3.5 How can texts offer multiple perspectives of a single issue, topic or theme? questions for IB English A Lang & Lit

13 questions on How can texts offer multiple perspectives of a single issue, topic or theme?, written by Augment in the style of IB exam papers. Six of them are below in full, to answer on paper.

  • IB English A: Language and Literature
  • Part of 3 Intertextuality: connecting texts
  • SL and HL

Questions by paper and level

SL and HL questions are for students at either level. HL only questions cover what only HL students study.

PaperSL and HLHL onlyAll
Paper 1909
Paper 2404
Every paper13013

Counted on

Questions to try

Written by Augment in the style of IB exams, not past papers. Answer them on paper, then check each one against its markscheme with a free account.

Question 1 · ENGALL-00005Paper 1 · 20 marks

The following manifesto is taken from the website of Steenberg Stemmen (“Voices of the Heap”), a residents’ heritage group in a former coal-mining town in Belgian Limburg. It was published in Dutch and in English in 2023.

A Manifesto for the HeapSteenberg Stemmen (Voices of the Heap), the website of a residents’ heritage group in a former coal-mining town in Belgian Limburg, 2023Written for Augment Education
Behind our town stands a hill that nobody planted. It is ninety metres of stone that the mine did not want: the waste rock that came up with the coal for sixty years and was tipped, wagon by wagon, until it was taller than the church. The mine closed in 1992. The heap stayed. We are the people who grew up in its shadow, and on the tenth anniversary of our group we have rewritten what we believe about it.
1. We are not one memory. Some of us remember the mine as the place that fed us, bought the first car and sent the first child to university. Some of us remember it as the place that took our fathers’ lungs at fifty-five. Both memories are true. Neither will be cut down to fit the other, and no plaque we put up will choose between them.
2. We were invited. Our grandparents came from Abruzzo and Silesia, from the Anatolian plateau and the Rif mountains, from Flemish farms twenty kilometres away. They came because men in suits travelled to their villages with contracts. We refuse to be told that we arrived. We were sent for, and we stayed.
3. We speak in the languages we were spoken to in. Underground, our grandfathers gave orders in a mixture of Flemish, Italian, Polish and Turkish that no school ever taught and no dictionary records. Above ground, they were told to speak Dutch. This manifesto is published in Dutch and in English, but at our meetings anyone may speak in any language, and someone will translate.
4. We will not tidy the heap. Birch trees have grown on its slopes without anyone’s permission. Natterjacks¹ breed in the pools at its foot. Some of us want paths, benches and a viewing platform. Some of us want it left exactly as the mine left it, black and steep. Some of us want it to become a forest and forget that it was ever anything else. We have not agreed, and we will not pretend that we have.
5. We remember the women. For its first seven years this manifesto had no point five. The heap was a story of men going down, told by men who had come back up. It left out the women who scrubbed the coal dust out of collars every night, who ran the boarding houses for single miners, who learnt three languages at the market before their husbands learnt one. Their memory is not a footnote to the mine. Without it, there would have been no town for the mine to belong to.
6. We will not become a museum. A museum puts the past behind glass so that it cannot answer back. We are aware that we run a small museum in the old wash-house, and that we are asking the council for money to make it bigger. We are aware of the contradiction. We would rather live with it than solve it by closing the doors or by locking the past inside them.
7. The young owe us nothing. Many of our grandchildren have never been down a mine and never will be. Some climb the heap only to run up it on Sunday mornings with a watch on their wrist. They are welcome. A body running up ninety metres of waste rock remembers something, even if it does not know what.
8. Where we disagree, we will say so in public. Heritage is usually written by the people who won the argument. We want ours written by the people who are still having it.
This manifesto was adopted at the general meeting of 14 October 2023 by forty-one votes to six, with three abstentions. The six who voted against have asked us to print their reason, and we do: “A manifesto should say what we are, not list everything we cannot agree on.”

¹ natterjacks: small, rare toads that breed in shallow pools.

Write a guided analysis of the following text.

– How is the collective “we” used in this manifesto to hold together different memories of the mine?

You may answer the guiding question or set your own focus on a technical or formal aspect of the text.

Exemplars and marksSee them with a free account
Question 2 · ENGALL-00054Paper 2 · 25 marks

Compare and contrast two of the literary works you have studied.

With regard to two works you have studied, examine how objects that people make or own are given conflicting meanings.

Exemplars and marksSee them with a free account
Question 3 · ENGALL-00105Paper 1 · 20 marks

The following travelogue was published in 2019 in Slow Atlas, a British quarterly magazine of travel writing, whose writers are sent to spend time in one place rather than tour many.

