3.4 How valid is the notion of a classic text? questions for IB English A Lang & Lit

13 questions on How valid is the notion of a classic text?, written by Augment in the style of IB exam papers. Six of them are below in full, to answer on paper.

  • IB English A: Language and Literature
  • Part of 3 Intertextuality: connecting texts
  • SL and HL

Questions by paper and level

SL and HL questions are for students at either level. HL only questions cover what only HL students study.

PaperSL and HLHL onlyAll
Paper 1909
Paper 2404
Every paper13013

Counted on

Questions to try

Written by Augment in the style of IB exams, not past papers. Answer them on paper, then check each one against its markscheme with a free account.

Question 1 · ENGALL-00020Paper 1 · 20 marks

The following set of instructions is taken from Kafa and Timber, a handbook written in 2019 by a village committee on Tongatapu, the main island of Tonga, for young volunteers helping to rebuild the village’s meeting hall. Lalava is the Tongan art of binding parts of a building together with patterned cord.

How to Lash a Rafter: Your First LalavaKafa and Timber, the volunteer handbook of a village rebuilding committee on Tongatapu, Tonga, 2019Written for Augment Education
How to Lash a Rafter: Your First Lalava
Welcome to the hall. This season we are rebuilding our village’s meeting fale, the house where weddings, funerals and Sunday lunches have happened for three generations, and you are going to help hold it together. Some of you grew up in this village. Some of you are here from Auckland, Sydney or Salt Lake City and have only seen lalava in photographs on your aunty’s wall. Both are welcome. These instructions will teach you one joint. They will not teach you the craft. Nobody has ever learnt lalava from a page, and this page is not going to be the first.
Before you start
Find the tufunga¹ on duty and ask permission to work on a beam. Do not skip this step. The tufunga will show you which beam, which pattern and which colour of kafa² to begin with, and will watch your first turns. If you are told to wait, wait. Waiting is part of the work.
You will need
Two coils of kafa, one black and one natural (the reddish-brown of the dried coconut husk). A bucket of fresh water. A wooden peg for pulling turns tight. Patience. You will not need a knife until the very end, and you will not need your phone at all.
The steps
1. Soak both coils in the bucket for ten minutes. Dry kafa snaps; wet kafa stretches a little and then shrinks as it dries, so that the joint tightens itself over the next day. The cord does some of the work for you, if you let it.
2. Hold the rafter against the beam so that they cross. Ask a partner to hold them steady. Lalava is never done alone, and the joint you are making is the meeting of two pieces of wood that would fall apart without each other.
3. Tie the black cord to the beam with the starting knot the tufunga shows you. Leave a tail as long as your forearm.
4. Wrap the black cord diagonally across the joint, over the rafter and under the beam, four times. Pull each turn tight with the peg before you begin the next. Each turn holds the one before it. A loose turn early on will still be loose when your grandchildren look up at this roof.
5. Now bring in the natural cord and wrap it across the black in the opposite direction, four times. Where the two colours cross, the pattern begins to appear. Do not hurry to see it. The pattern is made by the order of the turns, not by trying.
6. Repeat steps 4 and 5 until the tufunga tells you to stop. On your first joint this will probably be sooner than you expect, and that is not a judgement. It is how the old builders kept a beginner’s joints small.
7. Finish both cords with the closing knot, pull them under the last turns and trim the ends. This is when you may use the knife.
8. Show your joint to the tufunga. If it is untied in front of you, do not be offended. Start again. Every tufunga in Tonga has had a joint untied, usually by a relative.
A word about the patterns
The diamonds and triangles you are making are not decoration. The old builders used them the way a family uses names: to remember who made what, and what each part of the house is for. Many lalava patterns share their shapes with kupesi³, the designs printed on our tapa cloth. A visitor sees a beautiful pattern. Someone who can read it sees a story. You will not be able to read it yet. Keep looking.
Safety
Lalava alone will not hold a roof in a cyclone. Every joint in this hall is also fixed with a galvanised steel strap, as the building code requires, and the straps carry the load. The kafa holds the building in a different way. It holds it to us.

¹ tufunga: a master craftsman; an expert builder.

² kafa: cord braided from the fiber of coconut husks.

³ kupesi: traditional Tongan patterns, also used to print designs on tapa, a cloth made from bark.

Write a guided analysis of the following text.

– How and to what effect is the imperative voice used in these instructions to pass on a tradition?

You may answer the guiding question or set your own focus on a technical or formal aspect of the text.

