5.2 Prose: non-fiction

Reading writing that claims to be true: essays, memoirs, letters, diaries, reports, testimony and speeches, the self each makes on the page, and how far a true account may be shaped.

  • IB English A: Language and Literature
  • Part of 5 Literary forms
  • SL and HL

35 min readLast reviewed

Notes on 5.2 Prose: non-fiction

Prose non-fiction is prose that claims to be about the real world: real people, places and events, told by a writer who asks to be believed. That claim gives it powers that fiction does not have: the authority of fact, the trust of a reader who believes it happened, and an “I” who was there. The best non-fiction uses those powers with all the craft of fiction. Virginia Woolf’s “Street Haunting: A London Adventure” was first printed in 1927. In its opening the writer sets out on a winter evening to buy a pencil, and the passage shows how much shaping a true account can hold.

Street Haunting: A London Adventure (opening)The Yale Review, October 1927, 1927Virginia Woolf, “Street Haunting: A London Adventure”, The Yale Review, vol. 17, no. 1 (New Haven, October 1927), pages 49–51
No one perhaps has ever felt passionately towards a lead pencil. But there are circumstances in which it can become supremely desirable to possess one; moments when we are set upon having an object, a purpose, an excuse for walking half across London between tea and dinner. As the foxhunter hunts in order to preserve the breed of horses, and the golfer plays in order that open spaces may be preserved from the builders, so when the desire comes upon us to go street rambling the pencil does for a pretext, and getting up we say, “Really I must buy a pencil,” as if under cover of this excuse we could indulge safely in the greatest pleasure of town life in winter—rambling the streets of London.
The hour should be evening and the season winter, for in winter the champagne brightness of the air and the sociability of the streets are grateful. We are not then taunted as in summer by the longing for shade and solitude and sweet airs from the hayfields. The evening hour, too, gives us the irresponsibility which darkness and lamplight bestow. We are no longer quite ourselves. As we step out of the house on a fine evening between four and six we shed the self our friends know us by and become part of that vast republican army of anonymous trampers, whose society is so agreeable after the solitude of one’s own room. For there we sit surrounded by objects which perpetually express the oddity of our own temperaments and enforce the memories of our own experience. That bowl on the mantelpiece, for instance, was bought at Mantua on a windy day. We were leaving the shop when the sinister old woman plucked at our skirts and said she would find herself starving one of these days, but “Take it!” she cried, and thrust the blue and white china bowl into our hands as if she never wanted to be reminded of her quixotic generosity. So, guiltily, but suspecting nevertheless how badly we had been fleeced, we carried it back to the little hotel where, in the middle of the night, the innkeeper quarrelled so violently with his wife that we all leant out into the courtyard to look, and saw the vines laced about among the pillars and the stars white in the sky. The moment was stabilized, stamped like a coin indelibly, among a million that slipped by imperceptibly. There, too, was the melancholy Englishman, who rose among the coffee cups and the little iron tables and revealed the secrets of his soul—as travellers do. All this—Italy, the windy morning, the vines laced about the pillars, the Englishman and the secrets of his soul—rise up in a cloud from the China bowl on the mantelpiece. And there, as our eyes fall to the floor, is that brown stamp on the carpet. Mr. Lloyd George made that. “The man’s a devil!” said Mr. Cummings, putting the kettle down with which he was about to fill the teapot so that it burnt a brown ring on the carpet.
But when the door shuts on us, all that vanishes. The shell-like covering which our souls have excreted to house themselves, to make for themselves a shape distinct from others, is broken, and there is left of all these wrinkles and roughnesses a central oyster of perceptiveness, an enormous eye. How beautiful a street is in winter! It is at once revealed and obscured. Here vaguely one can trace symmetrical straight avenues of doors and windows; here under the lamps are floating islands of pale light through which pass quickly bright men and women, who for all their poverty and shabbiness wear a certain look of unreality, an air of triumph, as if they had given life the slip, so that life, deceived of her prey, blunders on without them. But, after all, we are only gliding smoothly on the surface. The eye is not a miner, not a diver, not a seeker after buried treasure. It floats us smoothly down a stream, resting, pausing, the brain sleeps perhaps as it looks.

What non-fiction promises

On its surface “Street Haunting” is an account of an errand. A woman in London decides between tea and dinner that she needs a pencil, and goes out to buy one. Every detail could be true, and the essay never asks a reader to doubt it. The opening already treats the errand as an excuse.

No one perhaps has ever felt passionately towards a lead pencil. But there are circumstances in which it can become supremely desirable to possess one; moments when we are set upon having an object, a purpose, an excuse for walking half across London between tea and dinner.

Virginia Woolf, “Street Haunting”, paragraph 1

The pencil is “an excuse”, and the essay admits it in its second sentence. What it reports is an experience that leaves no evidence: the pleasure of “rambling the streets of London” in winter, and what happens to a self in a crowd at dusk. Non-fiction can take that inner experience as its subject because the reader trusts the frame around it. London, the hour “between tea and dinner” and the walk are real; the reflection grows out of them.

