5.2 Governance and human rights questions for IB Digital Society

23 questions on Governance and human rights, written by Augment in the style of IB exam papers. Six of them are below in full, to answer on paper.

  • IB Digital Society
  • Part of 5 HL extension: challenges and interventions
  • HL only

Questions by paper and level

PaperQuestions
Paper 115
Paper 38
Every paper23

Counted on

Questions to try

Written by Augment in the style of IB exams, not past papers. Answer them on paper, then check each one against its markscheme with a free account.

Question 1 · DS-00001Paper 1 · 12 marks

Listening for ceasefire violations

In 2025 the government of Orvania and an armed group in its eastern province agreed a ceasefire. A global challenge in civil conflicts is that ceasefires break down when shelling and shooting go unrecorded and each side blames the other.

One intervention is a network of acoustic sensors installed along the ceasefire line by an international monitoring mission. Each sensor is connected to the internet and records loud sounds. Software classifies each sound, for example as artillery fire or gunfire, and compares the time it reached different sensors to estimate where it came from. Every detection appears on an online map (see Figure 1), which is shared with both sides and the public. Monitors visit some locations to confirm detections.

Online map: a dashed ceasefire line splits a government area from an armed group area; confirmed (filled) and unconfirmed (open) detections near Orlek, Mirel, Tamsk and Basin Road. Panel: this week 214 detections, 61 confirmed, 153 unconfirmed.
Figure 1: The monitoring mission's online map

It is claimed that the sensor network will protect civilians and hold both sides accountable for breaking the ceasefire.

To what extent do you agree with this claim?

12 marks

Question 2 · DS-00229Paper 3 · 30 marks

Early warning of violence between communities

This pre-released statement sets out the real-world nature of a challenge, and of two interventions, from the digital society higher level extension. Candidates should use it to plan and carry out extended inquiries before paper 3.

  • Challenge topic: Governance and human rights

  • Area for inquiry: Conflict, peace and security

As well as the information given here, candidates should consider relevant connections to other digital society concepts, content and contexts. Teachers should explore several scenarios in this context.

About the challenge

Much violence between communities does not begin as war. It often starts locally, when long-standing disputes over land, water, jobs or religious and cultural differences are inflamed by rumors. Digital systems have made this faster: a false claim that members of one community have attacked another can spread through messaging groups and social media across a whole district within hours, before anyone has checked it. Hate speech that portrays a group as dangerous or less than human has come before mass violence in several countries, and peacebuilders have called for early warning systems that spot the signs while there is still time to act.

Early warning is difficult. Warning signs are scattered across thousands of conversations, often in local languages that few technology companies support. The people best placed to notice rising tension are community members themselves, but reporting it can put them in danger. Any system that watches what people say also raises questions about privacy, freedom of expression and who controls the information collected.

This statement introduces two interventions designed to give peacebuilders earlier warning of violence between communities. Their impacts and implications should be evaluated against the six criteria of the HL evaluation framework: equity, acceptability, cost, feasibility, innovation and ethics. In the examination, candidates will be given a source booklet with four sources about one scenario.

About the interventions

Intervention 1: An AI-based social media monitoring tool. The tool uses natural language processing to scan public social media posts written in a district's languages. It gives each post a risk score for inflammatory language and rumors and shows peacebuilding staff a daily dashboard of rising tension by area.

Intervention 2: A community early-warning network. Trained volunteers in each village report incidents, rumors and rising tension by SMS from basic phones. Staff check each report and plot verified reports on a crisis map shared with local peace committees.

About the stakeholders

  • residents of communities affected by tension and violence

  • local peace committees and religious and community leaders

  • peacebuilding organizations and their volunteers

  • police and local government

  • social media and telecommunications companies

Additional terminology

Crisis mapping
Early warning system
False positive
Hate speech
Low-resource language
Natural language processing (NLP)
Peacebuilding
Risk score
Rumor
UN Sustainable Development Goal 16 (Peace, Justice and Strong Institutions)
Verification

Notes

Candidates do not need to study how natural language processing models are built.

Source booklet

Source A: Halvane district

Halvane is a rural district of about 180 000 people, home to two communities that differ in religion and language: Halvani speakers, who are mostly farmers, and Kesh speakers, who are mostly cattle herders. Disputes over grazing land and water have grown as rainfall has become less reliable.