Exemplars and marksSee them with a free account
Question 2 · ENGALL-00061Paper 2 · 25 marks

Compare and contrast two of the literary works you have studied.

Explore how, and to what effect, two works you have studied use characters whom the central figures barely notice.

Exemplars and marksSee them with a free account
Question 3 · ENGALL-00047Paper 1 · 20 marks

The following manifesto is taken from the website of the Open Ward Collective, a group of medical students and junior doctors in Kampala, Uganda, who meet each month to discuss the books they study from.

We Will Still Read the Classicsthe website of the Open Ward Collective, a group of medical students and junior doctors in Kampala, Uganda, 2024Written for Augment Education
We Will Still Read the Classics: A Manifesto for the Books We Learn From
We are medical students and junior doctors in Kampala. For years we have learned medicine from books written far from the wards we work in. Some of them are classics. We have carried them up hospital stairs, slept on them in the library and passed our exams because of them. This manifesto is not against them. It is against the idea that a book becomes true for everyone because it was once true for someone.
1. We honour the classics. We will not obey them.
A classic earned its place by being right about something. That does not make it right about everything. A textbook that describes a rash as “red” has never met most of our patients. On their skin, and on ours, the same rash may look purple, grey or almost invisible. We will learn the classic’s description. Then we will learn the one that is true on our ward.
2. A patient is not a case from somewhere else.
Our books are full of a “55-year-old man who presents with chest pain after shovelling snow”. None of us has ever shovelled snow. We have treated a market trader who felt the same pain carrying a bunch of matooke¹ up the hill at Kasubi. We want cases that sound like the people in front of us, so that when they walk in, we recognise them.
3. Our diseases deserve more than a box at the end of the chapter.
Malaria, sickle cell disease, tuberculosis and the injuries of the boda boda² fill our wards every night. In too many of our books they are given a short box at the end of a chapter, under the heading “Tropical conditions”. Tropical to whom? We are not asking for less science. We are asking for science that starts where we stand.
4. Knowledge should not cost more than food.
A new edition of a classic costs more than many of us spend on food in a month. So we photocopy, we share, and we study from editions older than we are. We will write books that are free to read and free to copy, and we will keep them up to date.
5. Our teachers are not only in the book.
The nurse on night duty who can hear pneumonia before the doctor arrives. The grandmother who explains, in Luganda, what her son means when he says his blood is tired. They have taught us more than some chapters have. We will write down what they know, with their permission, and we will print their names.
6. We will be the first readers of our own mistakes.
Every chapter we write will be checked by others and corrected in public. We expect to be wrong. A classic, too, began as somebody’s draft.
To our professors: we are not asking you to stop teaching from the classics. We are asking you to teach beside us.
To everyone else: we meet on the first Saturday of every month in the old lecture theatre, at ten. Bring a case from your ward. Bring a red pen. Bring the classic you love most, and we will read it together, carefully, respectfully, and with our patients in the room.
The Open Ward Collective, Kampala, March 2024

¹ matooke: green cooking bananas, a staple food in Uganda.

² boda boda: a motorcycle taxi, common in East Africa.

Write a guided analysis of the following text.

– How is the collective voice used in this manifesto to argue for change in medical education?

You may answer the guiding question or set your own focus on a technical or formal aspect of the text.

Exemplars and marksSee them with a free account
Question 4 · ENGALL-00111Paper 2 · 25 marks

Compare and contrast two of the literary works you have studied.

Minor characters often voice the ordinary values of their society. How do two works you have studied use such characters, and does this tie the works to their own time?

Exemplars and marksSee them with a free account
Question 5 · ENGALL-00089Paper 1 · 20 marks

The following article is taken from The Inkwell, a monthly English-language magazine about education, published in Cairo for teachers and parents.