The Ring and the FaceSlow Atlas, a British quarterly magazine of travel writing, 2019Written for Augment Education
The Ring and the Face
In Baghdad during Ramadan, the city stays up late to play a game with a single ring. Our writer went to watch, and ended up being watched.
The first thing I learned about mheibes is that I would never be good at it. The second thing I learned is that this did not matter in the slightest.
It was past eleven at night in the second week of Ramadan, and the courtyard behind a sports club in eastern Baghdad was fuller than any room I had been in since landing. Two teams of men, perhaps forty on each side, sat facing each other in long rows on plastic chairs and carpets. Between them, on a low table, stood trays of zalabia, the syrup-soaked sweets that would go to the winners. Behind them stood everybody else: boys on their fathers’ shoulders, teenagers holding up phones, a television crew with a light so bright that the men on the front row kept shielding their eyes.
The rules, as my guide Rana explained them, take one breath to say. One team hides a ring in the closed fist of one of its players. The other team’s leader must find it. He walks along the row, studies faces, orders some players to open their hands and others to keep them shut, and narrows forty fists to one. If he finds the ring, his team scores. If he guesses wrong, the other side scores and the ring goes back into hiding.
“So it is a guessing game,” I said.
Rana laughed. “Tell that to Abu Haidar.”
Abu Haidar was the leader of the home team, a retired schoolteacher of about seventy who had been playing, he told me later, since before the television was invented, which I chose to believe. When he stood up, the courtyard went quiet in the way a theatre does. He did not hurry. He stopped in front of one young man for so long that the young man began to laugh, then pointed at the man beside him instead. “Open.” The fist was empty. “Open.” Empty. He waved half the row away with the back of his hand, as if brushing crumbs off a table.
“It is not guessing,” he said to me afterwards, tapping his own cheek. “The hand can lie. The face cannot. Even the face that is trying very hard not to tell you anything is telling you that.”
For the younger players, the game was something else. Mustafa, who is twenty-three and drives a taxi, had come with his whole street. “When I was a child, nobody played,” he said. “It was not safe to sit outside so late. Now every district wants to beat every other district.” He held up his phone to show me a video of last year’s final, which had more views than anything I have ever written. For him mheibes was football with hands: a team, a rivalry, a trophy and a chance to be seen.
The organiser, a tired, cheerful man with a clipboard, gave me a third version. “Sunni, Shia¹, Christian, it doesn’t matter in this courtyard,” he said. “Here everyone is only a hand.” It was a fine line, and I wrote it down, though I noticed that every hand in the rows belonged to a man, and that the women of the neighbourhood were watching from the roof of the building next door.
Near one in the morning, the visiting team offered me the ring.
I should explain that I have spent twenty years in other people’s countries learning to look calm. I have crossed borders with the wrong stamp in my passport and eaten things I could not identify while smiling at the cook. I closed my hand around the ring, looked at a point just above Abu Haidar’s head and thought about nothing at all.
He found me in eleven seconds. Mustafa timed it.
He did not even ask the rest of the row to open their hands. He walked straight to me, smiled as a doctor smiles, and said, in English, “You are holding your breath.” The courtyard roared. Somebody put a piece of zalabia in my other hand, which seemed unfair, since we had lost.
I had come to Baghdad, as travel writers do, to look at a city and describe it. I had not expected to spend the evening as the thing being read. On the drive back to the hotel, Rana asked whether I now understood the game. I said that I understood that I was bad at it. She said that was the first step.

¹ Sunni, Shia: the two main branches of Islam, both present in Baghdad

Write a guided analysis of the following text.

– How and to what effect does this travelogue present a game through the eyes of different people?

You may answer the guiding question or set your own focus on a technical or formal aspect of the text.

Exemplars and marksSee them with a free account
Question 4 · ENGALL-00113Paper 2 · 25 marks

Compare and contrast two of the literary works you have studied.

Referring to two works you have studied, discuss how a character is built from the conflicting accounts that others give of them.

Exemplars and marksSee them with a free account
Question 5 · ENGALL-00123Paper 1 · 20 marks

The following extract is taken from the screenplay of Release, a short film published in the online script library of the Sea Grape Script Lab, a program in Trinidad and Tobago that develops scripts by new Caribbean screenwriters.

