a disaster. The passage reaches its most famous sentence: “Ein Buch muß die Axt sein für das gefrorene Meer in uns”, a book must be the axe for the frozen sea within us. For Kafka the value of literature lay in its power to break what habit had frozen, which is close to what Shklovsky meant by defamiliarization, and far from Horace’s delight.
A third position denies that the question is a moral one at all. Oscar Wilde’s preface to The Picture of Dorian Gray (1891) declared: “There is no such thing as a moral or an immoral book. Books are well written, or badly written. That is all.” On this view a text neither teaches nor unsettles in any way that matters to judgment. It is made well or badly, and morality belongs to its audience, not to the book.
Each position fits some works and not others. Horace describes Animal Farm well and Waiting for Godot poorly. Kafka describes Crime and Punishment and “A Modest Proposal”, whose shocks are designed to break a reader’s complacency, but he undervalues the quieter insight of a parable. Wilde is right that a work’s effects depend on its making, and wrong if he means that how a book treats suffering has no moral weight. The most useful position for a student is the analytical one: whether a work instructs, delights or unsettles, the effect is made by choices, and the choices can be shown. Being challenging says nothing about a text’s quality. The useful question is how the challenge is built and what it is for.
Writing about a text that challenges
A text that disturbs its reader invites two weak responses: a complaint about the content, or a summary of what is shocking. A strong response treats the discomfort as an effect and traces it to its causes. The learner portfolio is the natural place to record that process, including a view that changed. The entry that follows was written by a student after a second reading of “A Modest Proposal”.
On my first reading I thought the proposal was simply grotesque and could not see why the essay is admired.note 1 Rereading paragraphs 6 and 7, I noticed that the words that shocked me most, “breeders” and “no saleable commodity”, appear before the proposal itself, in the proposer’s calm account of the economy.note 2 Swift has made me hear the ordinary language of policy first, so that by paragraph 9 the cannibalism sounds like its natural conclusion. My view changed from disgust at the essay to discomfort at the words it borrows, which I now notice in reports about “human resources”.note 3 The challenge is in the order: Swift lets the vocabulary be accepted before showing where it leads.note 4
A first response, named honestly. The portfolio records the original view instead of hiding it, so the change can be traced.
Evidence that caused the change. The student points to particular words and their position in the essay, the textual reason for rereading.
The change stated precisely. The new view is specific, and the student tests it against language outside the text, which is what insight means in practice.
From reaction to analysis. The last sentence turns the experience into a claim about how the essay is built.
The entry is written in the first person, as a portfolio entry may be, but it never lets the reaction replace the analysis. The same move, from what a text made the student feel to how the text made it, is the one an essay needs. The two sentences that follow are about Raskolnikov.
Weak: Raskolnikov is an evil murderer and Dostoevsky shows that crime is wrong.note 1
Strong: By keeping Raskolnikov’s plan unnamed as “that” while letting the reader share his nervous jokes, Dostoevsky draws the reader into sympathy with a killer before the killing, so the novel’s moral challenge is aimed at the reader’s own judgment.note 2
A verdict and a moral. The sentence judges the character and reduces the novel to a lesson it never states, missing the moral ambiguity it builds.
The method of the challenge. The rewrite names the narrative choice (the withheld “that”, access to his thoughts) and says whom the challenge is aimed at.
Analyzing a challenging text is not the same as agreeing with it. An essay can explain exactly how Swift’s proposer makes cannibalism sound reasonable without endorsing a word of it, and it can explain how Crime and Punishment makes a murderer sympathetic without excusing murder. The distinction runs in the other direction too. Montaigne’s praise of the Brazilians as a “perfection” (paragraph 8) is generous, and a careful reading can still name it as idealization. Keeping three positions apart, the speaker’s, the writer’s and the student’s own, is what allows a student to write calmly and precisely about material that disturbs.
Try it
A student writes: “I found Waiting for Godot boring because nothing happens.” Rewrite the sentence so that it treats the experience as a designed effect.
One possible rewrite: “Beckett builds the audience’s boredom into the play’s structure: each act ends with the tramps agreeing to leave and staying where they are, so the audience shares their waiting and feels the absence of the event it expected.” The rewrite keeps the student’s experience but traces it to a choice (the repeated ending) and says what the choice does.
