4.2 Water access, use and security questions for IB Environmental Systems and Societies

127 questions on Water access, use and security, written by Augment in the style of IB exam papers. Six of them are below in full, to answer on paper.

  • IB Environmental Systems and Societies
  • Part of 4 Water
  • SL and HL

Questions by paper and level

SL and HL questions are for students at either level. HL only questions cover what only HL students study.

PaperSL and HLHL onlyAll
Paper 1241842
Paper 2483785
Every paper7255127

Counted on

Questions to try

Written by Augment in the style of IB exams, not past papers. Answer them on paper, then check each one against its markscheme with a free account.

Question 1 · ESS-00002Paper 1 · 18 marks

The resource booklet describes the Rio Tamaru catchment, a high mountain valley in the Andes of South America, where a copper mine has been proposed.

Figure 1: Fact file on the Rio Tamaru catchment

  • Area: 1,850 km2; altitude 2,400–5,200 m

  • Population: about 9,500, including the Tamaru indigenous community (3,200 people), who herd alpacas and llamas and grow potatoes and quinoa on terraces

  • Climate: wet season December to March; almost no rain from May to October, when river flow comes mainly from glacier meltwater and groundwater

  • Proposal: an open-pit copper mine at Cerro Blanco, run by Andina Copper, a private company; 22-year life; 1,100 jobs during construction and 450 during operation; 4% of profits paid into a regional development fund

  • The peak above the mine site is sacred to the Tamaru community

Figure 2: Dry-season (May to October) water use in the catchment, now and with the mine

Use

Current / million m3

With the mine / million m3

Irrigated farming

17.6

17.6

Livestock

0.8

0.8

Domestic

0.9

0.9

Mine (ore processing, dust control)

0.0

11.2

Total

19.3

30.5

Mean dry-season river flow: 26.0 million m3

Line graph of glacier area in the catchment: 24.0 km² in 1990, 22.6 in 1995, 20.9 in 2000, 18.8 in 2005, 16.9 in 2010, 14.7 in 2015, 12.6 in 2020.
Figure 3: Area of glaciers in the Rio Tamaru catchment, 1990–2020

Figure 4: Extracts from two statements

Source

Extract

Andina Copper, "Our values"

We create lasting value for our shareholders and our host communities. We apply world-class technology to use every drop of water responsibly. Copper wires the clean energy transition: no wind turbine or electric car can be built without it.

Tamaru community council

The mountain watches over us and the water is the blood of the land. Our grandparents taught us to take only what we need. No payment can replace a spring that has dried up.

  1. (a)

    Using Figure 3, calculate the percentage decrease in glacier area between 1990 and 2020.

    1 mark

  2. (b)

    Outline why the loss of glacier ice may increase water scarcity in the catchment during the dry season.

    2 marks

  3. (c)

    Using Figure 2, calculate the percentage increase in total dry-season water use if the mine opens.

    2 marks

  4. (d)

    With reference to Figure 2, outline why the mine could lead to conflict over water.

    2 marks

  5. (e)

    With reference to Figure 4, identify two values held by Andina Copper.

    2 marks

  6. (f)

    Explain how differences in values between Andina Copper and the Tamaru community could lead to tension over the mine.

    3 marks

  7. (g)

    Using evidence from the resource booklet, to what extent would the Cerro Blanco mine support sustainable development in the Rio Tamaru catchment?

    6 marks

Question 2 · ESS-00021Paper 2 · 8 marks

A coastal city in North Africa faces growing water scarcity. Figure 8 shows a simple model of the range of environmental perspectives.

A horizontal double-headed arrow. Left end: technocentric, technology can resolve environmental issues. Right end: ecocentric, the natural world has pre-eminent importance and intrinsic value. The middle position is labeled Q with a question mark.
Figure 8: A spectrum of environmental perspectives

Three residents of the city proposed the following responses to water scarcity:

  • Resident 1: reduce water use in homes and farms and leave enough water in the river to sustain its wetland ecosystem.

  • Resident 2: build a seawater desalination plant powered by solar energy, so supply can grow with demand.

  • Resident 3: charge higher prices for water above a basic allowance, so it is shared between farms, industry and homes.

  1. (a)

    Identify the perspective represented by position Q in Figure 8.

    1 mark

  2. (b)

    Identify the resident whose proposal lies closest to the technocentric end of the spectrum.

    1 mark

  3. (c)

    Outline two reasons why a single resident may not fit one position on the spectrum in Figure 8.

    2 marks

  4. (d)

    Compare and contrast ecocentric and technocentric approaches to the city's water scarcity.

    4 marks

Question 3 · ESS-00011Paper 1 · 16 marks

The resource booklet describes Tazrit, an oasis on the northern edge of the Sahara, in North Africa.

Figure 1: Fact file on Tazrit oasis

  • Population 6,800; many young people move to cities for work

  • 1,200 ha of date palms, with vegetables and animal fodder grown beneath them

  • For centuries, water came from 31 underground channels: gently sloping tunnels that carry groundwater by gravity from the aquifer to the fields

  • A village water council shares the channel water between families in timed turns

  • Since 2005, private farms on the edge of the oasis have drilled boreholes 60–120 m deep, pumped first with diesel and, since 2016, with solar panels subsidized by the government

  • Most of these farms grow watermelons for export, a crop that needs a lot of water

Two-axis line graph. Depth to water table below the surface, m: 8 (1995), 9 (2000), 12 (2005), 16 (2010), 22 (2015), 29 (2020), 33 (2023). Number of working channels (right axis): 31, 30, 27, 22, 15, 11, 9.
Figure 2: Depth to the water table below the surface and number of working channels at Tazrit, 1995–2023

Figure 3: Statements by four stakeholders

Stakeholder

Statement

Elder on the water council

Water belongs to everyone and to no one. Our ancestors dug the channels so that every family gets its turn. If one family takes more, the oasis dies.

