3.5 How can literary texts offer multiple perspectives of a single issue, topic or theme? questions for IB English A Lit

16 questions on How can literary texts offer multiple perspectives of a single issue, topic or theme?, written by Augment in the style of IB exam papers. Six of them are below in full, to answer on paper.

  • IB English A: Literature
  • Part of 3 Intertextuality: connecting texts
  • SL and HL

Questions by paper and level

SL and HL questions are for students at either level. HL only questions cover what only HL students study.

PaperSL and HLHL onlyAll
Paper 110010
Paper 2606
Every paper16016

Counted on

Questions to try

Written by Augment in the style of IB exams, not past papers. Answer them on paper, then check each one against its markscheme with a free account.

Question 1 · ENGAL-00024Paper 1 · 20 marks
VelorioDry Country, a collection of poems from northern New Mexico, 1920sWritten for Augment Education
They laid Fidel on the long table in the sala
with his boots on, because Rosa said
his feet had never once been cold at a dance
and she would not start them now.
The Hermanos came down from the morada after dark
and sang the alabados the old way,
no guitar, no fiddle, nothing a man could tap his foot to,
one voice going up alone like smoke from a piñon fire
and the others following when they had found it.
Thirty verses for the Passion. I counted.
I have played behind that man since Taft was President,
and I never knew till that night
what a voice is with nothing underneath it.
His fiddle was on the bench by the door.
Nobody had opened the case. The women
kept their eyes off it the way you keep your eyes
off a horse that has thrown somebody.
My hands sat on my knees like two dogs told to stay.
Toward three the coffee ran out and the candles
leaned over in the heat, and old Trujillo,
who is deaf, began to keep time on the floor
with his cane, slow, on the one and the three,
which is not how an alabado goes.
Nobody stopped him. After a while
I saw that half the room had its feet going.
We put him in the camposanto at first light,
the ground so hard they had built a fire on it the day before.
The priest from Taos said the Latin fast, being cold.
Then it was quiet, and I heard it, the varsoviana,
the one he always played too quick at the end
to watch the old people run to keep up —
not in the air. In me. In the right hand mostly.
Rosa gave me the case to carry home.
It is under my bed. I have not opened it.
In this dry country a fiddle left shut
goes out of tune by itself, a little each night,
the strings letting go one turn at a time,
and I lie there and listen to it do it.

Write a guided analysis of the following text.

The following text is a poem, “Velorio”. It is set in a village in northern New Mexico in the 1920s; a velorio is a wake.

Guiding question: How does the poet use sound and silence to present the speaker’s grief?

Use the guiding question or propose an alternative technical or formal aspect of the text to focus your analysis.

Exemplars and marksSee them with a free account
Question 2 · ENGAL-00194Paper 2 · 25 marks

How, and to what effect, do two works you have studied present people who work for others?

