2.4 How does the meaning and impact of a literary text change over time? questions for IB English A Lit

14 questions on How does the meaning and impact of a literary text change over time?, written by Augment in the style of IB exam papers. Six of them are below in full, to answer on paper.

  • IB English A: Literature
  • Part of 2 Time and space
  • SL and HL

Questions by paper and level

SL and HL questions are for students at either level. HL only questions cover what only HL students study.

PaperSL and HLHL onlyAll
Paper 1707
Paper 2707
Every paper14014

Counted on

Questions to try

Written by Augment in the style of IB exams, not past papers. Answer them on paper, then check each one against its markscheme with a free account.

Question 1 · ENGAL-00023Paper 1 · 20 marks
Thursday NightThe Lower Notes, a play from Lahore, 1970sWritten for Augment Education
The drawing room of a house in Model Town, Lahore. A Thursday evening in November. On a side table stands a large valve radio under a crocheted cover. Above it, a framed photograph of a man in a Jinnah cap. A wall clock. AMMI sits on the divan shelling peas into a steel bowl. SHAHEEN comes in from the street in a white nurse’s uniform with a dupatta over it. She takes off her shoes at the door.
AMMIYou’re late. The peas are nearly finished.
SHAHEENEmergency was full. A bus went into the canal at Mozang.
AMMIAnyone dead?
SHAHEENTwo. One was a boy.
She sits beside AMMI and takes a handful of pods from the bowl. JAVED enters from inside the house. He has a newspaper folded small in one hand.
JAVEDShaheen.
SHAHEENBhai Jan. You’re home early.
JAVEDDr Rizvi stopped me in the corridor today. He wanted to tell me how much his wife enjoys Thursday nights.
Pause. SHAHEEN splits a pod with her thumbnail.
JAVEDNaseem Ara. The new voice. Very fine in the lower notes, Mrs Rizvi says. The newspaper says so too.
He unfolds the newspaper and reads.
JAVED“A voice of unusual sorrow, whose owner Radio Pakistan has so far declined to name.”
AMMIJaved, sit down. You make the room small.
JAVEDMrs Rizvi’s cousin works in the recording room. She has told the whole of Gulberg. So tonight Rizvi knows, and tomorrow the Medical Superintendent knows, and the day after that the Qureshis know.
SHAHEENThe Qureshis don’t listen to the radio. They have a television.
JAVEDDon’t.
He puts the newspaper down on the radio.
JAVEDHow long?
SHAHEENSince March.
JAVEDMarch. Eight months you have been walking out of this house to the hospital, and from the hospital to the studio. In your uniform.
SHAHEENI change in the ladies’ room.
JAVEDOh, then it is all right.
SHAHEENIt is one hour on a Tuesday afternoon, Bhai Jan. I swap my shift with Sister Agnes. She thinks I go to the dentist.
JAVEDSo Sister Agnes is also lying for you.
SHAHEENSister Agnes is not lying. She thinks I have very bad teeth.
AMMI laughs, once, and stops.
JAVEDAmmi, this is funny?
AMMIYour sister is funny. She has always been funny. You were the serious one.
JAVEDSomebody in this house has to be.
He turns to the photograph.
JAVEDAbbu sat at that table every night for twenty years writing other people’s accounts so that one of us would be a doctor and one a nurse. Not a singing girl in a studio.
SHAHEENI am a nurse. I was a nurse this morning. I was a nurse at four o’clock when they brought the boy up from the canal.
JAVEDAnd at nine o’clock you are Naseem Ara.
SHAHEENAt nine o’clock I am here, shelling peas.
The clock shows five minutes to nine. AMMI puts down the bowl. She gets up, lifts the crocheted cover off the radio and folds it. She moves the newspaper to one side.
JAVEDAmmi, what are you doing?
AMMI turns the knob. The radio hums as the valves warm.
JAVEDAmmi.
JAVED crosses and turns the knob back. The hum dies. Silence. AMMI looks at him. She turns the knob again.
AMMIIt is my radio.
JAVEDIt is Abbu’s radio.
AMMIHe bought it the year we married. Nineteen fifty-one. He carried it in from the tonga himself, in a blanket, like a bride.
She smooths the folded cover.
AMMII used to sing in the kitchen then. My mother’s songs, the wedding ones. He liked it. Then one day his brother came for lunch and heard me through the wall, and that evening your father brought home this. He said, now you will not need to sing yourself. The radio will sing for you.
Pause.
JAVEDThat is not the same thing.
AMMINo. It is not the same thing.
The hum grows. A burst of static, then a tanpura drone.
SHAHEENBhai Jan. It doesn’t matter.
JAVEDOf course it matters.
SHAHEENThis is the last one. I recorded it last week. I told them on Monday I won’t come again.
Pause.
JAVEDYou told them.
SHAHEENOn Monday.
JAVEDBefore Rizvi.
SHAHEENBefore Rizvi.
JAVEDThen why did you let me —
SHAHEENYou didn’t ask me anything, Bhai Jan. You read me the newspaper.
From the radio, a man’s voice.
ANNOUNCER(on the radio) This is Radio Pakistan, Lahore. In our programme of ghazals for Thursday night, we present once again Naseem Ara.
The tanpura continues. A woman’s voice begins to sing, low. It is SHAHEEN’s voice. Nobody in the room moves.
JAVED goes to the radio. He puts his hand on the knob and keeps it there.
AMMI picks up the steel bowl and holds it out to him.
AMMISit. Finish these.
JAVED takes his hand from the knob. He takes the bowl. He sits at the far end of the divan with the bowl on his knees. He does not shell the peas.
SHAHEEN sits with her hands in her lap. The voice on the radio goes on singing.