In March last year, a video said to show Kesh herders burning a Halvani farm was shared in messaging groups. It had been filmed in another country years earlier. Within six hours, fights broke out at Halvane's main market: 14 people were injured and 30 stalls were destroyed.

Peace Bridge Forum, a local not-for-profit organization, runs peace committees of elders, religious leaders, women and young people from both communities. It wants to learn of rising tension early enough for the committees to act.

Source B: Peace Bridge Forum's proposals

AI-based monitoring tool

  • Licensed from a technology company for USD 60 000 a year.

  • Scans public posts and public groups on two social media platforms; private messages cannot be read.

  • Gives each post a risk score from 0 to 100; posts scoring over 70 are flagged and reviewed by two staff members.

  • Trained mainly on posts written in Halvani; far fewer texts in Kesh exist online.

Community early-warning network

  • 80 volunteers, 40 from each community, trained over three days.

  • Reports sent by SMS using short codes, for example R (rumor), V (violence), G (armed group seen).

  • Staff phone the volunteer back within two hours to check the report; verified reports appear on the crisis map.

  • Costs about USD 25 000 a year for training, phone credit and two staff members.

Source C: Results of a six-week trial of the monitoring tool

Staff reviewed every post that the tool flagged during the trial. Separately, Kesh-speaking staff found 64 inflammatory posts in Kesh that the tool had not flagged.

Bar chart of posts flagged in the six-week trial. Halvani: 390 inflammatory on review, 130 not inflammatory. Kesh: 95 inflammatory on review, 215 not inflammatory.
Figure 1: Posts flagged by the monitoring tool during the trial, by language

Source D: Views from Halvane

"Last March our committee heard about the fake video only when the market was already burning. Anything that warns us sooner is welcome."

Amina, peace committee member, Kesh community

"Young people post angry things online when cattle trample our crops. That doesn't mean we are planning violence. If Peace Bridge is reading our posts, who else will see what it collects?"

Joseph, youth leader, Halvani community

"Everyone in my village knows I talk to Peace Bridge. If people find out I reported my neighbor's son, I will not be safe."

Grace, volunteer in a pilot of the early-warning network

"We would like daily access to the dashboard so that officers can be sent before trouble starts."

Halvane district police commander

  1. (a)(i)

    Identify two types of data the AI-based monitoring tool could collect from public social media posts.

    2 marks

  2. (a)(ii)

    Outline what is meant by a false positive in the context of the monitoring tool.

    2 marks

  3. (b)(i)

    With reference to Source C, explain two reasons why the monitoring tool was less accurate for posts written in Kesh than for posts written in Halvani.

    4 marks

  4. (b)(ii)

    Explain one way in which the community early-warning network could put its volunteers at risk.

    2 marks

  5. (c)

    Joseph (Source D) is worried about Peace Bridge Forum reading posts written by young people.

    To what extent is it acceptable for a peacebuilding organization to monitor public social media posts without the knowledge of the people who write them?

    8 marks

  6. (d)

    Peace Bridge Forum has to choose between two interventions to address the challenge of preventing violence between the communities of Halvane:

    • Intervention 1: An AI-based social media monitoring tool that scans public posts and shows staff a daily dashboard of rising tension.

    • Intervention 2: A community early-warning network of 80 trained volunteers who report incidents and rumors by SMS to a crisis map.

    Recommend which of the interventions Peace Bridge Forum should choose.

    12 marks

Question 3 · DS-00002Paper 1 · 12 marks

Satellite evidence of destroyed villages

In many civil wars, villages are burned or demolished in remote areas that investigators cannot safely visit, and the forces responsible often deny that the attacks took place.

Clearsight, an international human rights organization, uses an intervention to address this. It buys high-resolution commercial satellite images of conflict regions every few days. An artificial intelligence (AI) model, trained using supervised learning on thousands of labeled images, compares each new image with an older image of the same place and flags buildings that appear to have been destroyed. Analysts check every flagged site, compare it with witness statements and videos posted online, and publish reports that are sent to international courts and United Nations investigators.

It is claimed that this intervention will provide reliable evidence that brings those responsible for attacks on civilians to justice.