That trust is the form’s first resource. A novelist who described a walk across London would be inventing a walk. An essayist describing one is reporting, and her reflections carry the weight of someone who was there. “The Ledger”, the extract from a novel of a Dundee jute mill read in the chapter on prose fiction, imitates memoir closely, with a first-person narrator looking back. Its authority comes from craft alone. Woolf’s comes from craft and from the claim that this is her city and her evening.

The second resource is range. Prose non-fiction runs from writing turned toward the world to writing turned toward the self. The diagram sets out the main kinds on that line, each with the text from this chapter that shows it best.

A line from writing turned toward the world to writing turned toward the self. Along it: report; reportage (Bly, 1887); letters and travel (Wollstonecraft, 1796); diary (Dorothy Wordsworth, 1800); autobiography (Equiano, 1789); personal essay (Woolf, 1927); lyric essay.A line from writing turned toward the world to writing turned toward the self. Along it: report; reportage (Bly, 1887); letters and travel (Wollstonecraft, 1796); diary (Dorothy Wordsworth, 1800); autobiography (Equiano, 1789); personal essay (Woolf, 1927); lyric essay.
Kinds of prose non-fiction, from reporting what happened to reflecting on what it meant. Positions are tendencies: a single work often moves along the line.

The line is a way of asking questions, not a set of boxes. A report keeps its writer out of sight and wants to be checked. A personal essay puts its writer at the center and wants to be understood. Most of the kinds in the middle do both at once, and much of the analysis of non-fiction is noticing where a text moves along the line. “Street Haunting” begins as a report of an errand and ends, in paragraph 3, as a reflection on what it means to see.

Literary and non-literary non-fiction

Prose non-fiction includes some of the most literary writing there is and some of the least. Woolf’s essay was written by a novelist for The Yale Review, a literary quarterly, for readers who wanted the pleasure of its prose as much as its ideas; it is read as a literary work. A public health report, a news story and a set of instructions are also prose non-fiction, but they are read as non-literary texts, for their purpose and their effect on an audience.

Many kinds sit on both sides. A speech can be a political act and a crafted work of prose, and Frederick Douglass’s Fourth of July oration of 1852, with its call for “scorching irony, not convincing argument”, is studied in both ways. Letters, diaries, memoirs and travel writing move across the line depending on who wrote them, why, and how they have been published and read since. Classifying a text is therefore a decision about how to read it: as a made object to be admired and interpreted, or as a message to be understood in its situation. Strong readings of non-fiction usually do some of both.

The essay: an attempt

The French writer Michel de Montaigne, who published the first books of his Essais in 1580, gave the form its name. An essai is an attempt or a trial: a mind testing a question on the page, without promising to settle it. John Florio’s English translation of 1603 called them Essayes. In “Of the Caniballes” Montaigne weighs travelers’ reports of the Tupinamba people of Brazil, and the attempt ends by turning against the judges.

Now (to returne to my purpose) I finde (as farre as I have beene informed) there is nothing in that nation that is either barbarous or savage, unless men call that barbarisme which is not common to them.
I am not sorie we note the barbarous horror of such an action, but grieved, that prying so narrowly into their faults we are so blinded in ours.

Michel de Montaigne, “Of the Caniballes”, trans. John Florio (1603), two sentences of the essay

The first sentence hedges before it strikes. “As farre as I have beene informed” admits that the writer has not been to Brazil, and the bracketed “to returne to my purpose” shows a mind that has just wandered. Then the claim arrives: barbarous is a word people use for whatever “is not common to them”. The second sentence turns the same word on Montaigne’s own society, “so blinded in ours”, after he has set the cruelty of European torture beside the cannibalism his readers found horrifying. The essay persuades by thinking aloud, so the doubt is followed as closely as the conclusion.

Montaigne’s method survives in Woolf’s essay, four centuries later and in a lighter key. Neither writer argues from a thesis set out in advance, and Florio’s “to returne to my purpose” could stand for both. Each starts from a small occasion (a report from Brazil, a pencil) and lets the thinking find its way, with the self who thinks always visible. The chapter on the essay as a text type separates the personal essay from the argumentative one; both descend from this idea of an attempt.

Digression as structure

Woolf’s second paragraph begins with the hour and the season, but within ten sentences it is in Italy. Turning from a text’s main line to follow another thought, memory or story is digression; in “Street Haunting” the digressions are the main line. The diagram maps the walk: the route the essay announces, and the two memories that branch from the room before the walker ever leaves it.

A route from left to right: a pencil, winter dusk, the room, the door shuts. From the room, digression 1 branches up through Mantua, the old woman’s “Take it!”, the quarrel, the vines and stars, and an Englishman; digression 2 branches down through a brown ring, Lloyd George and the kettle.A route from left to right: a pencil, winter dusk, the room, the door shuts. From the room, digression 1 branches up through Mantua, the old woman’s “Take it!”, the quarrel, the vines and stars, and an Englishman; digression 2 branches down through a brown ring, Lloyd George and the kettle.
The structure of the opening of “Street Haunting”: the walk the essay announces, and the memories that branch from the room before the door shuts.