Exemplars and marksSee them with a free account
Question 3 · ENGAL-00046Paper 1 · 20 marks
Stock RouteStock Route, a play from Queensland, 2020sWritten for Augment Education
The back verandah of a homestead, late afternoon. A screen door to the house. A table with a plastic cloth; on it, papers held down by a rock. At the far end of the verandah NEV, in his late seventies, sits in a cane chair facing out over the paddocks, an old felt hat on his knee. He does not speak at any point. DARREN, in his fifties, in work clothes, sits at the table. The screen door bangs and JODIE comes out with two mugs.
JODIEThere’s no milk, so it’s black.
DARRENThere’s milk. It’s in the esky in the laundry. Fridge packed it in Tuesday.
JODIERight.
She puts a mug in front of him. She takes the other to NEV, crouches and holds it out. NEV does not take it. She puts it on the boards beside his chair.
JODIEThat’s there, Dad. It’s hot.
DARRENHe doesn’t have it out here. He has it at the table.
JODIEHe’s not at the table.
DARRENNo.
JODIE sits. She looks at the papers under the rock.
JODIEThat’s it, is it?
DARRENThat’s the offer.
JODIEFrom Pearce.
DARRENFrom Col Pearce’s boy. Col’s in Dalby now. In the home.
JODIEWell, there you go.
DARRENWhat’s that mean?
JODIENothing. It means there you go.
She slides the rock off and reads the top page.
JODIEThat’s not even what the bank said it—
DARRENIt’s what it’s worth with no water on it. Go and have a look at the dam. Go on. You can walk across it.
JODIEI saw the dam. I drove past the dam.
DARRENThen you know.
JODIEIt’s broken before. Remember ninety-one? Dad said—
DARRENDad said a lot of things in ninety-one.
JODIE turns to NEV.
JODIEYou remember ninety-one, Dad. You had us out in the wet at two in the morning pulling calves out of the creek.
NEV does not move.
DARRENDon’t do that.
JODIEDo what?
DARRENAsk him things. Like he’s going to turn round and say, yeah, Jode, I remember, over my dead body.
JODIEHe can hear you.
DARRENI know he can hear me. I’m the one who knows he can hear. He hears me every morning at five when I get him up and every night when I put him down, and in between I do two hundred head on my own, and the books, and the bloody fridge.
Pause.
JODIEI said I’d pay for someone.
DARRENYou said it at Christmas.
JODIEI meant it at Christmas.
DARRENSomeone. Who’s coming out here, Jode? For what you’d pay? We had the backpacker. She lasted nine days. She cried in the ute.
JODIEWe could put on a manager. Lease the back country. Dad could go into Toowoomba, there’s a place, Kerry from work, her mum’s there, it’s lovely, it’s got a garden—
DARRENHe’s got a garden.
He points out past NEV at the paddocks.
DARRENThat’s his garden. Four thousand acres of it. You want to put him in a room with a window, and a garden some bloke does with a leaf blower on Thursdays.
JODIEI want him looked after.
DARRENHe’s looked after.
JODIEBy you.
DARRENYes. By me.
JODIEAnd you want to sell.
DARRENI want to stop.
Silence. NEV’s hand moves on the hat, then settles.
JODIEHe’d never sell. He told me. He told me in that chair. He said they’d have to carry him off it.
DARRENYeah, well.
JODIEWhat does that mean?
DARREN gets up and goes to the end of the verandah. He stands near NEV but looks out at the paddocks, not at him.
DARRENHe rang Col. Before. The March before he went crook. Had Col out here and walked him round the boundary. I drove them. They had a beer on this verandah and shook on a number.
JODIEThat’s not true.
DARRENHe was going to tell you at Christmas. Then he didn’t have the words to.
JODIEYou would say that.
DARRENAsk him, then.
JODIEYou said not to ask him things.
DARRENAsk him.
JODIE gets up. She goes to NEV and crouches by the chair. A long moment.
JODIEDad. Did you have Col Pearce out here?
NEV looks at her. Then he turns his head back to the paddocks.
JODIEDad.
Pause.
JODIEWhat’s that? Is that a yes? Darren, what is that?
DARRENThat’s him looking at the dam.
JODIEHe’s always looking at the dam.
DARRENYeah.
JODIE stays crouched by the chair. DARREN picks up the mug from the boards and holds it out. NEV takes it in both hands.
Distant thunder. None of them looks up.
DARRENThat’ll go round. It always goes round.
JODIEYou don’t know that.
DARRENNo.
NEV drinks. The light goes.

Write a guided analysis of the following text.

The following extract is from the play Stock Route. On a cattle property in rural Queensland during a drought, Darren has looked after his father, Nev, since a stroke left Nev unable to speak. Darren’s sister, Jodie, has driven out from Brisbane.

Guiding question: By what means, and to what effect, is Nev’s silence used in this extract?

Use the guiding question or propose an alternative technical or formal aspect of the text to focus your analysis.

Exemplars and marksSee them with a free account
Question 4 · ENGAL-00199Paper 2 · 25 marks

With reference to two works you have studied, discuss how the writers present an outsider and what the outsider’s position reveals.