Write a guided analysis of the following text.

The following extract is from the play The Lower Notes. It is set in Lahore, Pakistan, in the 1970s. Shaheen, a nurse, lives with her mother, Ammi, and her elder brother, Javed, a doctor; their father has died.

Guiding question: How does the playwright use the radio to build tension within the family in this extract?

Use the guiding question or propose an alternative technical or formal aspect of the text to focus your analysis.

Exemplars and marksSee them with a free account
Question 2 · ENGAL-00185Paper 2 · 25 marks

How, and to what effect, do two works you have studied present a desire that changes the person who feels it?

Exemplars and marksSee them with a free account
Question 3 · ENGAL-00057Paper 1 · 20 marks
Number Seven BlueThe Hall Stand, a collection of essays from Auckland, 1980sWritten for Augment Education
The painting hangs in my hallway now, between the coat hooks and the meter box, which is about where it hung in my grandfather’s house in Grey Lynn for twenty-six years. It is a view of Rangitoto from the beach at Mission Bay, eighteen inches by twenty-four, in a frame he made himself from an offcut of rimu skirting. It is a painting by numbers. I want to say that at the beginning, because for most of my life I did not.
When I was small I thought it was the best painting in the world, and that Grandad had made it the way God made the island, out of nothing. I used to stand on the hall runner with my nose almost touching the glass and try to find the place where he had started. I never could. The sky ran into the hills and the hills into the water, and there were tiny boats with a fleck of white each for a sail, and on the beach two people, a man and a woman, too small to have faces.
When I was fourteen our art teacher brought a kit like it to school, in a lesson on what she called kitsch, and I went home on the bus with my face hot. Nana had died by then. Grandad was making toast. I looked at the painting in the hall and saw, for the first time, the faint blue lines under the paint, the ghost of a map, and in one corner of the sky, where he had missed a patch, a small printed 3. I did not say anything. For the next few years, when friends came round, I walked them past the hall quickly, the way you might hurry a guest past a relative who drinks.
Grandad had been a wharfie until 1951, and after 1951 he did whatever he could get: painting houses, mostly, other people’s weatherboards in other people’s colours. He did not talk about the year of the lockout, and in our family you did not ask. I knew only that there had been a long winter when Nana took in washing and he went out every morning anyway, in his good coat, and came home at night with nothing to report. The kit, my mother told me later, was a present from Nana in the late fifties, when things were better. ‘Something to do with his hands that wasn’t for anybody,’ she said.
He left it to me. There was nothing else in the will to speak of, so it was not a large honour, but it was a particular one, and I was twenty-six and living in a flat in Mt Eden where the landlord did not allow nails. I wrapped it in a beach towel and put it on top of the wardrobe. It stayed there for most of a year.
What brought it down again was the lid. My mother, clearing out the shed in Grey Lynn, found the box the kit had come in and posted it to me with a note that said only Thought you should have this. On the lid was the picture the kit was meant to make. The sky was the same. The island was the same, and the boats, and the couple with no faces. But the sea on the lid was a bright, even, swimming-pool blue, number 7 on the key, and the sea in my grandfather’s painting is not. It is grey-green, darker towards the island, with a brown stain along the sand where a stream comes in after rain, and if you look closely you can see that he has painted over every 7 in a colour that is not in the key at all. He must have mixed it. He would have had to buy the paints separately, from the hardware shop, and carry them home.
I do not know why he did it. I would like to say it was defiance, a wharfie’s quiet answer to a world that had told him what he was allowed to do with his hands. But it may simply be that he had looked at that harbour every working day of his life and knew what colour it was. Neither of those is a thing he would have said.
It hangs in my hall now. Friends who come round are walked past it slowly. The ones who know about art say, kindly, ‘Oh, painting by numbers,’ and I say yes, and wait to see whether they notice the water. Most of them do not. In the corner of the sky the small 3 is still there, under nothing. I have thought about filling it in, and I have not.

Write a guided analysis of the following text.

This is an extract from The Hall Stand, a collection of essays. The essay is set in Auckland, New Zealand, in the 1980s.

Guiding question: In what ways does the writer use a single object to present the grandfather and his life?

Use the guiding question or propose an alternative technical or formal aspect of the text to focus your analysis.

Exemplars and marksSee them with a free account
Question 4 · ENGAL-00244Paper 2 · 25 marks

Referring to two works you have studied, explore how much the writers settle, and how much they leave open, in the final moments of each work.