ReleaseRelease, a screenplay for a short film, from the online script library of the Sea Grape Script Lab, Trinidad and Tobago, 2023Written for Augment Education
INT. ST. CLEMENT’S PRIMARY SCHOOL HALL, CORIAL BAY – NIGHT
Rain on the galvanise¹ roof, loud as gravel. Forty plastic chairs; thirty-one people. A standing fan turns its head slowly from side to side, like someone saying no.
At the front, a projector throws a slide onto a bedsheet pinned over the blackboard: COMMUNITY CONSULTATION: SUPPRESSION OF AEDES AEGYPTI THROUGH THE RELEASE OF STERILE MALES.
DR. RENÉE BAPTISTE (40s, university lanyard, a line of sweat down her back) stands beside it with a laser pointer. She grew up three streets from this hall. Nobody here has let her forget it.
Front row: MISS VERNA (70s, church hat, handbag held on her knees). Behind her: MR. ALLEYNE (60s, a fisherman’s forearms, arms folded). At a side table: COUNCILLOR RAMDASS (50s), beside a jug of juice nobody has touched. Against the wall: KESTON (19), phone held up, filming.
RENÉEI know. It’s a lot of Latin for a Thursday. So, the short version. In the lab we breed male mosquitoes and make them sterile. We release them here, in Corial Bay. They mate with the wild females, and the eggs don’t hatch. After six months, less mosquitoes. Less mosquitoes, less dengue.
KESTON(low, to his phone) Allyuh² hear that? Less.
MR. ALLEYNEFewer.
Heads turn.
MR. ALLEYNEFewer mosquitoes. I went to school too, Renée.
A ripple of laughter. Renée takes it on the chin.
RENÉEFewer. Thank you, Mr. Alleyne.
MISS VERNADoctor. What I want to know is simple. These mosquitoes allyuh releasing. They does bite?
RENÉENo, Miss Verna. Only the females bite. We release males only.
MISS VERNA(considering this) So the men doh bite.
RENÉEThe men don’t bite.
MISS VERNAThen they is the only ones.
Bigger laughter. Ramdass laughs loudest, a beat late, looking round to see who else is laughing.
INSERT – KESTON’S PHONE
The livestream. 212 WATCHING. Comments climb the screen:
“miss verna for prime minister”
“why corial bay tho”
“lab rats. thats all we are to them”
“my aunty had dengue last year she nearly died. let them release”
“who paying for this??”
BACK TO SCENE
MR. ALLEYNE(standing) The boy phone asking a good question. Who paying for this?
RAMDASS(rising, smoothly) Mr. Alleyne, the project is funded through an international health partnership, fully transparent, every cent accounted for, and the Ministry –
MR. ALLEYNEI asking she. Not you.
Ramdass sits.
RENÉEThe money comes from a research fund overseas. I’m not going to pretend it doesn’t. But the lab is in Trinidad, the people counting the eggs are from here, and the results come back here first. Not to a journal. Here. To this hall.
MR. ALLEYNEAnd why here? Plenty mosquito by the Minister house. Why not start there?
RENÉE(a beat) Because Corial Bay had forty-one cases last year. The highest in the region.
MR. ALLEYNESo we sick enough to be useful.
Silence. The fan turns toward Renée, and away. She clicks to the next slide: a graph, two lines, one falling steeply. Nobody looks at it.
RENÉE(quietly) You’re sick enough that it matters. That isn’t the same thing.
MR. ALLEYNEIs it not?
She doesn’t answer.
MISS VERNA(without turning round) Sit down, Lennox.
He looks at the back of her hat for a long moment. He sits.
MISS VERNAMy grandson spend four days in hospital in October. His platelets went down, down, down. I sat by that bed four nights and I slap every mosquito in that ward. If this girl say she could stop them having children, I will sign whatever she want me to sign. (beat) But Doctor. You will put in writing that they doh bite?
RENÉEIt’s in the consent form. Page three.
MISS VERNARead it for me.
Renée finds the page. She reads it out, word for word, in her university voice.
RENÉE“Released male mosquitoes do not feed on blood and pose no biting risk to residents or animals.”
Miss Verna nods once.
RAMDASSWonderful. Wonderful. So if we could have a show of hands –
The lights die. The fan winds down and stops. Only the rain, and the glow of Keston’s phone lighting his face from below.
KESTON(to his phone) Current gone. Classic Corial Bay.
In the dark, a thin, high WHINE, close to someone’s ear. A slap. Another slap, across the room.
MISS VERNA (O.S.)Doctor. That one is a man or a woman?
A long pause.
RENÉE (O.S.)That one’s a woman, Miss Verna. That one’s ours.
INSERT – KESTON’S PHONE
388 WATCHING. One new comment:
“so did they vote or what”
CUT TO BLACK.

¹ galvanise: sheets of corrugated iron, used for roofing.

² allyuh: “you all”, in the English of Trinidad.

Write a guided analysis of the following text.

– How and to what effect are contrasting voices used in this screenplay to present a debate about science?

You may answer the guiding question or set your own focus on a technical or formal aspect of the text.

Exemplars and marksSee them with a free account
Question 6 · ENGALL-00158Paper 2 · 25 marks

Compare and contrast two of the literary works you have studied.

With regard to two works you have studied, examine whether the loss of an illusion is presented as damage, as gain, or as both.

Exemplars and marksSee them with a free account

Practice all 13 in Augment

Free with an account. Every question has its markscheme, and Augment keeps the ones you got wrong so you can come back to them.

The notes on 3.5 How can texts offer multiple perspectives of a single issue, topic or theme?

More questions in Intertextuality: connecting texts

  1. 3.1How do texts adhere to and deviate from conventions associated with literary forms or text types?
  2. 3.2How do conventions and systems of reference evolve over time?
  3. 3.3In what ways can diverse texts share points of similarity?
  4. 3.4How valid is the notion of a classic text?
  5. 3.5How can texts offer multiple perspectives of a single issue, topic or theme?This page
  6. 3.6In what ways can comparison and interpretation be transformative?

Check your answers in Augment

A free account opens all 13 questions on How can texts offer multiple perspectives of a single issue, topic or theme? with their markschemes, and keeps a record of what you have marked.