All this—Italy, the windy morning, the vines laced about the pillars, the Englishman and the secrets of his soul—rise up in a cloud from the China bowl on the mantelpiece.

Virginia Woolf, “Street Haunting”, paragraph 2

The digression carries the argument. The essay claims that at home “we sit surrounded by objects which perpetually express the oddity of our own temperaments and enforce the memories of our own experience” (paragraph 2). The Mantua bowl proves it: one object releases a windy day, a sinister old woman pressing a gift on the buyers, a midnight quarrel and a stranger’s confessions, all in “a cloud”. When the next paragraph opens “But when the door shuts on us, all that vanishes”, the reader has just seen what vanishes.

The flâneur and the eye

The walker who sets out “to go street rambling” (paragraph 1) belongs to a long tradition of city writing. The French poet Charles Baudelaire, in “The Painter of Modern Life” (1863), described the flâneur. This stroller moves through crowds without practical purpose, a watcher at home everywhere and nowhere. Woolf’s walker joins “that vast republican army of anonymous trampers” and becomes, in paragraph 3, “a central oyster of perceptiveness, an enormous eye”.

The figure gives the essay its freedom, and its limits. A woman walking alone in London at dusk was making a claim in 1927, and the essay’s pleasure in anonymity is partly a pleasure in that freedom. But the flâneur sees surfaces. The passers-by “for all their poverty and shabbiness” wear “a certain look of unreality”, and the essay admits its method in the next breath: “we are only gliding smoothly on the surface”. That admission can be taken as honesty about the essay’s scope, or as the moment the essay turns poverty into scenery. The text supports both, and the second reading is sharper because Woolf names the risk herself.

The “I” and the “we”: making a self

The “I” of non-fiction is a real person, and a made one. Of all the things a writer is, an essay or memoir selects a few and builds a voice from them: curious or wry, wounded or calm. The chapter on narrative voice calls such a constructed self a persona, and in non-fiction the persona carries a promise that fiction’s narrator does not, that this voice belongs to someone who lived the events.

We were leaving the shop when the sinister old woman plucked at our skirts and said she would find herself starving one of these days, but “Take it!” she cried, and thrust the blue and white china bowl into our hands as if she never wanted to be reminded of her quixotic generosity.

Virginia Woolf, “Street Haunting”, paragraph 2

The chapter on narrative voice shows how Woolf’s “we” draws the reader into the walk and suits an essay about losing the private self in a crowd. A form page adds what the plural does to the promise of truth. In the Mantua anecdote the “we” is plainly a particular person, or people, on a particular windy day. The skirts tell us the walker is a woman, and the travelers may have been more than one, yet the essay never says who “we” were. A memory that belongs to one life is told in a pronoun that could belong to anyone.

That choice keeps the anecdote true while making it general. Nothing in it is invented, but the facts that would tie it to one biography, who traveled with whom and when, are held back. Non-fiction often keeps such facts back while promising truth. The promise covers what is told, not everything that could be, and the plural is one of the quietest ways an essay can decide how much of its writer to show.

Joan Didion’s essay “Goodbye to All That” (1967) makes a different self. A writer in her early thirties looks back on the eight years she spent in New York from her early twenties, and the essay sets the young woman who arrived beside the older one who left. The structure resembles that of “The Ledger”, a retrospective first person with two selves in it, but here the reader is promised that both selves are the author. That promise changes how the essay’s judgments of its younger self are received: as confession, not characterization.

Try it

Rewrite the opening of the Mantua anecdote with “I” in place of “we”: “I was leaving the shop when the sinister old woman plucked at my skirts.” What is gained and what is lost?

With “I” the anecdote becomes one woman’s travel memory: more intimate, more checkable, and more clearly autobiographical, so the reader starts to wonder who she is and who she was with. It loses the essay’s claim that such memories are common to everyone’s rooms, and it breaks the pattern of a voice that has been speaking for all of “us” since the first paragraph. Woolf’s plural keeps the story about what objects do to anyone, not about her own past.

Life writing: memoirs, letters and diaries

The forms that record a life, or part of one, make up the family called life writing. Autobiography tells a whole life, usually in order. Memoir takes one part of it and reflects on what it meant, and biography tells someone else’s. Letters and diaries record a life as it is lived, without knowing how it ends. Each has its own text type page. A form page asks what the differences do to the writing.

Autobiography and memoir are often confused, and the difference is one of scope and stance. An autobiography such as Equiano’s Interesting Narrative (1789) follows a life from childhood onward and asks to be read as a record. A memoir such as Didion’s “Goodbye to All That”, or Maya Angelou’s I Know Why the Caged Bird Sings (1969), takes one period and asks what it meant, so reflection carries as much weight as event. Both rest on the same promise of truth, and both use the double perspective of a writer looking back.