Exemplars and marksSee them with a free account
Question 5 · ENGAL-00066Paper 1 · 20 marks
The Sugar TongsBlack and White, a memoir from Hong Kong, 1940sWritten for Augment Education
I keep in my tin box, with my savings book and the photograph from the studio in Nathan Road, a pair of sugar tongs. They are silver, or silver over something else; I have never asked. The arms are made to look like the legs of a bird, and at the ends are a bird’s feet, three toes in front and one behind, so that when the tongs close on a lump of sugar it looks as though the sugar has been caught. They were given to me in March 1947 by Mrs Dorothy Ashworth of Conduit Road, when the family went Home, as a mark, she said, of their appreciation.
In the house on Conduit Road I was the one who carried the tea. At four o’clock: the pot, the hot-water jug, the milk, the cream for Master, who took cream, and the sugar basin with these tongs laid across it. Missee taught me in my first week. ‘One never touches the sugar, Ah Ying,’ she said. ‘Not with fingers.’ I had come from the silk country of Shunde, where I combed up my hair at seventeen, which is how a woman there says she has finished with the idea of a husband, and I had touched a great deal of sugar in my life by then, and silkworms, and the insides of chickens. But I understood her. In that house there was a difference between hands, and it was my work to carry it.
In the January after the surrender the Master and Missee and the two boys were taken with the other British to the camp at Stanley. The morning they went, Missee gave me the silver in a pillowcase. ‘Keep it safe for us, Ah Ying. It will only be a few months.’ I have thought since that she gave it to me because it was heavy, and they had been told to bring only what they could carry. But at the time I thought it was trust, and so it became trust, which is how these things work.
I will not write very much about the three years and eight months. Everyone in Hong Kong has an account, and mine is not worse than most. I went to live with my sworn sister Ah Kam in a cockloft in Wanchai, and I kept the pillowcase under the boards, and on the days when there was no rice we looked at the boards and did not lift them. The tongs I kept apart, sewn into the hem of my jacket, where they lay quite flat. I could not tell you why. There was no sugar in Hong Kong by then. Perhaps I wanted one thing of theirs that I could carry.
In the winter of 1943 Ah Kam was ill with her chest, and the doctor in Johnston Road would come only for military yen. I lifted the boards. I took out the cream jug, which was the smallest piece, and went to see a man in Lockhart Road. The doctor came twice. It is not necessary to say more about Ah Kam, except that she was thirty-four.
In September 1945 Missee came back to Conduit Road. She was very thin, and she had a way, which she kept afterwards, of looking at food on a plate as though she were counting it. I carried the pillowcase up the hill and laid everything out on the dining table, polished. She touched each piece. Then she asked about the cream jug, and I told her that the Japanese had taken it, which was what she expected to hear, and she put her hand on my arm and said, ‘Of course they did. Oh, Ah Ying, we heard such stories about the servants.’ I said nothing. It was true that there had been stories. I unpicked my hem that evening and put the tongs back across the sugar basin, where they belonged, and at four o’clock the next day I carried in the tea.
When they went Home she gave me the tongs and twenty dollars. ‘For your loyalty, Ah Ying,’ she said, ‘and your honesty, which we shall never forget.’ I have thought a good deal since about which of the two she was paying for, and whether twenty dollars was the price of one or of both.
I use the tongs now for the salted plums, which I keep in a jar on the windowsill. It is a foolish sight, an old woman with a pair of silver bird’s feet, picking out one plum at a time, and my neighbour’s daughter laughs at me through the door. But I find I do not like to put my fingers in the jar. I find that I was taught.

Write a guided analysis of the following text.

This is an extract from Black and White, a memoir. The writer worked as an amah, a live-in domestic servant, for a British family in Hong Kong before and after the Japanese occupation of 1941 to 1945.

Guiding question: By what means, and to what effect, does the writer use the sugar tongs to explore her place in the household?

Use the guiding question or propose an alternative technical or formal aspect of the text to focus your analysis.

Exemplars and marksSee them with a free account
Question 6 · ENGAL-00269Paper 2 · 25 marks

Referring to two works you have studied, discuss how the writers present the act of naming people or things.

Exemplars and marksSee them with a free account

Practice all 16 in Augment

Free with an account. Every question has its markscheme, and Augment keeps the ones you got wrong so you can come back to them.

The notes on 3.5 How can literary texts offer multiple perspectives of a single issue, topic or theme?

More questions in Intertextuality: connecting texts

  1. 3.1How do literary texts adhere to and deviate from conventions associated with literary forms?
  2. 3.2How do conventions and systems of reference evolve over time?
  3. 3.3In what ways can diverse literary texts share points of similarity?
  4. 3.5How can literary texts offer multiple perspectives of a single issue, topic or theme?This page
  5. 3.6In what ways can comparison and interpretation be transformative?

Check your answers in Augment

A free account opens all 16 questions on How can literary texts offer multiple perspectives of a single issue, topic or theme? with their markschemes, and keeps a record of what you have marked.