Exemplars and marksSee them with a free account
Question 5 · ENGAL-00078Paper 1 · 20 marks
The Rain GaugeQuarter Section, a novel from Manitoba, 2010sWritten for Augment Education
For most of the first year after Gerry died I read the rain gauge every morning at seven, and since I have been asked about it more than once, I may as well set down why. The reason I gave at the time was the record. Gerry had read that gauge every morning since the spring of 1981, and he wrote what it said in a Co-op notebook, one notebook a year, and phoned the numbers in to Winnipeg, where they went on a map that as far as I know nobody looked at. Thirty-four years without a gap, I told people. It seemed a shame to break it now.
People liked that reason. Pastor Friesen liked it so much he put it in a sermon, though he had the gauge on the wrong side of the house. Our daughter Karen phoned from Calgary on Sundays and asked, Mom, are you still doing the rain thing, in the voice she uses for her own kids when they are doing something she has decided to allow.
It is not much of a job. The gauge is a plastic tube on a post at the end of the shelterbelt, where Gerry put it so the spruce wouldn’t shelter it and the house wouldn’t either. You walk out, you crouch, you read the line, you tip it out on the grass and put it back. Then you write. Gerry wrote in tenths of an inch, because he had never given in to metric, and the girl in Winnipeg converted it for him. I wrote in millimetres. I told myself it saved the girl a job. Beside his numbers, all down the margins, Gerry had kept his remarks, hail like peas on the north quarter, first swaths, geese, so that the notebooks were a sort of diary of a man who did not keep a diary. My margins stayed empty. I had nothing to say to the margin.
In August Darcy Penner came to talk about the land. He is the middle Penner boy, though he must be forty. He sat at my table with his cap on his knee and talked about cash rent and canola prices and what Gerry would have wanted, which he had apparently discussed with Gerry at some length at the elevator. I let him. Then I said a number, which was forty dollars an acre more than his, and he looked at his cap a while and said that would be fine, Mrs. Thiessen. On his way out he stopped at the window over the sink, where you can see the post. “You still reading that thing?” “Somebody has to,” I said. He said Gerry had told him once he could set his watch by it. I said Gerry never wore a watch.
Darcy combined our three quarters at the end of September, mostly at night, with lights on the header, so that from the kitchen it looked like a small town was moving very slowly across the field. I didn’t take out coffee. I had taken out coffee for thirty-four harvests, in the green thermos with the dent, and I found I didn’t have to, and I sat in the dark with the yard light off and watched the town go up and back. The next morning there was nothing in the gauge, and I wrote 0, and then in the margin, for the first time, I wrote: Penner on the NW. It looked like his writing. I had not meant it to.
In November I went down to the basement to put the year’s notebook with the others, on the shelf over the deep freeze, the years on the spines in marker. I don’t know why I opened 1997. I knew what I would find, I suppose, or I wouldn’t have. That was the flood spring, when the Red came up over everything south of Winnipeg and they were sandbagging in Morris. You would think a man who read rain for a hobby would want that spring, of all of them, on paper. From the eleventh of April to the second of May there is nothing. Not a zero. Not a line. The pages are just blank, and then on the third of May his writing starts again, the same as ever, as if nothing had stopped.
Those were the weeks I was at my sister’s in Brandon. I am not going to go into that here. It is enough to say that I took the car, and he had the truck, and that when I came back the dishes were done and the gauge was on its post and neither of us said a word about either. I had always supposed he went on reading it. It had not once occurred to me, in eighteen years, that he hadn’t.
I sat on the steps with the book. The freezer came on and went off. I went up and got the pencil from the drawer by the phone, came back down, and in the margin beside those three empty weeks I wrote, small, in my own hand: Brandon. I did not write anything else. It is still there, if anyone wants it. I read the gauge until the snow came, and in the spring I bought a new notebook, and some mornings now I go out and some mornings I don’t. Karen has stopped asking.

Write a guided analysis of the following text.

The following extract is from the novel Quarter Section.

Guiding question: How does the narrator’s looking back shape what she reveals and what she keeps to herself?

Use the guiding question or propose an alternative technical or formal aspect of the text to focus your analysis.

Exemplars and marksSee them with a free account
Question 6 · ENGAL-00258Paper 2 · 25 marks

How, and to what effect, do two works you have studied use dialogue to bring conflicting values into the open?

Exemplars and marksSee them with a free account

Practice all 14 in Augment

Free with an account. Every question has its markscheme, and Augment keeps the ones you got wrong so you can come back to them.

The notes on 2.4 How does the meaning and impact of a literary text change over time?

More questions in Time and space

  1. 2.1How important is cultural or historical context to the production and reception of a literary text?
  2. 2.2How do we approach literary texts from different times and cultures to our own?
  3. 2.3To what extent do literary texts offer insight into another culture?
  4. 2.4How does the meaning and impact of a literary text change over time?This page
  5. 2.5How do literary texts reflect, represent or form a part of cultural practices?
  6. 2.6How does language represent social distinctions and identities?

Check your answers in Augment

A free account opens all 14 questions on How does the meaning and impact of a literary text change over time? with their markschemes, and keeps a record of what you have marked.