Letters written to be overheard

In 1795 Mary Wollstonecraft traveled in Scandinavia on business, and in 1796 she published the letters she had written on the way as a book. The first sentence keeps the shape of a real letter, with an addressee who knows more than the public reader.

Eleven days of weariness on board a vessel not intended for the accommodation of passengers have so exhausted my spirits, to say nothing of the other causes, with which you are already sufficiently acquainted, that it is with some difficulty I adhere to my determination of giving you my observations, as I travel through new scenes, whilst warmed with the impression they have made on me.

Mary Wollstonecraft, Letters Written during a Short Residence in Sweden, Norway, and Denmark (1796), Letter I, paragraph 1

“To say nothing of the other causes, with which you are already sufficiently acquainted” is a private reference left in a public book. The “you” knows why the writer is exhausted; the reader of the book does not, and is made to feel it as an untold sorrow. This is the power of the epistolary form. A letter promises freshness, observations written “whilst warmed with the impression”, and it lets the public read over the shoulder of a private addressee.

Wollstonecraft’s letters are also travel writing, and travel writing judges new places by the measure of home. Becalmed off the Swedish coast, she waits for a pilot boat that never comes and decides that “Despotism, as is usually the case, I found had here cramped the industry of man” (paragraph 4). The king’s pilots are paid “scantily” and will not leave their hovels, while on “the english coast” boats come out in any weather “brought out by the expectation of extraordinary profit”. One windless morning becomes evidence for a political argument about freedom and enterprise. The letter form lets the judgment arrive as a passing observation, written warm, which is part of its persuasive force.

Fiction has borrowed the form since the eighteenth century. Samuel Richardson’s Pamela (1740) is told in a servant’s letters, and Mary Shelley, Wollstonecraft’s daughter, opened Frankenstein (1818) with an explorer’s letters to his sister. In fiction the letter imitates the immediacy that real letters have. In Wollstonecraft’s book the “Eleven days of weariness” were a real voyage, but the immediacy has been chosen for publication, and the gaps the letters leave are part of what the book means.

The diary and the vignette

A diary is written for the writer, day by day, and its entries are often brief. Dorothy Wordsworth kept a journal at Grasmere, in the English Lake District, and on 3 October 1800 she recorded a meeting with an old man on the road.

He had on a coat, thrown over his shoulders, above his waistcoat and coat. Under this he carried a bundle, and had an apron on and a night-cap. His face was interesting. He had dark eyes and a long nose.

Dorothy Wordsworth, Grasmere journal, 3 October 1800, paragraph 2

The entry is a vignette. It sketches a person completely, in a few lines, with no plot. Its sentences are plain and short, a list of clothes and features, and its one judgment, “His face was interesting”, is as flat as a note. Then come the facts of his life, partly in his own words: ten children, all but one dead; a trade, gathering leeches, that no longer pays. The diary does not shape these facts into a story or a lesson. Its force comes from that restraint, and from details no one would invent, such as the price of leeches, “2s. 6d. per 100” once and “30s.” now.

Truth and shaping

Every piece of non-fiction selects, orders and compresses. Dorothy Wordsworth’s entry gives the old man’s life in a few sentences and leaves out everything else that happened on 3 October 1800 beyond the rain and a walk to Ambleside. Woolf reports the old woman’s cry of “Take it!” and Mr. Cummings’s “The man’s a devil!” (paragraph 2), words recalled from memory and placed exactly where the essay needs them. None of this is lying. It is the shaping without which no true account could be read.

His trade was to gather leeches, but now leeches were scarce, and he had not strength for it. He lived by begging, and was making his way to Carlisle, where he should buy a few godly books to sell.

Dorothy Wordsworth, Grasmere journal, 3 October 1800, paragraph 2

The same meeting shows how far shaping can go when the form changes. Dorothy’s brother William, who was with her on the road, later made the old man the center of his poem “Resolution and Independence”, published in 1807. In the poem the man is met alone on a moor, standing by a pool and still gathering leeches, and he becomes an example of endurance that rebukes the poet’s low spirits. The diary records a beggar whose trade has failed; the poem makes a figure of steadfastness. Set side by side, the two texts show that the difference between documenting and shaping is a matter of degree, and that genre sets the degree a reader will accept.

The promise of the “I”

A poem is allowed a great deal of shaping and a memoir much less, because a memoir makes a promise. The French critic Philippe Lejeune, in Le pacte autobiographique (1975), called it the autobiographical pact. The name on the cover, the “I” who tells the story and the person the story is about are one real person, and the account is offered as true to that person’s life. The pact allows for faulty memory and for a point of view. It does not allow for invention presented as fact.

Breaking the pact changes how a book is read. In January 2006 reporters showed that much of James Frey’s A Million Little Pieces (2003), sold as a memoir of addiction and recovery, had been exaggerated or invented. The same sentences that had moved readers as testimony now read as fiction, and later printings carried a note from the author about what he had changed. The words did not change; the pact did, and with it their meaning.