To what extent do you agree with this claim?

12 marks

Question 4 · DS-00230Paper 3 · 30 marks

Keeping critical infrastructure safe from cyberattacks

This pre-released statement sets out the real-world nature of a challenge, and of two interventions, from the digital society higher level extension. Candidates should use it to plan and carry out extended inquiries before paper 3.

  • Challenge topic: Governance and human rights

  • Area for inquiry: Conflict, peace and security

As well as the information given here, candidates should consider relevant connections to other digital society concepts, content and contexts. Teachers should explore several scenarios in this context.

About the challenge

Water, electricity, transport and hospital services all depend on digital control systems. Many of these systems were designed decades ago to work in isolation, but they are now linked to office networks and the internet so that engineers can monitor and adjust them from anywhere. This has made them targets. Criminal groups use ransomware to lock an organization's systems until a payment is made, and groups sponsored by states have been found inside other countries' infrastructure networks, where they could cause disruption during a conflict. An attack on an electricity network can cut power to homes, hospitals and water pumps across a whole region, as the 2015 attack on Ukraine's power grid showed when hundreds of thousands of customers lost power for several hours.

Many governments now treat the protection of critical infrastructure as a matter of national security. Yet much of it is run by local public bodies and small companies with limited budgets and few security specialists. Protecting it raises questions about cost, about who is accountable when an attack succeeds, and about how much control should be handed to automated systems.

This statement introduces two interventions designed to protect critical infrastructure from cyberattacks. Their impacts and implications should be evaluated against the six criteria of the HL evaluation framework: equity, acceptability, cost, feasibility, innovation and ethics. In the examination, candidates will be given a source booklet with four sources about one scenario.

About the interventions

Intervention 1: An AI-based anomaly detection system. Sensors on the control network copy all network traffic to a machine learning model, which learns the normal pattern of commands between computers and equipment. It alerts staff to unusual activity and can be set to disconnect automatically any device it judges to be under attack.

Intervention 2: Network segmentation with zero-trust access. The control network is separated from the office network and the internet. All remote access passes through one monitored gateway, and every user and device must prove its identity each time it connects, using hardware security keys for multi-factor authentication.

About the stakeholders

  • residents and businesses that depend on the service

  • engineers and operators who run the infrastructure

  • governments and national cybersecurity agencies

  • technology vendors and security companies

Additional terminology

Air gap
Anomaly detection
Critical infrastructure
Hardware security key
Machine learning
Multi-factor authentication (MFA)
Network segmentation
Operational technology (OT)
Phishing
Ransomware
Remote access
State-sponsored attack
Zero trust

Notes

Candidates do not need to study industrial control protocols or how anomaly detection models are trained.

Source booklet

Source A: Eastmark Power

Eastmark Power is a publicly owned company that distributes electricity to 600 000 customers in a region on the country's eastern border, where relations with the neighboring country are tense. Its 140 substations have no staff on site and are controlled remotely from one control center. Its IT team has six members; none is a security specialist.

In January, an engineer's password was stolen through a phishing email. The attacker used it to log in to the remote-access software on an engineering laptop and opened the circuit breakers at two substations. 23 000 homes lost power for three hours, until engineers drove to the substations and reset them by hand. The national cybersecurity agency believes a state-sponsored group was responsible.

Figure 1 shows the company's current network.

Network diagram. The internet connects to the office network (email, billing and staff computers) and to an engineering laptop with remote-access software. The office network and the laptop each connect directly to the operational network (1 control center, 140 substations).
Figure 1: Eastmark Power's current network

Source B: Details of the proposed interventions

Anomaly detection system

  • USD 180 000 to install and USD 70 000 a year, including a security company that watches alerts 24 hours a day.

  • Needs six weeks to learn normal network traffic before it can raise alerts.

  • Automatic disconnection of devices can be switched on or off.

Segmentation and zero-trust access

  • USD 95 000 for new firewalls, a remote-access gateway and hardware security keys for 120 staff.

  • 18 substations use controllers too old to work behind the gateway; replacing them would cost USD 300 000 over three years.

  • Engineers can reach the control network from home only through the gateway, using their key.