Young watermelon farmer

With a solar pump I can earn more from one watermelon harvest than my father earned in a year. Why should I wait for my turn?

Regional agriculture official

Solar pumps and drip irrigation are modern solutions. With them the desert can become a garden that feeds the cities and earns export income.

Environmental NGO

The aquifer refills only very slowly. Every new borehole lowers the water for everyone, and the old channels are drying one by one.

  1. (a)

    Using Figure 2, state the depth to the water table in 2010.

    1 mark

  2. (b)

    Using Figure 2, calculate the mean annual fall in the water table between 2010 and 2023.

    2 marks

  3. (c)

    With reference to Figures 1 and 2, outline why the number of working channels has fallen.

    2 marks

  4. (d)

    Identify the environmental perspective shown by the regional agriculture official in Figure 3.

    1 mark

  5. (e)

    Outline how the values of the elder differ from those of the young watermelon farmer in Figure 3.

    2 marks

  6. (f)

    Outline how borehole pumping at Tazrit illustrates the tragedy of the commons.

    2 marks

  7. (g)

    Using evidence from the resource booklet, to what extent can traditional water management sustain Tazrit oasis in the future?

    6 marks

Question 4 · ESS-00023Paper 2 · 2 marks

A farmer in a semi-arid region is told that the volume of groundwater she can pump to irrigate her crops will be limited from next year.

Outline how her lived experience and her economic conditions may each inform her perspective on the limit.

2 marks

Question 5 · ESS-00062Paper 1 · 16 marks

Figure 1: Fact file on Puerto Alto

  • A coastal city of 1.1 million people in central Chile, with a Mediterranean climate: wet winters and dry summers.

  • Water comes from two reservoirs in the mountains, filled by rain and snowmelt, and from wells that pump groundwater.

  • Farms in the valley below the reservoirs also depend on water released from them.

  • Rainfall and snowfall were below average every year from 2018 to 2023.

  • In 2021 the city introduced water prices that rise steeply for households using more than a basic amount, and limited garden watering to two days a week.

  • A desalination plant on the coast is planned for 2027, able to supply 100 000 m3 of fresh water a day. It will be powered from the national electricity grid and will return brine to the sea.

Systems diagram, flows in million m³/yr. Reservoirs (store 160 million m³): river inflow 120 in; evaporation 14 and releases to farms 60 out; abstraction 95 to network. Aquifer: recharge 22 in; pumping 35 to network. Network out: homes 70, industry 24, leaks 36.
Figure 2: Systems diagram of Puerto Alto's water supply in 2022 (flows in million m³ yr⁻¹)
Line graph 2015–2024. Reservoir storage on 1 January (% of capacity): 78, 74, 80, 71, 62, 52, 47, 40, 28 (2023), 33. Household water use (L per person per day): 215, 218, 220, 221, 219, 214, 190, 172, 165, 168.
Figure 3: Reservoir storage on 1 January and household water use in Puerto Alto, 2015–2024
  1. (a)

    Using Figure 3, identify the year in which reservoir storage was lowest.

    1 mark

  2. (b)

    Using Figure 2, calculate the net change in the volume of water stored in the reservoirs during 2022. Show your working.

    2 marks

  3. (c)

    Using Figure 2, calculate the percentage of the water entering the supply network that is lost through leaks.

    1 mark

  4. (d)

    With reference to Figures 1 and 3, explain how the water prices and garden watering limits introduced in 2021 act as a negative feedback in Puerto Alto's water system.

    3 marks

  5. (e)

    With reference to Figure 2, explain how the size of storages and the diversity of water sources affect the resilience of Puerto Alto's water supply.

    3 marks

  6. (f)

    With reference to the information in the case study, to what extent will the planned desalination plant make Puerto Alto's water supply sustainable?

    6 marks

Question 6 · ESS-00029Paper 2 · 10 marks

A city with a Mediterranean climate suffered a severe drought. Figure 14 shows the mean daily water use per person over 24 months. At A (month 6) the city government began a media campaign asking residents to save water. At B (month 12) it set a limit of 90 liters per person per day and warned that taps could run dry. At C (month 20) heavy rains refilled the reservoirs and the limit was relaxed.

Line graph of mean water use (L per person per day) over months 1 to 24: about 210–218 in months 1–4, 200 at month 6, 160 at month 12, falling to a minimum of 90 at month 18, then rising to 120 by month 24. Vertical lines at months 6 (A), 12 (B) and 20 (C).
Figure 14: Mean daily water use per person during a drought
  1. (a)

    Identify the month in which water use was lowest.

    1 mark

  2. (b)

    Calculate the percentage reduction in water use from month 1 to the lowest value.

    2 marks

  3. (c)

    Suggest two reasons why water use fell more steeply after B than after A.

    2 marks

  4. (d)

    To what extent do the data in Figure 14 show that the campaign changed residents' perspectives on water, rather than only their behavior?

    5 marks

Practice all 127 in Augment

Free with an account. Every question has its markscheme, and Augment keeps the ones you got wrong so you can come back to them.

The notes on 4.2 Water access, use and security

More questions in Water

  1. 4.1Water systems
  2. 4.2Water access, use and securityThis page
  3. 4.3Aquatic food production systems
  4. 4.4Water pollution

Check your answers in Augment

A free account opens all 127 questions on Water access, use and security with their markschemes, and keeps a record of what you have marked.