How much shaping the promise allows is contested. The term creative non-fiction names factual writing that uses fiction’s methods, and its writers disagree about where the line falls. The Lifespan of a Fact (2012) records a dispute between the essayist John D’Agata and the fact-checker Jim Fingal. D’Agata had altered details of an essay for the sake of its rhythm and effect, and he defends this as the essayist’s right to put art before accuracy. Fingal, who checked the essay’s facts, holds that a reader told a piece is true is owed the facts. For a reader of an unseen text the practical point is that a text claiming to be true asks for a trust that invention spends without asking. That is why reconstructed dialogue, composite characters and changed details are worth noticing in any non-fiction extract.

Argument and anecdote

Non-fiction moves between two ways of persuading: the claim, which states, and the story, which shows. An anecdote is a short account of a single incident within a longer text. In “Street Haunting” the Mantua bowl is an anecdote that proves a claim, that objects at home “enforce the memories of our own experience” (paragraph 2). The claim comes first and the story makes it felt. Frederick Douglass’s oration of 5 July 1852, the speech in which a man who had escaped slavery asks a Rochester audience what their holiday means to the people held in slavery, takes the opposite route.

At a time like this, scorching irony, not convincing argument, is needed. O! had I the ability, and could I reach the nation’s ear, I would, to day, pour out a fiery stream of biting ridicule, blasting reproach, withering sarcasm, and stern rebuke.

Frederick Douglass, Fourth of July oration, 1852, paragraph 4

Douglass refuses both argument and anecdote. He has spent three paragraphs declining to prove what his audience already admits, that slavery is wrong, and here he names the mode he will use instead. The sentence about irony is itself crafted prose: a balanced antithesis (“scorching irony, not convincing argument”) followed by four pairs of adjective and noun in a rising list. Read on the page, in the pamphlet printed that year, the speech is prose non-fiction of the highest finish. In this part of the oration he does not narrate one person’s suffering, so the audience is denied the comfort of pity and left with its own hypocrisy.

The speech on the page

A speech is composed for listeners and often read by later generations in print, and both audiences shape it. Douglass delivered his oration in Corinthian Hall, Rochester, to an antislavery society, and it was printed as a pamphlet the same year. The printed text keeps the marks of speech, such as the exclamation “O!” and direct address, and adds marks of writing, such as italics for stress. Its central paragraph answers the question the whole speech has been circling.

What, to the American slave, is your 4th of July? I answer; a day that reveals to him, more than all other days in the year, the gross injustice and cruelty to which he is the constant victim. To him, your celebration is a sham; your boasted liberty, an unholy license; your national greatness, swelling vanity.

Frederick Douglass, Fourth of July oration, 1852, paragraph 5

The pronouns do the arguing. It is “your 4th of July” and “your celebration”, while the enslaved man is “him”: the speaker stands between the two, addressing one on behalf of the other. Each clause after the first pairs a proud phrase with its exposure, “your boasted liberty, an unholy license”, and drops the verb, so the charges arrive like entries in a ledger of hypocrisy. Read as prose non-fiction, the paragraph suggests that a speech’s structure can be studied as closely as a poem’s. Read as a non-literary text, it shows a speaker turning an occasion meant for celebration into an indictment of the audience that invited him.

Anecdote and argument can trade places. Rachel Carson’s Silent Spring (1962), a work of science writing that changed public opinion about pesticides, opens with “A Fable for Tomorrow”: a town where the birds have stopped singing. The town is invented, a composite of real cases, and the chapter calls itself a fable. Because the invention is announced, the pact with the reader is kept, and the story prepares its audience to accept the evidence that follows. The film on Carson sets out how the book made its case and what it cost her.

YouTube
How one scientist took on the chemical industry: Mark Lytle on Rachel Carson and *Silent Spring*. TED-Ed.

The balance between story and claim is one of the first things to judge in a non-fiction extract. A text built on anecdote moves its audience through a single case and asks them to generalize; a text built on argument asks for agreement first. Woolf, Carson and Douglass each choose differently, and in each case the choice fits the audience the text expects to meet.

Reportage and testimony: writing as a witness

Some non-fiction draws its authority from presence: the writer was there and saw it. In 1887 the young reporter Nellie Bly pretended to be insane so that she would be committed to the women’s asylum on Blackwell’s Island in New York. Her reports for the New York World became the book Ten Days in a Mad-House. Its chapter “In the Bath” records an early scene on the ward.

The water was ice-cold, and I again began to protest. How useless it all was! I begged, at least, that the patients be made to go away, but was ordered to shut up. The crazy woman began to scrub me. I can find no other word that will express it but scrubbing.

Nellie Bly, Ten Days in a Mad-House (1887), chapter XI, paragraph 2

This is reportage: journalism that reports from the writer’s own observation, with the writer present in the account. Bly’s body is the evidence. The cold water, the soap rubbed into her face and the “three buckets of water over my head” (paragraph 2) are facts she can vouch for because they happened to her. The sentence “I can find no other word that will express it but scrubbing” is a reporter’s claim to precision: she has looked for a gentler word and refuses it. The plain diction of the passage asks to be checked against the institution’s practice.