Source C: Email from the operations manager to the board

Our engineers fix most night-time faults from home. If every login needs a key and the gateway, a lost key at 2 a.m. means a two-hour drive to the substation.

I am also worried about letting the AI system disconnect equipment by itself. Last winter's cold snap pushed demand to a record overnight. A system that has never seen that could decide a substation is under attack and cut it off from the control network. In a storm we would then have to send engineers by road to restore power, leaving homes, including people who rely on medical equipment, without electricity for hours. I want a person to make that decision.

Priya Shah, Operations Manager, Eastmark Power

Source D: Advice to energy operators

Reported attacks on electricity and gas operators in the country rose from 12 in 2022 to 37 in 2024. In most successful intrusions, attackers used stolen passwords and remote-access software that could be reached from the internet. Separating networks and requiring multi-factor authentication would have stopped most of them. Operators should report any incident to the agency within 72 hours.

Adapted from an advisory by a national cybersecurity agency, 2025.

  1. (a)(i)

    Identify two signs that an email may be a phishing attempt.

    2 marks

  2. (a)(ii)

    Outline how multi-factor authentication makes it harder for an attacker to log in with a stolen password.

    2 marks

  3. (b)(i)

    With reference to Source A and Figure 1, explain two ways in which Intervention 2 could have prevented or limited the January attack.

    4 marks

  4. (b)(ii)

    Explain why the anomaly detection system needs six weeks to learn normal network traffic before it can raise alerts.

    2 marks

  5. (c)

    Intervention 1 can be set to cut a device off from the control network automatically if it judges that the device is under attack. Priya Shah (Source C) wants a person to make that decision.

    To what extent is it acceptable for an AI-based system to take action on a regional electricity network without a human decision?

    8 marks

  6. (d)

    Eastmark Power has to choose between two interventions to address the challenge of protecting its electricity network from cyberattacks:

    • Intervention 1: An AI-based anomaly detection system on the control network.

    • Intervention 2: Network segmentation with zero-trust access and hardware security keys.

    Recommend which of the interventions Eastmark Power should choose.

    12 marks

Question 5 · DS-00003Paper 1 · 12 marks

Virtual meetings across a divided city

The city of Norvast has been divided between two communities, with different languages and religions, since a civil conflict ended in 2009. Walls and checkpoints still separate many neighborhoods, and most young people have never had a conversation with someone from the other community.

One intervention is run by BridgeSpace, a peacebuilding charity. It has given virtual reality (VR) headsets to 20 youth clubs on both sides of the city. Each week, groups of teenagers from the two communities meet as avatars in a shared virtual space, where they play cooperative games and take part in discussions led by trained facilitators. Speech is translated automatically between the two languages.

It is claimed that BridgeSpace will reduce hostility between the two communities.

To what extent do you agree with this claim?

12 marks

Question 6 · DS-00231Paper 3 · 30 marks

Reuniting families separated by conflict

This pre-released statement sets out the real-world nature of a challenge, and of two interventions, from the digital society higher level extension. Candidates should use it to plan and carry out extended inquiries before paper 3.

  • Challenge topic: Governance and human rights

  • Area for inquiry: Conflict, peace and security

As well as the information given here, candidates should consider relevant connections to other digital society concepts, content and contexts. Teachers should explore several scenarios in this context.

About the challenge

Wars and civil conflicts force millions of people from their homes. In the rush to escape, families are often separated: parents and children flee in different directions, phones and documents are lost, and people end up in different camps, towns or countries. Many remain internally displaced within their own country; others become refugees. Not knowing whether a relative is alive causes lasting distress, and unaccompanied children are at particular risk of exploitation.

Humanitarian organizations have run family-tracing services since the nineteenth century, using paper records, radio messages and lists of names. Digital systems now promise much faster searches across large numbers of people. However, information about displaced people is highly sensitive. If it is leaked, hacked or handed over, it can reveal where members of a persecuted group are living, or be used to target people believed to support one side of a conflict. Tracing services must therefore balance speed against the principle of "do no harm".

This statement introduces two interventions designed to reunite families separated by conflict. Their impacts and implications should be evaluated against the six criteria of the HL evaluation framework: equity, acceptability, cost, feasibility, innovation and ethics. In the examination, candidates will be given a source booklet with four sources about one scenario.