An Enemy of All That He ReadsThe Inkwell, a monthly English-language magazine about education, published in Cairo, 2024Written for Augment Education
A physics teacher in Alexandria has her students rebuild a thousand-year-old experiment. Not everyone thinks it is worth the time.
At twenty to ten on a Tuesday morning, Room 14 of a government secondary school in Moharram Bey is the darkest place in Alexandria. Black bin bags are taped over the windows, a blanket hangs across the door, and thirty-four sixteen-year-olds sit on their desks in silence, staring at a wall. On the wall, upside down and the colour of weak tea, a minibus crosses from right to left.
“Again,” somebody whispers, when it has gone. Nobody laughs. The picture comes through a hole the size of a lentil, punched in a square of kitchen foil in the middle of one of the bin bags, and it has been on the wall the whole time, the students tell me. They simply had not been in the dark long enough to see it.
Their teacher, Hala Mourad, has taught physics for nineteen years. For the last four, she has spent the first fortnight of the optics unit not with the national textbook but with a man who died in Cairo nearly a thousand years ago. Ibn al-Haytham’s Book of Optics, written in the early eleventh century, described dark rooms like this one, and argued, against the most respected authorities of his day, that we see because light enters the eye, not because the eye sends out rays to touch what it looks at.
“They come to me thinking science is a list of facts that somebody else has already checked,” she says, pulling back the blanket and letting in a slab of daylight that makes the whole class groan. “I want them to meet a person who did the checking.”
It is hard to argue with the dark room. It is much easier to argue with the timetable. Optics is a small part of the curriculum, and these students will sit the Thanaweya Amma¹ in two years’ time; the examination asks for ray diagrams and the lens formula, not for medieval scholars. A colleague, who asked not to be named, put it plainly: “It is a lovely story. It is not on the paper.” Two parents have complained to the head teacher, Mrs Mourad admits, and she does not entirely blame them. Private tutoring for the Thanaweya Amma costs families more than many of them can afford, and every lesson spent in the dark is, from one point of view, a lesson paid for twice.
There is a deeper objection, too, and it goes to the heart of what we mean by a classic. In literature, a classic is a book that is still worth reading because nothing has replaced it. In science the opposite is usually true: a book is replaced precisely because somebody has done better. Ibn al-Haytham made mistakes. He believed that the seeing happened in the lens at the front of the eye, an error that took Europe another six centuries to correct. Why ask teenagers to read a textbook whose errors are known?
Mrs Mourad’s answer is on the whiteboard, in Arabic and in English, copied from another of his books, a long list of objections to the great astronomer Ptolemy. A person who wants the truth, he wrote there, must “make himself an enemy of all that he reads”.
“So he tells them not to trust him,” she says. “That is the best sentence any textbook has ever written.” Each year she sets the class the same task: find something in the Book of Optics that is wrong, and prove it. Last year one group spent a week of lunch breaks with mirrors and a torch trying to catch him out on reflection, and failed. This year’s group has already found the eye.
Malak, who sits by the window and keeps lifting the corner of a bin bag to check that the sun is still there, is honest about how she felt at the start. “At first I thought, OK, he is Arab, he is from here, so we have to say he is great,” she says. “Now I think he is great because he was wrong in an interesting way. And because he made a mess of a room to find out.” Her friend Youssef, who wants to be an engineer, says the dark room is the only lesson he has ever described to his grandmother.
None of this will appear in a league table. Nobody can yet say whether Room 14 will produce better results in two years’ time, and Mrs Mourad does not pretend to know. What she knows is what happens at twenty to ten on a Tuesday, when the blanket falls back across the door and thirty-four people wait, without being told to, for their eyes to adjust.
She does not take the bin bags down between lessons. The next class, she says, deserves to sit in the dark for a while before they see anything.

¹ Thanaweya Amma: Egypt’s national examination at the end of secondary school, whose results decide university places.

Write a guided analysis of the following text.

– How does the writer use the dark room to explore the value of an old scientific text?

You may answer the guiding question or set your own focus on a technical or formal aspect of the text.

Exemplars and marksSee them with a free account
Question 6 · ENGALL-00184Paper 2 · 25 marks

Compare and contrast two of the literary works you have studied.

How do two works you have studied make a single voice stand for many people, and what does that voice leave out?

Exemplars and marksSee them with a free account

Practice all 13 in Augment

Free with an account. Every question has its markscheme, and Augment keeps the ones you got wrong so you can come back to them.

The notes on 3.4 How valid is the notion of a classic text?

More questions in Intertextuality: connecting texts

  1. 3.1How do texts adhere to and deviate from conventions associated with literary forms or text types?
  2. 3.2How do conventions and systems of reference evolve over time?
  3. 3.3In what ways can diverse texts share points of similarity?
  4. 3.4How valid is the notion of a classic text?This page
  5. 3.5How can texts offer multiple perspectives of a single issue, topic or theme?
  6. 3.6In what ways can comparison and interpretation be transformative?

Check your answers in Augment

A free account opens all 13 questions on How valid is the notion of a classic text? with their markschemes, and keeps a record of what you have marked.