Reportage borrows fiction’s methods freely. Bly builds suspense (“I knew now what was to be done with me. I shivered”), asks a question and answers it at once (“Did I protest?”) and ends the scene on a turn of feeling: “I burst into roars of laughter” (paragraph 2). The comedy matters. A reporter who can laugh at “the absurd picture I presented” keeps the reader’s trust that she is sane, and the reader’s trust is what makes the cruelty credible. The “I” of reportage is a persona built to be believed. In the 1960s American writers such as Tom Wolfe and Joan Didion took this presence further in what was called the New Journalism, reporting real events with the full methods of fiction.

Testimony

Where reportage observes, testimony bears witness: it is a first-hand account of suffering or injustice, offered to readers who were not there, and its authority comes from the writer having endured what is told. The Interesting Narrative of the Life of Olaudah Equiano, or Gustavus Vassa, the African (1789), published by its author in London during the campaign against the slave trade, is one of its founding works. In the third chapter the boy, newly sold in Virginia, is sent into his owner’s house.

I was much astonished and shocked at this contrivance, which I afterwards learned was called the iron muzzle. Soon after I had a fan put into my hand, to fan the gentleman while he slept; and so I did indeed with great fear.

Olaudah Equiano, The Interesting Narrative (1789), volume 1, chapter 3

The passage holds two times, like every retrospective account. The boy sees a “contrivance” he has no name for; the older writer supplies the name, “the iron muzzle”, that he “afterwards learned”. The gap between the two is the testimony’s method. A reader in 1789 is made to see the instrument with a child’s unfamiliar eyes, and the horror is sharper for not being explained at once. The same double view governs the watch, which the boy fears will tell the gentleman what he does amiss, and the picture that seems always to look at him. The narrative ends the paragraph on a fact about naming: “In this place I was called Jacob; but on board the African snow I was called Michael”. A life told by a man whose name was changed by each owner is itself an argument about who owns a person.

Testimony rests on the autobiographical pact more heavily than any other form, and it can be questioned on the same ground. The historian Vincent Carretta, first in 1999 and then in his biography Equiano, the African (2005), reported a baptismal record and a naval muster roll that give Equiano’s birthplace as South Carolina. He asked whether the African childhood of the early chapters was drawn from others’ accounts. Other historians, among them Paul Lovejoy in 2006, answered that the African chapters fit what is known of the Igbo region and that the records may reflect what officials assumed. Either way, the account of slavery in the Americas and at sea keeps its force; what changes is how the opening chapters are read, as memory or as a composite made for a cause.

Reading an unseen non-fiction extract

A first reading of the opening of “Street Haunting”, as a student might meet it unseen, shows the questions a reader of non-fiction asks and the order that works best. The reading moves from impressions to an interpretation it can defend, and each question grows out of the answer to the last.

The first impression is of play. An essay that begins by doubting that anyone “has ever felt passionately towards a lead pencil” is not going to be solemn. The analogies that follow are mock-serious. The foxhunter who hunts “in order to preserve the breed of horses” and the golfer who plays so that open spaces are “preserved from the builders” (paragraph 1) have respectable excuses for pleasure. The pencil, the essay admits, is the same kind of excuse. The tone is light, self-mocking and confiding.

The second question is what kind of text this is and who speaks. There is no headline, no data and no call to action, so it is not a report or a column; it is an essay, and its speaker hedges (“perhaps”) and generalizes (“we”). The persona is a companionable one, inviting the reader on the walk instead of arguing at them. The third question follows from the first two: if the pencil is an excuse, what is it an excuse for? Paragraph 2 answers. The real subject is what happens to a self when it leaves home at dusk.

The fourth question is how the text is built, and here the digressions matter. The essay promises a walk and spends most of its second paragraph indoors, in memories released by a bowl and “that brown stamp on the carpet”. A reader who expected a route has to adjust. The digressions make the point that a room holds the self together with memories, so that the walk becomes an escape from them.

The shell-like covering which our souls have excreted to house themselves, to make for themselves a shape distinct from others, is broken, and there is left of all these wrinkles and roughnesses a central oyster of perceptiveness, an enormous eye.

Virginia Woolf, “Street Haunting”, paragraph 3

The fifth question is what images carry the meaning. The self at home is a shell, “excreted” (an ugly, bodily word) to make a shape “distinct from others”. Outside, the shell breaks and leaves “an enormous eye”. The image is strange and a little comic, an oyster that sees, but it states the essay’s idea exactly: walking in a crowd reduces a person to pure perception. The paragraph’s last image limits the claim: “The eye is not a miner, not a diver, not a seeker after buried treasure”. Three negatives, each longer than the last, refuse depth.