About the interventions

Intervention 1: Facial recognition photo matching. Displaced people and searching relatives provide photographs, which are stored in a database. An AI system compares faces and suggests possible matches for caseworkers to check.

Intervention 2: A shared tracing database with name matching. Caseworkers record names, ages, home villages and relatives' names in a database shared by several aid agencies. A fuzzy-matching algorithm suggests possible matches, even when names are spelled differently.

About the stakeholders

  • people separated from their relatives, including unaccompanied children

  • humanitarian organizations and their caseworkers

  • governments and armed groups in the conflict area

  • technology companies that provide software and data storage

Additional terminology

Biometric data
Consent
Data minimization
Data protection
Do no harm
Facial recognition
False match
Fuzzy matching
Internally displaced person (IDP)
Refugee
Transliteration
Unaccompanied child

Notes

Candidates do not need to study how facial recognition models are trained.

Source booklet

Source A: Corda Aid's tracing service in Merel

Fighting in Merel province ended in a ceasefire last year. About 230 000 people were displaced to 14 camps and nearby towns. Corda Aid, an international humanitarian organization, has 4 800 open tracing requests, including 1 100 from or about unaccompanied children.

Caseworkers currently fill in paper forms and phone other agencies to compare lists. A request takes seven months on average to resolve. Most people in Merel speak Tavic, and names are written in both the Tavic and the Latin alphabet, often with different spellings.

Source B: Details of the two proposals

Facial recognition photo matching

  • Photos taken at camp registration and supplied by searching families.

  • Software and cloud storage donated free for three years by a technology company based in another country.

  • Each search takes seconds; a caseworker interviews both sides before any match is confirmed.

Shared tracing database

  • Shared with three other aid agencies working in Merel.

  • Stored on Corda Aid's servers in the capital city.

  • Needs 25 more trained caseworkers, costing USD 400 000 a year.

Source C: Results of a trial on past cases

Both tools were tested on 500 past cases in which the family had already been reunited.

Facial recognition

Name matching

Correct matches suggested (out of 500)

412

318

Wrong matches suggested

37

96

Correct matches for children under 10 (out of 120)

61

83

Source D: Views on the proposals

"We left at night with nothing. I have no photo of my son. All I can give them is his name and the name of our village."

Hana, mother searching for her 8-year-old son

"Families come back every week to ask if there is news. With paper forms I can only check a few names an hour."

Yusuf, Corda Aid caseworker

"The ministry requests access to the tracing database so that former fighters can be identified among the displaced population."

Letter from the Ministry of the Interior to Corda Aid

"I won't let them photograph my face. Who knows who will see it in five years?"

Daniel, 19, living in a camp

  1. (a)(i)

    Identify two items of data, other than a photograph, that could help match a missing person with their family.

    2 marks

  2. (a)(ii)

    Outline why a photograph of a person's face used for facial recognition is classed as biometric data.

    2 marks

  3. (b)(i)

    With reference to Source C, explain two reasons why name matching found more correct matches than facial recognition for children under 10.

    4 marks

  4. (b)(ii)

    Explain one reason why the name-matching algorithm needs to use fuzzy matching rather than looking for exact matches.

    2 marks

  5. (c)

    Corda Aid has received a letter from the Ministry of the Interior (Source D).

    To what extent is it acceptable for a humanitarian organization to collect biometric data from people displaced by conflict?

    8 marks

  6. (d)

    Corda Aid has to choose between two interventions to address the challenge of reuniting families separated by the conflict in Merel:

    • Intervention 1: Facial recognition matching of photographs of displaced people and their relatives.

    • Intervention 2: A tracing database shared with other aid agencies, using fuzzy name matching.

    Recommend which of the interventions Corda Aid should choose.

    12 marks

Practice all 23 in Augment

Free with an account. Every question has its markscheme, and Augment keeps the ones you got wrong so you can come back to them.

The notes on 5.2 Governance and human rights

More questions in HL extension: challenges and interventions

  1. 5.1Global well-being
  2. 5.2Governance and human rightsThis page
  3. 5.3Sustainable development

Check your answers in Augment

A free account opens all 23 questions on Governance and human rights with their markschemes, and keeps a record of what you have marked.