Applying it in the individual oral
The individual oral asks how one global issue is presented in two works, one written in English and one studied in translation, through an extract from each. Challenging works make strong orals because their discomfort is usually tied to a real issue. “A Modest Proposal” and Crime and Punishment make a strong pair on one: the reasoning that weighs human lives as sums. Swift’s proposer reckons children as stock; in Part I of Dostoevsky’s novel Raskolnikov overhears a student argue that killing one useless old woman would save a hundred lives, an arithmetic he has been making himself.
The oral’s risk with such works is moralizing: ten minutes of saying that cannibalism and murder are wrong. What the criteria reward is analysis of how each writer builds the challenge. A model spoken sentence might be: “Both writers let a reasonable voice do the arithmetic, Swift through a proposer who never raises his tone and Dostoevsky through the student in the tavern whose logic Raskolnikov already shares, so in both extracts the horror lies in how sensible the sums sound.” The sentence names a shared method, gives each writer’s version, and says what the method does to the issue.
The oral is the same task at SL and HL, weighted differently.
The challenge a text offers depends on who reads it and when. That leads to questions of context and reception: what a text meant to its first audience, and how its insights and its shocks change over time.
Self-check
- To do:
I can explain defamiliarization and show it working in a passage.
- To do:
I can explain what insight a text into another life can give, and where that insight stops.
- To do:
I can analyze how “A Modest Proposal” builds its satire through a persona, its vocabulary and its order.
- To do:
I can distinguish didactic texts and parables from texts that leave their questions open, without treating either as better.
- To do:
I can explain moral ambiguity, the antihero, paradox and black comedy with examples.
- To do:
I can describe how the alienation effect and the theater of the absurd refuse an audience comfort.
- To do:
I can write about a challenging text by tracing the discomfort to its causes, and record how my own view changed.
Key terms
Each is also in the Readers, writers and texts glossary for IB English A Lit, beside the other terms of its topic.
- Alienation effect
Bertolt Brecht's name for the methods that stop an audience from identifying with the characters, such as songs, announced scenes and actors who show their roles, so that the audience judges what it sees instead of losing itself in the story.
- Antihero
A protagonist who lacks the conventional qualities of a hero, such as courage or virtue, yet still holds the reader's attention and some of their sympathy.
- Black comedy
Comedy drawn from death, suffering or taboo subjects, which makes the audience laugh at what is terrible and then consider why it laughed.
- Defamiliarization
The technique of presenting something familiar as if it were strange, so that a reader sees it freshly instead of through habit. The term comes from the Russian critic Viktor Shklovsky (1917).
- Didacticism
The aim of teaching a lesson through literature, either by stating it or by designing the work so that the lesson is clear.
- Moral ambiguity
The quality of a character or situation that resists a clear moral judgment, so that the reader is left weighing sympathy against condemnation.
- Parable
A short narrative that teaches a moral or spiritual lesson by analogy, so that events stand for a truth about how to live.
- Paradox
A statement that seems to contradict itself but, when thought through, holds a truth. Working out the contradiction changes the meaning of the words involved.
- Satire
Writing that attacks folly or vice by making it ridiculous or monstrous, through irony, exaggeration and often a naive voice, so that the audience recognizes its target and condemns it.
- Theater of the absurd
Drama, mostly of the 1950s and 1960s, that presents a world without meaning through circular action, broken logic and repetition; the name comes from the critic Martin Esslin (1961).
Practice questions on 1.6 How do literary texts offer insights and challenges?
Augment’s own questions, written in the style of IB exam papers. Here is how a few of them start.
Practice all 17 questions on 1.6 How do literary texts offer insights and challenges?
Free with an account. Write your answer, open the markscheme beside it and mark yourself. Augment keeps the ones you got wrong for another go.
1.6 How do literary texts offer insights and challenges? questions by paper, with 6 in full
More in 1 Readers, writers and texts
The whole topic is on its own page.
- 1.1Why and how do we study literature?
- 1.2How are we affected by literary texts in various ways?
- 1.3In what ways is meaning constructed, negotiated, expressed and interpreted?
- 1.4How does language use vary among literary forms?
- 1.5How does the structure or style of a literary text affect meaning?
- 1.6How do literary texts offer insights and challenges?This page
More IB English A Lit notes
- 1.5 How does the structure or style of a literary text affect meaning?Before this in the syllabus.
- 2 Time and spaceNext in the syllabus.
- English A Lit exam formatEach English A Lit paper, how long it is and its share of the grade.
- IB English A LitThe English A Lit syllabus, how it is assessed and every notes page.
Carry on with 1.6 How do literary texts offer insights and challenges? in Augment
With a free account, Augment remembers where you stopped in the notes and which questions you have marked.