Only now can an interpretation be argued. The opening of “Street Haunting” turns a trivial errand into an inquiry into identity. It suggests that the private self is a crust of habits and memories, and that the city at night offers a holiday from it, at the price of seeing only surfaces. The tone moves from comedy to lyric wonder (“How beautiful a street is in winter!”) without losing its honesty about that price. An interpretation of this kind keeps the first impression, that the essay is playful, and explains what the play is for.

Non-fiction at the borders of other forms

Non-fiction borders fiction on one side and poetry on the other. Toward poetry lies the lyric essay, a name the American journal Seneca Review gave in 1997 to essays that move by images, fragments and association more than by argument. The third paragraph of “Street Haunting” already leans that way.

How beautiful a street is in winter! It is at once revealed and obscured. Here vaguely one can trace symmetrical straight avenues of doors and windows; here under the lamps are floating islands of pale light through which pass quickly bright men and women.

Virginia Woolf, “Street Haunting”, paragraph 3

The passage makes no claim that could be argued with. It offers an exclamation, a paradox (“revealed and obscured”) and a picture built on the repetition of “here”. Its meaning sits in the image of “floating islands of pale light”, as a poem’s would. A lyric essay pushes this mode further, sometimes to the point of dropping paragraphs and sequence altogether, and asks to be read with the attention a poem receives.

Toward fiction lies the non-fiction novel. Truman Capote called In Cold Blood (1966) a “non-fiction novel”. It is an account of the murder of a farming family in Holcomb, Kansas, in 1959, and of the two men executed for it. Capote researched for six years and claimed the book was entirely accurate, yet it reconstructs private thoughts and conversations no reporter could have witnessed. Later reporting found that some scenes were embellished or invented. The book shows both what the novel’s methods give non-fiction (scene, suspense, interior life) and what they risk: the autobiographical pact’s cousin, the reporter’s promise that it happened this way.

Between the two lies the graphic memoir, which tells a true life in drawn panels. Art Spiegelman’s Maus, subtitled “A Survivor’s Tale” (1980–1991), records his father’s account of surviving Auschwitz, with Jews drawn as mice and Nazis as cats, and it makes the son’s difficulty in hearing the testimony part of the story. Its animal masks are an open fiction in the service of fact. As with the lyric essay and the non-fiction novel, the reader has to decide which promises the work makes and judge it by them.

Writing about prose non-fiction

A paragraph on non-fiction does what a paragraph on fiction does, with one extra question always in view: how the text earns belief. The paragraph that follows is about the opening of Woolf’s essay.

Woolf opens “Street Haunting” by confessing that its errand is an excuse, and the confession sets the terms on which the essay asks to be trusted.note 1 No one, the essay begins, “has ever felt passionately towards a lead pencil”, and the hedge “perhaps” makes even that claim modest (paragraph 1). The foxhunter who hunts “in order to preserve the breed of horses” and the golfer who plays so that open spaces may be “preserved from the builders” are mock-justifications: pleasures dressed as public duties.note 2 Setting the pencil beside them, the essay admits that its own errand disguises “the greatest pleasure of town life in winter”.note 3 That candor is the essayist’s credential: a writer who exposes her pretext in the first paragraph earns belief for the reflections on self and city that follow.note 4

  1. Claim about a choice. The topic sentence names what the opening does and why it matters for the whole essay.

  2. Evidence read, not just quoted. The student names the analogies as mock-justifications and says what they have in common.

  3. The link made explicit. The third sentence connects the analogies back to the pencil, so the quotation serves the argument.

  4. The non-fiction question. The last sentence turns the analysis toward credibility, the question every non-fiction text raises.

The paragraph never praises Woolf’s language in general terms, and it never retells the walk. The pair that follows shows a common weak sentence about reportage and a rewrite of the same point.

Weak: Nellie Bly uses vivid imagery and personal experience to make the reader feel sorry for the patients and understand how bad the asylum was.note 1

Strong: Bly makes her own body the evidence: the “ice-cold” water and the “three buckets of water over my head” are facts only someone in the tub could report, and her refusal of a gentler word (“I can find no other word that will express it but scrubbing”) presents the reporter as precise rather than sensational.note 2

  1. Feature labels and a vague effect. “Vivid imagery” and “personal experience” name categories, “feel sorry” is a guess about any reader, and nothing is quoted.

  2. Choice, evidence, credibility. The rewrite quotes the details, explains why presence makes them authoritative, and says how one sentence builds the reporter’s persona, which is the question non-fiction always raises.

Applying it in Paper 1

Paper 1 in Language and Literature sets unseen non-literary texts, and much of what appears is prose non-fiction: speeches, letters, travel writing, memoir extracts, magazine features and opinion pieces. SL students write on one of two texts in 1 hour 15 minutes; HL students write on both, each marked out of 20. Each text comes with a guiding question, which a student may answer or replace with a focus of their own on a technical or formal aspect of the text.

The questions of this chapter translate directly. A guiding question about how a writer presents an experience can be opened with the persona: who the “I” is, what it claims to have witnessed and how it earns belief. A question about how a text persuades can be opened with the balance of anecdote and argument. A model opening for a travel letter like Wollstonecraft’s might read: “The letter persuades its reader of the writer’s exhaustion before it describes anything, and the private reference to ‘other causes’ turns a travel account into a confession overheard.” The sentence names the purpose, quotes precisely and points to the effect on an audience.

Marks are most often lost by treating non-fiction as transparent: summarizing what the writer says happened, as if the text were a window rather than a made thing. Every feature analyzed in a novel (structure, voice, imagery, pace) is also present in a memoir or a speech, and the strongest responses analyze them with the same care while keeping the text’s purpose in view.

The essay, memoir, letter, diary, speech and travelogue each have a text type page that reads one complete example closely. The chapter on narrative voice takes the question of who says “I” further, and the rhetoric chapter sets out the tools of persuasion that Douglass uses.

Self-check

  • To do:

    I can explain what prose non-fiction promises a reader, and when a non-fiction text is read as literary or as non-literary.

  • To do:

    I can analyze how an essay, memoir or report makes a self on the page, including the effects of “I” and “we”.

  • To do:

    I can describe the main kinds of life writing and what letters, diaries and vignettes do.

  • To do:

    I can explain the autobiographical pact and evaluate how much shaping a true account can carry.

  • To do:

    I can analyze how a non-fiction text moves between anecdote and argument, and how reportage and testimony earn belief.

  • To do:

    I can read an unseen non-fiction extract in a sensible order, from impressions to an interpretation I can defend.

  • To do:

    I can write a paragraph on non-fiction that links a choice to its effect and to the text’s claim to truth.

Key terms

Each is also in the Literary forms glossary for IB English A Lang & Lit, beside the other terms of its topic.

Anecdote

An anecdote is a short account of a single incident, told as a story within a longer text, often to make a point vivid or to support a claim.

Autobiographical pact

The autobiographical pact is the implied promise of an autobiography or memoir that its author, its narrator and its main character are the same real person, and that the account is true to that person's life. It is Philippe Lejeune's term.

Creative non-fiction

Creative non-fiction is factual writing that uses the methods of fiction, such as scene, dialogue, a shaped plot and a distinct voice, while still claiming to be true.

Digression

A digression is a passage that turns away from the main subject or line of a text to follow another thought, memory or story before returning, or never returning.

Epistolary form

Epistolary form is writing made of letters, real or invented, so that a text is shaped by the conventions of a correspondence: an addressee, a date and the gaps between letters.

Flâneur

A flâneur is a figure of city writing: a walker who strolls through streets and crowds without a practical purpose, watching and interpreting urban life.

Life writing

Life writing is the family of non-fiction forms that record a life or part of one, including autobiography, biography, memoir, diaries and letters.

Lyric essay

A lyric essay is a short non-fiction form that works more like a poem than an argument, moving by images, fragments and association rather than by a stated line of reasoning.

Non-fiction novel

A non-fiction novel tells true events, usually from research and interviews, with the full methods of a novel: scenes, dialogue, interior thought and a shaped plot.

Prose non-fiction

Prose non-fiction is prose writing that claims to be about the real world: real people, places and events, presented by a writer who asks to be believed. It ranges from reports and journalism to memoirs, letters and essays.

Reportage

Reportage is journalism that reports events from the reporter's own observation, often in vivid narrative detail and with the reporter present in the account.

Testimony

Testimony is writing that bears witness: a first-hand account of events, often of suffering or injustice, offered as evidence to readers who were not there.

Vignette

A vignette is a short, sharply observed sketch of a person, place or moment, complete in itself and usually without a plot.

Practice questions on 5.2 Prose: non-fiction

Augment’s own questions, written in the style of IB exam papers. Here is how a few of them start.

Question 1 · ENGALL-0001625 marks

Compare and contrast two of the literary works you have studied.

With reference to two works you have studied, discuss how paired figures who mirror or reverse each other shape the way a group of people is represented.

Exemplars and marksSee them with a free account
Question 2 · ENGALL-0001825 marks

Compare and contrast two of the literary works you have studied.

Explore how two works you have studied use wandering, whether on foot or in thought, as a way of reaching ideas, and to what effect.

Exemplars and marksSee them with a free account
Question 3 · ENGALL-0003025 marks

Compare and contrast two of the literary works you have studied.

Irony often depends on knowing the world in which a work was written. Explore how, and to what effect, two works you have studied use irony of this kind.

Exemplars and marksSee them with a free account

Practice all 18 questions on 5.2 Prose: non-fiction

Free with an account. Write your answer, open the markscheme beside it and mark yourself. Augment keeps the ones you got wrong for another go.

5.2 Prose: non-fiction questions by paper, with 6 in full

The English A Lang & Lit question bank, topic by topic

More in 5 Literary forms

The whole topic is on its own page.

  1. 5.1Prose: fiction
  2. 5.2Prose: non-fictionThis page
  3. 5.3Poetry
  4. 5.4Drama

Carry on with 5.2 Prose: non-fiction in Augment

With a free account, Augment remembers where you stopped in the notes and which questions you have marked.